I have heard rave reviews about Ted's for the last ten years I have lived in the area, but have never tried them. Sadly, Ted's did not live up to the hype. I ordered my go-to pie, Large Pepperoni. I was disappointed that their large is most places medium. The pie itself was cooked well, but the sauce tasted bland (like most jarred sauces.) The pepperoni was tastless and rubbery. The saving grace was the plentiful amount of cheese. Having eaten many pizzas in my day, both from east coast and west, I hoped for the best and nearly got the worst.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
David Graham
This place is a waste of money people go somewhere else You're better off by Tony's pizza and making it yourself Does this place screws you over and has no flavorDietary restrictions: This place is a rip-off
Best pizza ever, been getting pizzas here for 40 plus years
Stephany Blanchard
Went 50 minutes before closing and they said they weren't taking any new orders. Just close at 8 if you want to leave at 8.
Aric Young II
They're doe's way too thick and came apart and layers all I could taste was dough hardly any sauce and the pepperoni tasted really funky the only thing I could taste really was the dough it was insanely thick with no pizza toppings also the taste was just terrible in general all around and the bottom of the pizza was kind of burnt a little on edges but irregardless I don't think it would have affected how bad the pizza was
Josh Blase
Pizza just wasn't that good. No spices. The place and people were super nice... but unfortunately just wasn't great pizza
As always they're pizza is amazing, make sure to call ahead and order for your specific time as they get slammed due to being soo darn good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J B.
Local legend. Pizza is really tasty. The pies are on the smaller size so if you are starving, be aware. The pepperoni on their pies are so good- the kind that curl up and get crispy. This place is always busy, and the staff are great, very local.
Renie L.
I know the Ted's recipe was left there! So many things have been lost in the "Ted's Pizza", it not worth the time or the money anymore. I remember when we would NEVER get pizza any place else!! Red and green peppers????
Heuserkamph Engel
The staff was great. Very friendly. But that pizza was barely edible. The dough was uncooked in the middle, there was barely any sauce, the cheese and sauce tasted like nothing, and a large pizza was barely what I would call a medium. If I'm being honest, it tasted like a mama mia's frozen pizza. And can someone explain why they cut pizza into rectangular pieces?
John Doeherty
FYI: I grew up in Rutland, so I remember Teds in the 70's. But today....seriously? Who on Earth could legitimately post 4 and 5 stars for a dry (what seems like preprepared) crust so bland that it was tasteless. Have these reviewers never eaten a decent pizza before??? A thick layer of tasty pizza sauce would have helped, but when I lifted the cheese, the sauce was so thin it looked like it had been air brushed on. The cheese? Tasteless. Only the pepperoni was decent. I'm sorry to have to say that this was possibly THE WORST pizza I've ever eaten...and most importantly of all, THIS OPINION IS SHARED UNANIMOUSLY BY SIX OTHER PEOPLE WHO ATE THE SAME PIZZA, all of whom encouraged me to write this review. All I have left are my memories of what once was... Sigh.
Pizza was overpriced and barley cooked. Take your money elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best pizza around. Love the people. Try the sausage, meatballs and peppers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing as always - wish you guys would deliver to England!!! 2 large pizzas between 3…didn’t last long.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Sausage Ham and Meatball Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Cracker crust sweet sauce and. Ezzo cupping Pepperoni's ...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
I have heard rave reviews about Ted's for the last ten years I have lived in the area, but have never tried them. Sadly, Ted's did not live up to the hype. I ordered my go-to pie, Large Pepperoni. I was disappointed that their large is most places medium. The pie itself was cooked well, but the sauce tasted bland (like most jarred sauces.) The pepperoni was tastless and rubbery. The saving grace was the plentiful amount of cheese. Having eaten many pizzas in my day, both from east coast and west, I hoped for the best and nearly got the worst.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
This place is a waste of money people go somewhere else You're better off by Tony's pizza and making it yourself Does this place screws you over and has no flavorDietary restrictions: This place is a rip-off
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Ted's Pizza Rutland Vermont
Best pizza ever, been getting pizzas here for 40 plus years
Went 50 minutes before closing and they said they weren't taking any new orders. Just close at 8 if you want to leave at 8.
They're doe's way too thick and came apart and layers all I could taste was dough hardly any sauce and the pepperoni tasted really funky the only thing I could taste really was the dough it was insanely thick with no pizza toppings also the taste was just terrible in general all around and the bottom of the pizza was kind of burnt a little on edges but irregardless I don't think it would have affected how bad the pizza was
Pizza just wasn't that good. No spices. The place and people were super nice... but unfortunately just wasn't great pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
As always they're pizza is amazing, make sure to call ahead and order for your specific time as they get slammed due to being soo darn good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Local legend. Pizza is really tasty. The pies are on the smaller size so if you are starving, be aware. The pepperoni on their pies are so good- the kind that curl up and get crispy. This place is always busy, and the staff are great, very local.
I know the Ted's recipe was left there! So many things have been lost in the "Ted's Pizza", it not worth the time or the money anymore. I remember when we would NEVER get pizza any place else!! Red and green peppers????
The staff was great. Very friendly. But that pizza was barely edible. The dough was uncooked in the middle, there was barely any sauce, the cheese and sauce tasted like nothing, and a large pizza was barely what I would call a medium. If I'm being honest, it tasted like a mama mia's frozen pizza. And can someone explain why they cut pizza into rectangular pieces?
FYI: I grew up in Rutland, so I remember Teds in the 70's. But today....seriously? Who on Earth could legitimately post 4 and 5 stars for a dry (what seems like preprepared) crust so bland that it was tasteless. Have these reviewers never eaten a decent pizza before??? A thick layer of tasty pizza sauce would have helped, but when I lifted the cheese, the sauce was so thin it looked like it had been air brushed on. The cheese? Tasteless. Only the pepperoni was decent. I'm sorry to have to say that this was possibly THE WORST pizza I've ever eaten...and most importantly of all, THIS OPINION IS SHARED UNANIMOUSLY BY SIX OTHER PEOPLE WHO ATE THE SAME PIZZA, all of whom encouraged me to write this review. All I have left are my memories of what once was... Sigh.