Cute gelateria with lots of fun flavors. We got the brownie batter flavor and wished we’d tried more. Next time I’d go back for the toffee coffee. They have some seating inside and even a window to order from - just press the bell!Vegetarian options: They have vegan sorbet too
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Cortney OE
It was raining, i was walking & had been for quite some time, 5 hrs away from home, (car issues) phone was dying trying to book a last minute motel for that evening. I seen an ice cream sign ☺️, went inside, wonderful smell & all looked very tasty, As My assumption was right! But not only was my gelato & lBlack raspberry sherbet & cherry cheesecake ice cream very delicious ?But everyone working so friendly & nice props to the young gentleman server whom was very welcoming with his positive energetic vibes (allowed me to sit in there for over an hour even after I ate all my ice cream. as i was able to get a charge & make my reservations) & wished me a great evening as i left (has he had done so to everyone walking in & out the door )Keep putting out that positivity & kindness & trust the universe will bring it back to you tenfold ❣️ Thank you all again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brittany D
First and foremost the waffle cone was really good. The waffle cones are homemade and I definitely appreciate a good homemade waffle cone. The gelato was good I got the cookies and cream and vanilla. It’s very nice inside. It’s gives off a retro vibe in a way.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Waffle Cone
Stephania Ray
Absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Russell McMullan
OMG! Their Gelato is so good! I got their brownie sundae with peanut butter Gelato (pictured). The warm brownie was thick and rich, and the fresh whipped cream was light and sweet. It was all tied together with their delicious hot fudge! My wife got their Black Forrest Gelato (chocolate with cherries and dark chocolate ganache). The Gelato is so fresh and creamy, yum!The staff were very friendly and they let us sample a few flavors so that we could decide what we wanted. The Banana Split Company is a great place to stop for a sweet treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Brian S.
We live close by and on a somewhat regular basis we walk over and get things. We always get a pup cup for our dog, who is highly intelligent and absolutely knows what it means when we walk down this street! As we stand at the window waiting for our orders to be ready, she starts getting more and more excited until she can't sit still anymore. Putting it on the sidewalk and watching her get whipped cream all over her face is one of the greatest joys in life.
Josh Clapper
Loved the espresso and white chocolate flavors. Nice atmosphere with lots of seating, in central Staunton - can’t wait to come back and try some
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Robin Richard
This is, hands down, the best ice cream shop I have ever tried. And I have tried a lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bobby S.
The best ice cream spot in Staunton hands down. Delicious milkshakes and seasonally the hot chocolate is the best I've had. Yummy!
Nathan A.
Super tasty ice cream and friendly, prompt service in a beautifully old-fashioned shop. Don't sleep on the apple pie ice cream when it's in season -- it's the best such flavor I've had in years. I also like that the gelato cups are biodegradable!
So, I had just had a big lunch before I walked by this shop. One look at the flavors and I had to go inside to see it for myself. The decor was like a 50's ice cream parlor. The case had so many amazing fluffy gelato and sorbets flavors to choose from. The staff were friendly enough to let us try as many flavors as it took until we chose the right flavor. I will add this into the rotation of stops when visiting Staunton. Fair prices and amazing flavors!
Craig F.
Excellent ice cream. Best Butter Pecan ice cream I have ever tasted. Service is very good.Located downtown. Great for kids. Treat yourself.
Kate V.
Clean with friendly staff and great gelato. Had a bad experience down the street and decided to give this place a try. Highly recommend
Kasey DiSessa
Omg, delicious! The icecream was soooo tasty, every flavor we got. I love that they tell you where their ingredients are from—mostly local and LOVEEE that the spoons and cups are biodegradable! I’ve never seen an ice cream shop do that and so appreciate it.
Cute gelateria with lots of fun flavors. We got the brownie batter flavor and wished we’d tried more. Next time I’d go back for the toffee coffee. They have some seating inside and even a window to order from - just press the bell!Vegetarian options: They have vegan sorbet too
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
It was raining, i was walking & had been for quite some time, 5 hrs away from home, (car issues) phone was dying trying to book a last minute motel for that evening. I seen an ice cream sign ☺️, went inside, wonderful smell & all looked very tasty, As My assumption was right! But not only was my gelato & lBlack raspberry sherbet & cherry cheesecake ice cream very delicious ?But everyone working so friendly & nice props to the young gentleman server whom was very welcoming with his positive energetic vibes (allowed me to sit in there for over an hour even after I ate all my ice cream. as i was able to get a charge & make my reservations) & wished me a great evening as i left (has he had done so to everyone walking in & out the door )Keep putting out that positivity & kindness & trust the universe will bring it back to you tenfold ❣️ Thank you all again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First and foremost the waffle cone was really good. The waffle cones are homemade and I definitely appreciate a good homemade waffle cone. The gelato was good I got the cookies and cream and vanilla. It’s very nice inside. It’s gives off a retro vibe in a way.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Waffle Cone
Absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
OMG! Their Gelato is so good! I got their brownie sundae with peanut butter Gelato (pictured). The warm brownie was thick and rich, and the fresh whipped cream was light and sweet. It was all tied together with their delicious hot fudge! My wife got their Black Forrest Gelato (chocolate with cherries and dark chocolate ganache). The Gelato is so fresh and creamy, yum!The staff were very friendly and they let us sample a few flavors so that we could decide what we wanted. The Banana Split Company is a great place to stop for a sweet treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
We live close by and on a somewhat regular basis we walk over and get things. We always get a pup cup for our dog, who is highly intelligent and absolutely knows what it means when we walk down this street! As we stand at the window waiting for our orders to be ready, she starts getting more and more excited until she can't sit still anymore. Putting it on the sidewalk and watching her get whipped cream all over her face is one of the greatest joys in life.
Loved the espresso and white chocolate flavors. Nice atmosphere with lots of seating, in central Staunton - can’t wait to come back and try some
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
This is, hands down, the best ice cream shop I have ever tried. And I have tried a lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best ice cream spot in Staunton hands down. Delicious milkshakes and seasonally the hot chocolate is the best I've had. Yummy!
Super tasty ice cream and friendly, prompt service in a beautifully old-fashioned shop. Don't sleep on the apple pie ice cream when it's in season -- it's the best such flavor I've had in years. I also like that the gelato cups are biodegradable!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great variety of flavors, and so good!
So, I had just had a big lunch before I walked by this shop. One look at the flavors and I had to go inside to see it for myself. The decor was like a 50's ice cream parlor. The case had so many amazing fluffy gelato and sorbets flavors to choose from. The staff were friendly enough to let us try as many flavors as it took until we chose the right flavor. I will add this into the rotation of stops when visiting Staunton. Fair prices and amazing flavors!
Excellent ice cream. Best Butter Pecan ice cream I have ever tasted. Service is very good.Located downtown. Great for kids. Treat yourself.
Clean with friendly staff and great gelato. Had a bad experience down the street and decided to give this place a try. Highly recommend
Omg, delicious! The icecream was soooo tasty, every flavor we got. I love that they tell you where their ingredients are from—mostly local and LOVEEE that the spoons and cups are biodegradable! I’ve never seen an ice cream shop do that and so appreciate it.