Very solid family run restaurant. Service is always stellar and food is ready ridiculously quickly. A bit Americanized for my preference (lot of things come with cheese sauce) but the food is very tasty and the portions are generous for the price. Definitely worth your time!Parking: Plenty of parking in a large, communal lot. I've never had issues finding a spot.
Great little lunch spot! Great food, great prices, 10/10, would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lekeyo Mincey
THE FOOD IS AMAZING AND FLAVORFUL GREAT VIBE .EASILY BEST MEXICAN RESTARAUNT IN
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Fajitas
Jill Olson
The service here is stellar, and the food is delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa
Mitchell K.
For one, WAY TOO MUCH SALT. I got the bisteck a la mexicana, it would've been good flavor wise but I couldnt eat it due to too much salt. The rice was also salty, my friend brought that up before I tried it and he was right. Ive never had rice that tasted salty! It wasn't as bad as the entree though. The salty taste I mean, the rice itself was pretty bland and boring. Their mild salsa tasted like spaghetti sauce (gross) and my coworker agreed, however the hot salsa was fantastic with chips. My coworker, who is mexican btw, said the steak tacos were okay, but they didnt dice the onions, they were lazily cut and unappetizing so he took them off. When you order a taco mexican style with cilantro/onions, the onions are ALWAYS diced, for a reason...and im from Racine, Wi. So I know good mexican food. Lastly I ordered the bean burrito, which was decent...but it was NOT a burrito, it was an enchilada with beans inside. I dont think they know the difference.
Duwayne Sime
Everytime we go there it is always fantastic food. The service and people are top notch. The owner always makes sure you are satisfied with your food and service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa, Chicken Fajitas, Burrito, Chimichanga
e/a mason
Don Maguey checked all the boxes before I ate. Someone answered the phone. ✔️ They answered All the questions and guided me to what I was looking for. ✔️. I didn't have to sign in, go to an app or pay ahead. ✔️. They said ready in 10 minutes ✔️. Food ready when I got there. ✔️.Carne asada fries Delish nachos yum. Chimichanga is so satisfying.I'll be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick Puttkamer
Great food and service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Christiaansen
The Burrito Don Maguey is fantastic!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Delyea
Vegetarian options: Who knew that beans could taste so good!
Perfect for a family meal at this Mexican restaurant. Great food, friendly service, classic American style Mexican food. Worth the stop for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa, Chicken Fajitas, Fajitas
Daniel Harvey
Wow! First time there! Talk about a hidden gem! The food was amazing! The staff was the exactly perfect amount of present, knowledgeable, and friendly. The margaritas were mmmmmmmmmm!
Myles Safford
Very poor experience tonight. Our usual takeout Mexican spot closed early for NYE, so we thought we’d give Don Maguey another shot after a couple years since our last time here.Firstly, apparently all of their card machines suddenly stopped working in the time between I called to place the order and went to pick it up. Okay, no problem, as it was out of their control. Had to go to the ATM at Kwik Trip to get cash and go back. An inconvenience to be sure, but I honestly wasn’t annoyed hardly at all because the workers were very kind and apologetic about the issue with their machines.Now, on to the food. My partner and I each did a pick 3 combination. The ground beef in her burrito was severely undercooked (see picture). Ground beef shouldn’t be that pink. The burritos were really more like enchiladas than burritos, as they were covered in red sauce and quite loose (not folded tightly), and not able to be eaten by hand. The pulled chicken tasted fine.The “quesadillas” were so oily that they were legitimately soggy (see the glistening in the below picture). It’s like they weren’t grilled or pressed at all, and were just one tortilla loosely folded over.My partner’s soft taco was also super wet. The rice that came with the meals was obviously frozen and not fresh, with random bits of corn, cubed carrots and grayish peas.Overall, just incredibly disappointing food. We ended up getting delivery Taco Bell and were much more satisfied with that.I like to support CG businesses when I can, but this experience unfortunately reminded me why going to East Madison or Sun Prairie for decent Mexican food is worth the trip.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Family Russ
Grabbed to go food for the first time tonight! It was delicious even after the 10 min drive home. The staff was very welcoming and friendly when we went in to pick up our order. Looking forward to going back to dine in and try some margaritas!
