The atmosphere of the place is very good, the tables outside are very enjoyable on a sunny day, however, the people who served us were not very friendly, in a hurry to take the orders and get us moving fast. The coffee was ok and the food order came out of the kitchen wrong and took a long time. The bathroom was very dirty, I would not recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Katie Kwon
Atmosphere is good like a vintage cafe. But even if there was 4 staffs working they ignored us for few minutes to do busy work such as putting stickers on the cups. And it took more than 20 minutes to get my drink. The coffee was very mediocre the latte was very sour and weakly brewed.
Great place for a coffee and pastry on a Sunday morning on the island. Almond croissant was great, but the raspberry oat bar was the bomb!!Parking: Ease of parking, just drove in and there were plenty of spots in the lot as well as on the street.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pastries
Kristen Spitzer
I don’t love leaving bad reviews but this experience was so frustrating I feel like I need to say something.At first our experience here was good. The building is beautiful, the inside is very cute and the woman who took our order was nice enough. I ordered my daughter the avocado toast and an apple juice. They didn’t have what I had originally wanted, which was no problem, that happens sometimes. So instead I ordered the panini and a cup of tea. The total came to around $40 ish. My daughter’s food came out quickly. Then I waited. And waited. After about 20 minutes I got up to check on my order. I was told that it was all good and that it would be right out. About 10 minutes later I checked on things again, they apologized and made my tea. When I went up to get my tea I was told that I hadn’t ordered a panini. When I told them that I had in fact ordered food and paid for it their attitude totally changed. They became very rude and I was being treated as if I was trying to scam them or something. I then had to order and pay for a second sandwich, which I had to have to go at this point.I understand that mistakes happen or things get forgotten. It’s frustrating but I would have been ok with it. But the way that I was made to feel as if I was in the wrong or that I was trying to scam someone was so unprofessional and hurtful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ariel Motaghedi Alfaro
The coffee is GOOD, like, really good. We had some breakfast here too and it was delicious, although, if you’re looking for something more decadent you might want to find another place to eat. They have avo toast, breakfast sandwiches, pastries etc. I had a caramel latte and it was so tasty, I would recommend a cup of coffee here before taking a walk around the marina or into the Main Street area.Dietary restrictions: Substitutions are welcome for dietary restrictionsParking: Street parking, adjacent lot and small lot reserved for customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Avocado
sanchit gupta
I was traveling to Bainbridge when I heard about Pegasus Coffee shop and had to try it. There was a large crowd with lines forming to order (a good sign for the quality of the food). I ordered a couple of coffees and avocado toasts. The coffees were really good but I felt the toasts were a little expensive for what we were given. The toasts were definitely tasty.
Great coffee drinks and pastries. It can get a little crowded. Luckily they have outdoor seating.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pastries, Scone
Pooja Chaudhary
TLDR; coffee is awful, food is ok.We came in with high expectations, but somehow were let down by the food and drinks here. The cappuccinos were incredibly bitter and acidic- no amount of sugar could fix it. The avocado toast was alright (the avocado tasted a bit old) and the egg bacon provolone breakfast sandwich wasn’t any better.I can’t for the life of me figure out how a place with such good ratings turned out to be a let down.On the other hand, it is a really nice cafe atmosphere-wise.
Super cute coffee shop with great drinks. Both their house brewed coffee and their lattes were extremely satisfying on a misty afternoon.Only disappointing thing was that they were out of their iconic coffee sleeves- which I collect.@pegasus coffee house if you see this please mail me one!!Vegetarian options: Plenty of plant based milk options!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Drip Coffee, Drip
Rakhshanda Saif
Overrated, not enough seating area, too long of a wait.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Gilberto Lobaton
Love this place!!
Thomas Hughes
Overpriced like everything else in the area. The shallow coffee cup overcooled the coffee. No warmup.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hiram Banks
Great place for evening coffee and a cookie on the weekends. Excellent whole bean coffee to take home.
A calm and pretty little coffee shop out there.
The atmosphere of the place is very good, the tables outside are very enjoyable on a sunny day, however, the people who served us were not very friendly, in a hurry to take the orders and get us moving fast. The coffee was ok and the food order came out of the kitchen wrong and took a long time. The bathroom was very dirty, I would not recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Atmosphere is good like a vintage cafe. But even if there was 4 staffs working they ignored us for few minutes to do busy work such as putting stickers on the cups. And it took more than 20 minutes to get my drink. The coffee was very mediocre the latte was very sour and weakly brewed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cute, cute spot. Cappuccino tastes like burnt tires. Nice looking pastries, lovely outdoor patio, clean restroom, easy parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great place for a coffee and pastry on a Sunday morning on the island. Almond croissant was great, but the raspberry oat bar was the bomb!!Parking: Ease of parking, just drove in and there were plenty of spots in the lot as well as on the street.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pastries
I don’t love leaving bad reviews but this experience was so frustrating I feel like I need to say something.At first our experience here was good. The building is beautiful, the inside is very cute and the woman who took our order was nice enough. I ordered my daughter the avocado toast and an apple juice. They didn’t have what I had originally wanted, which was no problem, that happens sometimes. So instead I ordered the panini and a cup of tea. The total came to around $40 ish. My daughter’s food came out quickly. Then I waited. And waited. After about 20 minutes I got up to check on my order. I was told that it was all good and that it would be right out. About 10 minutes later I checked on things again, they apologized and made my tea. When I went up to get my tea I was told that I hadn’t ordered a panini. When I told them that I had in fact ordered food and paid for it their attitude totally changed. They became very rude and I was being treated as if I was trying to scam them or something. I then had to order and pay for a second sandwich, which I had to have to go at this point.I understand that mistakes happen or things get forgotten. It’s frustrating but I would have been ok with it. But the way that I was made to feel as if I was in the wrong or that I was trying to scam someone was so unprofessional and hurtful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 1
The coffee is GOOD, like, really good. We had some breakfast here too and it was delicious, although, if you’re looking for something more decadent you might want to find another place to eat. They have avo toast, breakfast sandwiches, pastries etc. I had a caramel latte and it was so tasty, I would recommend a cup of coffee here before taking a walk around the marina or into the Main Street area.Dietary restrictions: Substitutions are welcome for dietary restrictionsParking: Street parking, adjacent lot and small lot reserved for customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Avocado
I was traveling to Bainbridge when I heard about Pegasus Coffee shop and had to try it. There was a large crowd with lines forming to order (a good sign for the quality of the food). I ordered a couple of coffees and avocado toasts. The coffees were really good but I felt the toasts were a little expensive for what we were given. The toasts were definitely tasty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Coffee Beans, Avocado, Drip, Lox
Great coffee drinks and pastries. It can get a little crowded. Luckily they have outdoor seating.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pastries, Scone
TLDR; coffee is awful, food is ok.We came in with high expectations, but somehow were let down by the food and drinks here. The cappuccinos were incredibly bitter and acidic- no amount of sugar could fix it. The avocado toast was alright (the avocado tasted a bit old) and the egg bacon provolone breakfast sandwich wasn’t any better.I can’t for the life of me figure out how a place with such good ratings turned out to be a let down.On the other hand, it is a really nice cafe atmosphere-wise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Super cute coffee shop with great drinks. Both their house brewed coffee and their lattes were extremely satisfying on a misty afternoon.Only disappointing thing was that they were out of their iconic coffee sleeves- which I collect.@pegasus coffee house if you see this please mail me one!!Vegetarian options: Plenty of plant based milk options!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Drip Coffee, Drip
Overrated, not enough seating area, too long of a wait.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Love this place!!
Overpriced like everything else in the area. The shallow coffee cup overcooled the coffee. No warmup.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for evening coffee and a cookie on the weekends. Excellent whole bean coffee to take home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pastries, Drip