Karen The Cake Lady

117 Commerce St, DeForest
(608) 846-2446

Recent Reviews

Linda Leen

She has amazing desserts, cookies and caramel rolls. She always goes above and beyond. She.has done many family weddings and birthdays and she never disappoints! Highly recommend!Dietary restrictions: She does gluten free also.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cakes

Blayne Pynakker

It seems to be one of the companies that don't have to answer their phone or return your messages

Bruce Miller

Feedback from others who enjoyed the cake was very positive, and the GF option was very good, from my own experience.Dietary restrictions: GF options available.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cakes

Mrs Dixon

She made an absolutely delicious Tres Leches cake for my husband’s birthday! The cinnamon rolls are good too. Highly recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cakes

Andrew Hanson

Karen’s home town charm and delectable flavors helped bring our wedding desert desires to life that ranged from cheese cake bites to lemon bars. Everyone loved her deserts and could not stop complimenting her deserts. It is clear that Karen passion is not just for baking but is in having people enjoy her treats.

Gerrick Childs

Karen is the best.We first had her do our wedding cake 15 years ago.We've been back for special occasions of all sorts and dosen't matter if it's a cake, cookies, Cinnamon rolls or something else. Karen always exceeds expectations.

Cally Vaughn

The best gluten free cake I've had! Karen is even able to make gluten free and dairy free taste amazing! I haven't tried her wheat flour cakes but I received a lot of complements on it at my wedding! Karen can be hard to get a hold of due to her limited hours, but once you do, it's worth it! She does an amazing job and puts so much love into her cakes!

Cally Schumal

The best gluten free cake I've had! Karen is even able to make gluten free and dairy free taste amazing! I haven't tried her wheat flour cakes but I received a lot of complements on it at my wedding! Karen can be hard to get a hold of due to her limited hours, but once you do, it's worth it! She does an amazing job and puts so much love into her cakes!

Allie D'Amato

Karen was such a joy to work with. She has provided many baked goods for my husband and his family over the years, so it was an easy decision to go with her for our wedding day! Cake tasting was our favorite part of wedding planning, and WOW did she deliver! She was so patient + helpful, and everything she baked for us was delicious! Truly couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend Karen!

Joe Maly

Karen is an absolute delight, very kind hearted, and as far as the baked goods we'll they speak for themselves. A hands down must try, you won't regret it.

Dylan

Awesome fresh baked goods live chocolate dipped bonbons!

Alana Salas

Karen was awesome to work with! We loved every single item we tried during our tasting so we had a difficult time deciding what cakes, cupcakes, and other treats to offer. We ended up going with 3 cupcake flavors, some 7 layer bars, and a 3 tier cake that had 2 flavors. I only heard great things from all of our guests about the desserts and there was very little left over at the end of the night. She delivered the items, brought displays, and set up the dessert bar. Highly recommend booking her for your big day!

Kasey Hoffman

She makes the most delicious desserts. She did our wedding cakes and cupcakes most recently, but she has been making our cakes since were were little. Absolutely recommend!

Kathleen Harris

Yes we are going to use Karen the cake lady for our wedding

A-Belle R.

Karen is always so sweet and flexible! We recieved a chocolate cake with stawberry filling and it was great! The cake was beautfully decorated! Highly reccomend

Load More