We booked Costella's on a Sunday for a private family reunion and buffet lunch for 20 people. The food and service were wonderful! From the Antipasto platter to the scrumptious cannoli and other desserts, this place had great Italian food at a reasonable price. Crystal was good to work with on the planning, and Head Waiter Tom was so very kind to our elderly mother. One cousin was already eager to book this place again for the next family reunion!
Kim Rene
Stopped in to check out and support a small business and delightedly surprised! Food was delicious, drinks were on point (margaritas) and great service from Tom. You can tell he enjoys his job. Thanks guys! We’ll be back ?
Karen Turner
Currently open Tuesday through Saturday at 3 pm.Food always fresh, best side salad ever (no iceberg lettuce!). The menu isn't huge, and that assures the food is always freshly prepared.Staff attentive and knowledgeable.
Kim R.
Went here with my husband specifically to try a new local restaurant. This place did not disappoint. The food was delicious, the drinks (margaritas) were perfect and the service was extraordinary. Thank you Tom for being awesome!
Emily S.
We booked Costella's on a Sunday for a private family reunion and buffet lunch for 20 people. The food and service were wonderful! From the Antipasto platter to the scrumptious cannoli and other desserts, this place has great Italian food at a reasonable price. Crystal was good to work with on the planning, and Head Waiter Tom was so very kind to our elderly mother. One cousin is already eager to book this place again for the next family reunion! PS - The wine list is all Italian! You can't go wrong, but we sure enjoyed the Soave.
Rocky McCool
Wonderful meal, great service and nice ambiance
Trish Addis Cole
Great pood. I tried the risotto with shrimp. It was beautiful. Delicious and priced well. Our table had a appetizer plate that was beautiful. Try it, you will like it!
Rhema A.
We had amazing service here as well as absolutely delicious food. The charcuterie board was a good size with many cheese and meat options, and the chicken Marsala was absolutely amazing. The kids pizza and Mac and cheese was even delicious! We had a few drinks as well, all tasted great and were strong. And our waitress was super kind and helpful! We loved this place! The only issue I have is that they aren't open Sunday or Monday
Rick Westerman
Restaurant has a great atmosphere. Soft background music. Friendly and attentive staff. Had their Fettuccine Alfredo and do recommend it. Served with bread and dipping sauce.
J K.
Not trying to be mean spirited here, just stating observations and personal opinions from a dining experience a few weeks back. Not quite friendly (may be overworked and tired due to understaffing) waitress. Took approximately 20 minutes to even get asked for initial drink orders, and another 5-6 minutes for utensils. To say the food wasn't great is an understatement. Wife took pictures of how bad and silly the clam linguini was with uncooked noodles and too much water (no flavor), but no need to share it. Didn't get asked about the dinner once by our waitress (C...?) during dinner. One of the ladies that seemed like management was pleasant and rang us out. We couldn't wait to get out of there. Won't be going back and will not be recommending. I'm surprised to see a few decent reviews, but the negative ones are quite in sync with each other as was my dining experience.
Our first time here tonight. Waited a few minutes since nobody was there to greet us at first. The waiter put us in the bar area & waited a few more minutes. We ordered mushroom risotto and spaghetti & meatballs. The food got 5 stars...what kind of ticked us off was the lack of salad that goes with our entree. Everything is a la carte. Plus, water was never refilled. We like to come back but it will be a last resort.
Ivan Alexander
Wow! I thought that this place sounded good from the other reviews - but it was exceptional. I ordered the special. The chicken was as moist as any I've had anywhere in the world (I've been to over 60 countries and lived in 8 and I'm a complete foodie) and the pasta was perfectly cooked. My friends all loved their food too. If I lived here I'd be eating here every week. This is a hidden gem.
A N
Fresh made to order pasta. Best charcuterie board we've had in a long time! Very friendly server. We will pick this for italian over anywhere else next time. The lasagna and spaghetti with meatballs were amazing and very generous portions with microwavable reusable take out boxes.
Tamandra
We were so disappointed! This place seemed to have good reviews, so we decided to give it a try. The staff are all incredibly friendly and fun, so my low review is for the food. The lasagna we were served was so bland! No herbs, garlic or sausage...it had absolutely no flavor! When I spoke to our server about it, and described the lasagna that received rave reviews, she stated that, “Oh, that was three chefs ago! We let each new chef put their own spin on our menu.” Even the bruschetta starter was flavorless...something you don't often experience in an Italian restaurant. So beware if you are looking at the reviews, to make sure that they are current.
sarah cook
Randomly found this Puyallup gem and so glad I did. The food was all very fresh and tasty. The outdoor patio was the perfect spot for our evening meal and we enjoyed the whole experience. The wait staff was extremely pleasant and we felt welcome as soon as we entered the establishment. Will be back again to try more of the menu but loved the shrimp cavatelli- a perfect combo of creamy but with a nice kick at the end & the chicken Marsala was another favorite. A perfect dinner out.
We booked Costella's on a Sunday for a private family reunion and buffet lunch for 20 people. The food and service were wonderful! From the Antipasto platter to the scrumptious cannoli and other desserts, this place had great Italian food at a reasonable price. Crystal was good to work with on the planning, and Head Waiter Tom was so very kind to our elderly mother. One cousin was already eager to book this place again for the next family reunion!
Stopped in to check out and support a small business and delightedly surprised! Food was delicious, drinks were on point (margaritas) and great service from Tom. You can tell he enjoys his job. Thanks guys! We’ll be back ?
Currently open Tuesday through Saturday at 3 pm.Food always fresh, best side salad ever (no iceberg lettuce!). The menu isn't huge, and that assures the food is always freshly prepared.Staff attentive and knowledgeable.
Went here with my husband specifically to try a new local restaurant. This place did not disappoint. The food was delicious, the drinks (margaritas) were perfect and the service was extraordinary. Thank you Tom for being awesome!
We booked Costella's on a Sunday for a private family reunion and buffet lunch for 20 people. The food and service were wonderful! From the Antipasto platter to the scrumptious cannoli and other desserts, this place has great Italian food at a reasonable price. Crystal was good to work with on the planning, and Head Waiter Tom was so very kind to our elderly mother. One cousin is already eager to book this place again for the next family reunion! PS - The wine list is all Italian! You can't go wrong, but we sure enjoyed the Soave.
Wonderful meal, great service and nice ambiance
Great pood. I tried the risotto with shrimp. It was beautiful. Delicious and priced well. Our table had a appetizer plate that was beautiful. Try it, you will like it!
We had amazing service here as well as absolutely delicious food. The charcuterie board was a good size with many cheese and meat options, and the chicken Marsala was absolutely amazing. The kids pizza and Mac and cheese was even delicious! We had a few drinks as well, all tasted great and were strong. And our waitress was super kind and helpful! We loved this place! The only issue I have is that they aren't open Sunday or Monday
Restaurant has a great atmosphere. Soft background music. Friendly and attentive staff. Had their Fettuccine Alfredo and do recommend it. Served with bread and dipping sauce.
Not trying to be mean spirited here, just stating observations and personal opinions from a dining experience a few weeks back. Not quite friendly (may be overworked and tired due to understaffing) waitress. Took approximately 20 minutes to even get asked for initial drink orders, and another 5-6 minutes for utensils. To say the food wasn't great is an understatement. Wife took pictures of how bad and silly the clam linguini was with uncooked noodles and too much water (no flavor), but no need to share it. Didn't get asked about the dinner once by our waitress (C...?) during dinner. One of the ladies that seemed like management was pleasant and rang us out. We couldn't wait to get out of there. Won't be going back and will not be recommending. I'm surprised to see a few decent reviews, but the negative ones are quite in sync with each other as was my dining experience.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our first time here tonight. Waited a few minutes since nobody was there to greet us at first. The waiter put us in the bar area & waited a few more minutes. We ordered mushroom risotto and spaghetti & meatballs. The food got 5 stars...what kind of ticked us off was the lack of salad that goes with our entree. Everything is a la carte. Plus, water was never refilled. We like to come back but it will be a last resort.
Wow! I thought that this place sounded good from the other reviews - but it was exceptional. I ordered the special. The chicken was as moist as any I've had anywhere in the world (I've been to over 60 countries and lived in 8 and I'm a complete foodie) and the pasta was perfectly cooked. My friends all loved their food too. If I lived here I'd be eating here every week. This is a hidden gem.
Fresh made to order pasta. Best charcuterie board we've had in a long time! Very friendly server. We will pick this for italian over anywhere else next time. The lasagna and spaghetti with meatballs were amazing and very generous portions with microwavable reusable take out boxes.
We were so disappointed! This place seemed to have good reviews, so we decided to give it a try. The staff are all incredibly friendly and fun, so my low review is for the food. The lasagna we were served was so bland! No herbs, garlic or sausage...it had absolutely no flavor! When I spoke to our server about it, and described the lasagna that received rave reviews, she stated that, “Oh, that was three chefs ago! We let each new chef put their own spin on our menu.” Even the bruschetta starter was flavorless...something you don't often experience in an Italian restaurant. So beware if you are looking at the reviews, to make sure that they are current.
Randomly found this Puyallup gem and so glad I did. The food was all very fresh and tasty. The outdoor patio was the perfect spot for our evening meal and we enjoyed the whole experience. The wait staff was extremely pleasant and we felt welcome as soon as we entered the establishment. Will be back again to try more of the menu but loved the shrimp cavatelli- a perfect combo of creamy but with a nice kick at the end & the chicken Marsala was another favorite. A perfect dinner out.