Very solid family run restaurant. Service is always stellar and food is ready ridiculously quickly. A bit Americanized for my preference (lot of things come with cheese sauce) but the food is very tasty and the portions are generous for the price. Definitely worth your time!Parking: Plenty of parking in a large, communal lot. I've never had issues finding a spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Enchilada, Burrito Diablo, Chimichanga
Great little lunch spot! Great food, great prices, 10/10, would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
THE FOOD IS AMAZING AND FLAVORFUL GREAT VIBE .EASILY BEST MEXICAN RESTARAUNT IN
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Fajitas
The service here is stellar, and the food is delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa
For one, WAY TOO MUCH SALT. I got the bisteck a la mexicana, it would've been good flavor wise but I couldnt eat it due to too much salt. The rice was also salty, my friend brought that up before I tried it and he was right. Ive never had rice that tasted salty! It wasn't as bad as the entree though. The salty taste I mean, the rice itself was pretty bland and boring. Their mild salsa tasted like spaghetti sauce (gross) and my coworker agreed, however the hot salsa was fantastic with chips. My coworker, who is mexican btw, said the steak tacos were okay, but they didnt dice the onions, they were lazily cut and unappetizing so he took them off. When you order a taco mexican style with cilantro/onions, the onions are ALWAYS diced, for a reason...and im from Racine, Wi. So I know good mexican food. Lastly I ordered the bean burrito, which was decent...but it was NOT a burrito, it was an enchilada with beans inside. I dont think they know the difference.
Everytime we go there it is always fantastic food. The service and people are top notch. The owner always makes sure you are satisfied with your food and service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa, Chicken Fajitas, Burrito, Chimichanga
Don Maguey checked all the boxes before I ate. Someone answered the phone. ✔️ They answered All the questions and guided me to what I was looking for. ✔️. I didn't have to sign in, go to an app or pay ahead. ✔️. They said ready in 10 minutes ✔️. Food ready when I got there. ✔️.Carne asada fries Delish nachos yum. Chimichanga is so satisfying.I'll be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Burrito Don Maguey is fantastic!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vegetarian options: Who knew that beans could taste so good!
Restaurantji Recommends
Good food, prices are
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fried Ice Cream
Perfect for a family meal at this Mexican restaurant. Great food, friendly service, classic American style Mexican food. Worth the stop for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa, Chicken Fajitas, Fajitas
Wow! First time there! Talk about a hidden gem! The food was amazing! The staff was the exactly perfect amount of present, knowledgeable, and friendly. The margaritas were mmmmmmmmmm!
Very poor experience tonight. Our usual takeout Mexican spot closed early for NYE, so we thought we’d give Don Maguey another shot after a couple years since our last time here.Firstly, apparently all of their card machines suddenly stopped working in the time between I called to place the order and went to pick it up. Okay, no problem, as it was out of their control. Had to go to the ATM at Kwik Trip to get cash and go back. An inconvenience to be sure, but I honestly wasn’t annoyed hardly at all because the workers were very kind and apologetic about the issue with their machines.Now, on to the food. My partner and I each did a pick 3 combination. The ground beef in her burrito was severely undercooked (see picture). Ground beef shouldn’t be that pink. The burritos were really more like enchiladas than burritos, as they were covered in red sauce and quite loose (not folded tightly), and not able to be eaten by hand. The pulled chicken tasted fine.The “quesadillas” were so oily that they were legitimately soggy (see the glistening in the below picture). It’s like they weren’t grilled or pressed at all, and were just one tortilla loosely folded over.My partner’s soft taco was also super wet. The rice that came with the meals was obviously frozen and not fresh, with random bits of corn, cubed carrots and grayish peas.Overall, just incredibly disappointing food. We ended up getting delivery Taco Bell and were much more satisfied with that.I like to support CG businesses when I can, but this experience unfortunately reminded me why going to East Madison or Sun Prairie for decent Mexican food is worth the trip.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Grabbed to go food for the first time tonight! It was delicious even after the 10 min drive home. The staff was very welcoming and friendly when we went in to pick up our order. Looking forward to going back to dine in and try some margaritas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrito