Brianne at Spilled Butter was so easy to work with for our Jan 2024 wedding. She was flexible with our schedules to do a small tasting and helped us with our dream cake design. The cake and desserts were all so beautiful and tasty to boot! We did an assortment of her homemade desserts and they were all delicious. Our guests loved our dessert buffet and having mini cupcakes versions of our wedding cake made everything easier! Highly recommend!
Binta Mustapha
Absolutely delicious cake. Brianne is so professional and nice. She was helpful with any questions I had and very prompt. I am a carrot cake addict so I know when I have good carrot cake. Her carrot cake was BOMB. It was 2/3 layers of my cake. The red velvet layer was also amazing I heard (didnt get a chance to try it, my guests devoured it). Thank you Spilled Butter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josephine B.
Your lemon meringue pie was simply outstanding, far exceeding any other I have ever had! The highest compliment I can offer is your lemon meringue pie was better than the ones my Mom used to make. The crust was indescribably great! You are now my go-to for all desserts!
Ricky R.
I have not visited their location, but I have had many treats from them. At events or shops. Their treats are worth the price and trip. I have a favorite cake spot that will always be close to the top, but this was damn close to dethroning. Plus their other treats are really nice as well. They had a bourbon cherry brownie that inspired me to make my own bourbon cherry brownies. Mine were okay. Theirs were amazing. If you see them, grab them. Its worth it!!
Kyra Williams
Always the best when it comes to cakes and pies! Brianne has great customer service and her business is a gem to have in Tacoma. Love the flavors and how amazing the cakes and pies look when they you pick them up!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
Dan J.
After an amazing experience with a birthday cake, we decided to use Spilled Butter for our wedding cakes as well. Our ceremony was in Oregon, so Brianne was able to wrap them up for us to transport safely. We ended up with two 9 inch cakes with different flavors and they were absolutely incredible!! Our guests loved them as well. The only arguments were which flavor people liked better. We will absolutely be back and now have a favorite baker!
Camryn Stoltzfus
I can’t express how great it was working with this small business! Communication was always easy and she worked with me to get exactly what I wanted. And the cake was delicious! We got the vanilla bean cake with cream cheese layered for our main cake. And the cupcakes were chocolate and red velvet, both with cream cheese frosting. Every one of our guests enjoyed them! I’d highly recommend for any occasion.
Julie R.
5 Stars! From the ease of ordering, to pick-up, and finally to the cake itself....everything was 5 stars. Also the prices are excellent!The website was easy to navigate. I had a couple questions and the owner responded promptly by email with excellent suggestions. I checked in midway between ordering and the day of pick up because it seemed way too easy! She again responded promptly and all was set!For pick-up, I was able to pull up right in front and get the cake. Easy!But the cake....oh my gosh was it pretty and delicious. It really did exceed my expectations. Everyone raved about the cake. I will definitely order any cake from here again.
Gabrielle P.
Brianne was phenomenal. Her professionalism, prompt responses to my inquiries, and creations were outstanding. I am by no means a cake person but this was the best cake I have ever tried in my whole life. I highly suggest her red velvet cake with peanut butter mousse. Our wedding guests raved about the cake, cupcakes, and key lime bar bites. I just wished she had a store front where I could come in at any time to get myself a treat.
Danielle J.
We purchased 24 cupcakes for my sons birthday that were supposed to be "Ninja Turtle" themed. The buttercream was not the right color and hard. It didn't soften after sitting out, and apart in chunks/crumbled while guests attempted to eat them. The kids didn't even finish their cupcakes--so that is telling you something. I did contact the owner after to let her know but never received a response.
My fiancé ordered my birthday cake from this bakery and it’s by far the most delicious cake I’ve ever had!
Rachel Thoenen
Brianne made our wedding cake and we were so happy with how it turned out!! Her aesthetic is so cute, the frosting held up in June PNW heat, and the flavors we picked (chocolate cake with raspberry curd, citrus cake with lemon curd) were so delicious, I don't know how we're going to wait a year to eat our anniversary tier! Pricing was a steal for the quality of what we got and we will definitely be back for more desserts in the future!
Rachel T.
Brianne made our wedding cake and we were so happy with how it turned out!! Her aesthetic is so cute, the frosting held up in June PNW heat, and the flavors we picked (chocolate cake with raspberry curd, citrus cake with lemon curd) were so delicious, I don't know how we're going to wait a year to eat our anniversary tier! Pricing was a steal for the quality of what we got and we will definitely be back for more desserts in the future!
adam juhl
The best cake i've ever had! Everyone at my wifes birthday party raved about how good it was. Definitely recommend!!
Melelototo'a M.
This person still gets my one star reviews deleted, see our conversation on Google reviews. Look at their catalog and look at the product their reviews are displaying. The "real cakes" suck in appearance. The penmanship looks so sloppy, anyone can produce it. They advertise beautiful floral cakes, but where is the photo reviews of them? This person was so disrespectful to me when I inquired about a simple 'pre season' wedding cake. Just keep in mind that they can and they DO get their less then 5 star reviews deleted here and the knot. Go to Google reviews to see what people are really saying.
Brianne at Spilled Butter was so easy to work with for our Jan 2024 wedding. She was flexible with our schedules to do a small tasting and helped us with our dream cake design. The cake and desserts were all so beautiful and tasty to boot! We did an assortment of her homemade desserts and they were all delicious. Our guests loved our dessert buffet and having mini cupcakes versions of our wedding cake made everything easier! Highly recommend!
Absolutely delicious cake. Brianne is so professional and nice. She was helpful with any questions I had and very prompt. I am a carrot cake addict so I know when I have good carrot cake. Her carrot cake was BOMB. It was 2/3 layers of my cake. The red velvet layer was also amazing I heard (didnt get a chance to try it, my guests devoured it). Thank you Spilled Butter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Your lemon meringue pie was simply outstanding, far exceeding any other I have ever had! The highest compliment I can offer is your lemon meringue pie was better than the ones my Mom used to make. The crust was indescribably great! You are now my go-to for all desserts!
I have not visited their location, but I have had many treats from them. At events or shops. Their treats are worth the price and trip. I have a favorite cake spot that will always be close to the top, but this was damn close to dethroning. Plus their other treats are really nice as well. They had a bourbon cherry brownie that inspired me to make my own bourbon cherry brownies. Mine were okay. Theirs were amazing. If you see them, grab them. Its worth it!!
Always the best when it comes to cakes and pies! Brianne has great customer service and her business is a gem to have in Tacoma. Love the flavors and how amazing the cakes and pies look when they you pick them up!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
After an amazing experience with a birthday cake, we decided to use Spilled Butter for our wedding cakes as well. Our ceremony was in Oregon, so Brianne was able to wrap them up for us to transport safely. We ended up with two 9 inch cakes with different flavors and they were absolutely incredible!! Our guests loved them as well. The only arguments were which flavor people liked better. We will absolutely be back and now have a favorite baker!
I can’t express how great it was working with this small business! Communication was always easy and she worked with me to get exactly what I wanted. And the cake was delicious! We got the vanilla bean cake with cream cheese layered for our main cake. And the cupcakes were chocolate and red velvet, both with cream cheese frosting. Every one of our guests enjoyed them! I’d highly recommend for any occasion.
5 Stars! From the ease of ordering, to pick-up, and finally to the cake itself....everything was 5 stars. Also the prices are excellent!The website was easy to navigate. I had a couple questions and the owner responded promptly by email with excellent suggestions. I checked in midway between ordering and the day of pick up because it seemed way too easy! She again responded promptly and all was set!For pick-up, I was able to pull up right in front and get the cake. Easy!But the cake....oh my gosh was it pretty and delicious. It really did exceed my expectations. Everyone raved about the cake. I will definitely order any cake from here again.
Brianne was phenomenal. Her professionalism, prompt responses to my inquiries, and creations were outstanding. I am by no means a cake person but this was the best cake I have ever tried in my whole life. I highly suggest her red velvet cake with peanut butter mousse. Our wedding guests raved about the cake, cupcakes, and key lime bar bites. I just wished she had a store front where I could come in at any time to get myself a treat.
We purchased 24 cupcakes for my sons birthday that were supposed to be "Ninja Turtle" themed. The buttercream was not the right color and hard. It didn't soften after sitting out, and apart in chunks/crumbled while guests attempted to eat them. The kids didn't even finish their cupcakes--so that is telling you something. I did contact the owner after to let her know but never received a response.
Restaurantji Recommends
My fiancé ordered my birthday cake from this bakery and it’s by far the most delicious cake I’ve ever had!
Brianne made our wedding cake and we were so happy with how it turned out!! Her aesthetic is so cute, the frosting held up in June PNW heat, and the flavors we picked (chocolate cake with raspberry curd, citrus cake with lemon curd) were so delicious, I don't know how we're going to wait a year to eat our anniversary tier! Pricing was a steal for the quality of what we got and we will definitely be back for more desserts in the future!
Brianne made our wedding cake and we were so happy with how it turned out!! Her aesthetic is so cute, the frosting held up in June PNW heat, and the flavors we picked (chocolate cake with raspberry curd, citrus cake with lemon curd) were so delicious, I don't know how we're going to wait a year to eat our anniversary tier! Pricing was a steal for the quality of what we got and we will definitely be back for more desserts in the future!
The best cake i've ever had! Everyone at my wifes birthday party raved about how good it was. Definitely recommend!!
This person still gets my one star reviews deleted, see our conversation on Google reviews. Look at their catalog and look at the product their reviews are displaying. The "real cakes" suck in appearance. The penmanship looks so sloppy, anyone can produce it. They advertise beautiful floral cakes, but where is the photo reviews of them? This person was so disrespectful to me when I inquired about a simple 'pre season' wedding cake. Just keep in mind that they can and they DO get their less then 5 star reviews deleted here and the knot. Go to Google reviews to see what people are really saying.