The Legacy Supper Club

5334 N Richmond St, Appleton
(920) 733-2427

Recent Reviews

Skye Caldie

Good old fashioned supper club. Hubby said the Old Fashion he drank was great!!

Georgia Westenberger

Great salad. One of the best. Cheese potatoes were wonderful. Salmon was done just right. Look forward to going again soon.

Larry Snap

It’s decent.Ok salad bar. Ok menu. Decent food.Not my first choice, but would go if someone asked.

Dawn Giamarino

Was disappointed in the T-Bone quality, and deep fried haddock was only so-so. The service was excellent.

Donald Skalecki

Bought walleye tonight the breading was soggy got only one piece my wife had a t bone steak no flavoring at all so for 1 piece of fish and one baked potato 25 dollars over priced and when we paid for our meal they charge u 2 dollars for using yr credit card wow so 70 dollars we paid was over priced and not worth never will go

Angela S

Bartender was great, drinks were good. All downhill from there though:(. Salad bar looked amazing until you got up close. Lettuce was wilted and brown, green onions were slimy, radishes were dried out and honest to gosh… the cherry tomatoes had mold on them and were shriveled. Our waitress was LESS than friendly and just walked by and took our salad plates off the end of our table without asking or saying a word. We decided to just it go hoping for a great meal. Nope?‍♀️. We ordered the crab tot appetizer for $14 and aside from being cold and greasy it was nothing mor than mushy canned crab with peppers deep fried with an awful thick dipping sauce I could not define. I was so shocked at our meals that I never took pictures which would have shocked anyone. The ribs were grey, they looked boiled and the sauce as requested by us was on the side ( we prefer it not so heavy) but nonetheless without any bbq on these ribs we had nothing but tasteless meat. I had one bite of the salmon and it was apparent it was bad. I didnt realize the smell until after that first bite which was a sick feeling in itself. We each had a dinner roll which was the ONLY good part of the meal. Even our hash browns were not touched as we asked for them to be well done extra crispy and they were barely cooked. Again the waitress NEVER even came by to ask how our food was,, there is only one other table, and the other waitress was taking care of that table, she finally came and asked, “are you folks done” and we said yes and she grabbed our full plates of food without asking a question and two minutes later came and set down the bill to say “hope you folks have good nite”! We even heard her (as we were rite at the kitchen door exclaim, “table two don’t like the food”! Wow?! We actually still left her an over 20% tip, Im sure she expecting, after the experience of being snubbed but aside from her less than professional or friendly manner.,, the kitchen sent all this food out this way, from the salad bar, to apps to meals. :( A long awaited trip to Legacy to meet friends turned into a terrible disappointment:(, not to mention a McDonald’s drive through run on the drive back home an hour away after spending over $200 on dinner and drinks.

Jeff Smith

The food was real good, service was slow which I understand being short handed, but when your seated means your up and service should be good but it wasn't the best.

Jane Foreman

got reservation for Friday which was nice had organized 10 people well things fell thru end up being 6 of us. lady made me feel bad for people canceling on my bday. but things happened. even said this is why I hate taking reservations. well excuse me would u rather party of 6 to 10 just show up. got the tenderloin and it was juicy but taste was plain no flavor and for 30dollars even order au ju sauce to help that was tasteless. salad bar was good. took long time for food when all the tables behind us were bare. and waitress too 20 mins to refill drinks after one person with asked her out right. parking was easy. So if they add flavor to steak might not be bad. also beware on Fridays if u order potato cakes for ur potato choice they give u. they add a upcharge 2 of my people got. and were you'd it was from them but why offer as a potato choice and then told uocharge for ot is written on board out front next to bar. well I don't know if I was taking orders I think I'd probably still offer it at a upcharge

Kathleen Gribble

One waitress with lots of energy and enthusiasm took care of 22 of us in a group!

thomas hoida

The Friday fish lunch was delicious! With a nice selection of seafood, soup, appetisers prompt Friendly service. We are looking forward to stopping in again. Thanks for a Great meal ✌️

Barbara Danielson

The price is high and the portion size is very small. I ordered a steak it was tough and tasteless. Frozen prior and microwaved before grilling. The salad bar and the wait staff were the only redeeming quality.

Helen Timm

Food was delicious. Bartender/Owner could use an attitude adjustment. Don't know if I'll return for that reason alone!

Chad Morien

Food was average, service was exceptional and drinks and atmosphere were lit up for this supper club.

Jacqueline Cassandra

Tried to order a pickup and the person on the phone rudely said we don’t have time. Anytime we’ve tried going staff has also been very rude.

Josh Dura

Friends invited us out with them to try this place. They have been here before n keep coming back. We now know why. Service was great. Place was clean. Salad bar was next level. We tired the ribs. Those were great. Scallops were breaded and did not amaze but not bad. Lobster was honored in it's death. Just outstanding. Steak was awesome. Just overall a great place and super happy to know they are just a short drive away. We will be back for sure!

Load More