My god. This is the best pie in the county, in the state, maybe the world. It's magic. You've gotta plan ahead a little and order online, or keep an eye on the Instagram in case there's something available last-minute, but holy moly is it worthwhile.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina Bonholzer
This is an updated review.My previous review was for a banana cream pie that was actually bought by a friend. The 4 of us shared the pie and although the pie was beautiful it didn't live up to our expectations.Today we picked up our apple pie with a cinnamon roll crust. We brought it home and we had our same friends over to sample it.The pie was once again beautiful. I knew it would be a winner before I even cut it. It did not disappointThe crust was very good and loved the sugar sprinkles. The cinnamon roll crust was perfect. There were a lot of apples and they were sliced and placed perfectly. The cinnamon sauce was wonderful. It was worth the price. If we lived closer I would definitely splurge for this pie on special occasions.On a personal note to Shannon. There was never any doubt that you put your heart and soul into each pie you make. You said your banana cream pie was one of your best selling pies and I'm sure it is. It just wasn't for us. But your Apple Pie is fantastic and is deserving of 5 stars.Thanks for responding so quickly to my post.I have to say we were very disappointed with our banana cream pie. I don't mind spending 55 for a pie but for that price it needs to be outstanding. We waited over a month for this pie and we drove over 45 min to pick it up.The pie was beautiful. We invited our friends over for pie. All 4 of us said the same thing. We were all disappointed. It was overly sweet. Hardly any bananas. I think we each got 2 little chunks. The crust was thick which made it hard to cut and was not flakey at all.I also feel like a reminder should be sent out to the customer the day before to remind them to pick ip their pie. The wait time is so far out that some people may forget. It would be a shame to forget to pick up your pie when they're so expensive.All the reviews are for 5 stars. There were no 3 or 4 star reviews soWe were expecting this awesome pie. It was so disappointing.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexandra Bolin
Best pie i have ever had in my life. I’ve tried apple, apple cinnamon roll, key lime, coconut cream, berry, pumpkin and lemon and they are all ? ? ?. Keep trying to order more but she’s always sold old because these pies are amazing!! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Apple Pie, Lemon Meringue, Lemon Raspberry Cream, Blackberry, Lemon Cream, Cinnamon Roll Apple, Strawberry Rhubarb
Ryan Bailey
Totally worth the wait!! This cake-eater has been converted to a pie-eater! Picked up the Cinnamon Roll Apple Pie yesterday... half of it is gone already. I spoiled my dinner and I didn't care. It tasted so good I didn't want the taste to end! No crumb went to waste on my plate and seconds were a must. The TLC that was put into this pie was so evident. Thank you, thank you! Take a bow. Brava!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll Apple
Miles Webb
Decided to try one of her pies, ordered one of my favorite pies, Cherry. It was delicious. Looking forward to ordering another pie soon, probably key lime or pecan.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leilani B.
Such a delightful treat! I usually skip the crust, but this crust is amazing! I wish Shannon over-the-top success.
Julie H.
Shannon's pies are absolutely amazing! By far and away our favorite pies. Not only do they taste great, but are beautiful as well. We've ordered several times and every time someone new tries them, they want her information. She also makes delicious cookies! I highly recommend Rumbly In My Tumbly Pie Co.
Carol Olson
I purchased two pies for Thanksgiving and they were both amazing. The Apple Berry Crumb was a perfect mix of sweet and sour and the Chocolate Cream was so creamy. I'll get their pies again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erica H.
The best pie! We've tried a few different flavors, and the Apple Berry Crumb is my favorite with Key Lime a close second, but really EVERYTHING is fabulous! Just be sure to plan ahead and order in advance.
Sam Francisco
These pies will change your life - full stop. The balance of flavors and care that is put into every single pie is unmatched!
Just brought home a peach crumble pie. Absolutely delicious. Love this place, we're working our way thru the whole pie menu. The Banana Dulce is one of our favorites.
Lauren Bopp
My husband has been asking me to try and recreate his great grandmas peach pie for over 10 years. No one in his family had her recipe and I never got to try it before she passed. I asked Shannon to make me a peach crisp pie to surprise him and pray to his great grandma it was closer than all my attempts. Let me tell you she nailed it! He almost cried over this peach pie from Rumbly in my Tumbly. Worth every single penny. She’s great grandma good!
Diana Nguyen
I’ve ordered at least 10 pies or more from Shannon since she started her pie business, whether it was for my family, for the holidays, or as a special surprise for a loved one, one thing holds true & true, her pies are the best! They’re THE best because it’s no secret she uses high quality ingredients, has the most perfect crumble topping and/or that flakey buttery pie crust that she nails, but every bite we take warms our soul because she bakes with love. My favorite is the apple berry crumble pie, second favorite is peach crumble, but my husband loves the cherry pie! And my favorite holiday seasonal offering is the Nantucket crustless cranberry pie!! The creamy pies rhyme with dreamy and they’re also delicious! I’m embarrassed to admit I’ve tried too many flavors but sometimes you feel like you won the lotto when you score one of her pies! Anyways I’ve tried breaking up with Rumbly in my Tumbly many times, usually after the New Years but something keeps pulling me back …. ?
Adam Frantz
She made such a wonderful lemon meringue pie for my wife’s birthday. It was hard to find a place who did lemon meringue. My wife was over the moon about it and said this will have to be our new pie place! Super convenient, well priced, and delicious!
Gianna Galle
I cannot say enough how incredibly delicious these pies are. The crusts are the flakey, the cream fillings decadent, and the fruit pies perfectly sweet. Our family loves the lemon raspberry, egg nog, and dulce banana best of all. You can’t go wrong!!!
My god. This is the best pie in the county, in the state, maybe the world. It's magic. You've gotta plan ahead a little and order online, or keep an eye on the Instagram in case there's something available last-minute, but holy moly is it worthwhile.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is an updated review.My previous review was for a banana cream pie that was actually bought by a friend. The 4 of us shared the pie and although the pie was beautiful it didn't live up to our expectations.Today we picked up our apple pie with a cinnamon roll crust. We brought it home and we had our same friends over to sample it.The pie was once again beautiful. I knew it would be a winner before I even cut it. It did not disappointThe crust was very good and loved the sugar sprinkles. The cinnamon roll crust was perfect. There were a lot of apples and they were sliced and placed perfectly. The cinnamon sauce was wonderful. It was worth the price. If we lived closer I would definitely splurge for this pie on special occasions.On a personal note to Shannon. There was never any doubt that you put your heart and soul into each pie you make. You said your banana cream pie was one of your best selling pies and I'm sure it is. It just wasn't for us. But your Apple Pie is fantastic and is deserving of 5 stars.Thanks for responding so quickly to my post.I have to say we were very disappointed with our banana cream pie. I don't mind spending 55 for a pie but for that price it needs to be outstanding. We waited over a month for this pie and we drove over 45 min to pick it up.The pie was beautiful. We invited our friends over for pie. All 4 of us said the same thing. We were all disappointed. It was overly sweet. Hardly any bananas. I think we each got 2 little chunks. The crust was thick which made it hard to cut and was not flakey at all.I also feel like a reminder should be sent out to the customer the day before to remind them to pick ip their pie. The wait time is so far out that some people may forget. It would be a shame to forget to pick up your pie when they're so expensive.All the reviews are for 5 stars. There were no 3 or 4 star reviews soWe were expecting this awesome pie. It was so disappointing.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pie i have ever had in my life. I’ve tried apple, apple cinnamon roll, key lime, coconut cream, berry, pumpkin and lemon and they are all ? ? ?. Keep trying to order more but she’s always sold old because these pies are amazing!! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Apple Pie, Lemon Meringue, Lemon Raspberry Cream, Blackberry, Lemon Cream, Cinnamon Roll Apple, Strawberry Rhubarb
Totally worth the wait!! This cake-eater has been converted to a pie-eater! Picked up the Cinnamon Roll Apple Pie yesterday... half of it is gone already. I spoiled my dinner and I didn't care. It tasted so good I didn't want the taste to end! No crumb went to waste on my plate and seconds were a must. The TLC that was put into this pie was so evident. Thank you, thank you! Take a bow. Brava!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll Apple
Decided to try one of her pies, ordered one of my favorite pies, Cherry. It was delicious. Looking forward to ordering another pie soon, probably key lime or pecan.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a delightful treat! I usually skip the crust, but this crust is amazing! I wish Shannon over-the-top success.
Shannon's pies are absolutely amazing! By far and away our favorite pies. Not only do they taste great, but are beautiful as well. We've ordered several times and every time someone new tries them, they want her information. She also makes delicious cookies! I highly recommend Rumbly In My Tumbly Pie Co.
I purchased two pies for Thanksgiving and they were both amazing. The Apple Berry Crumb was a perfect mix of sweet and sour and the Chocolate Cream was so creamy. I'll get their pies again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pie! We've tried a few different flavors, and the Apple Berry Crumb is my favorite with Key Lime a close second, but really EVERYTHING is fabulous! Just be sure to plan ahead and order in advance.
These pies will change your life - full stop. The balance of flavors and care that is put into every single pie is unmatched!
Restaurantji Recommends
Just brought home a peach crumble pie. Absolutely delicious. Love this place, we're working our way thru the whole pie menu. The Banana Dulce is one of our favorites.
My husband has been asking me to try and recreate his great grandmas peach pie for over 10 years. No one in his family had her recipe and I never got to try it before she passed. I asked Shannon to make me a peach crisp pie to surprise him and pray to his great grandma it was closer than all my attempts. Let me tell you she nailed it! He almost cried over this peach pie from Rumbly in my Tumbly. Worth every single penny. She’s great grandma good!
I’ve ordered at least 10 pies or more from Shannon since she started her pie business, whether it was for my family, for the holidays, or as a special surprise for a loved one, one thing holds true & true, her pies are the best! They’re THE best because it’s no secret she uses high quality ingredients, has the most perfect crumble topping and/or that flakey buttery pie crust that she nails, but every bite we take warms our soul because she bakes with love. My favorite is the apple berry crumble pie, second favorite is peach crumble, but my husband loves the cherry pie! And my favorite holiday seasonal offering is the Nantucket crustless cranberry pie!! The creamy pies rhyme with dreamy and they’re also delicious! I’m embarrassed to admit I’ve tried too many flavors but sometimes you feel like you won the lotto when you score one of her pies! Anyways I’ve tried breaking up with Rumbly in my Tumbly many times, usually after the New Years but something keeps pulling me back …. ?
She made such a wonderful lemon meringue pie for my wife’s birthday. It was hard to find a place who did lemon meringue. My wife was over the moon about it and said this will have to be our new pie place! Super convenient, well priced, and delicious!
I cannot say enough how incredibly delicious these pies are. The crusts are the flakey, the cream fillings decadent, and the fruit pies perfectly sweet. Our family loves the lemon raspberry, egg nog, and dulce banana best of all. You can’t go wrong!!!