If you're going to Massacre, the Gyros sandwich , I have a feeling should stick to ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Michael McMillan
Had Gyros one night Chicago style stuff pizza the second night. Both were great. Serving sizes are huge, reasonable prices and delivery on time. Highly recommend them.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Stuffed Create Your Own Pizza, Lamb & Beef Gyros
Christopher Tuskowski
The Chicago style is by far the best pizza available for delivery in Madison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori G.
Was craving for a Pizza Pit pizza. Guy said 45-1 hour for delivery. It was terrible. Hardly any beef, more mushroom than anything! Tasted like cardboard , hardly any good Wisconsin cheese. Pizza was cold after waiting 50 minutes. Never this place again! Sure wasn't a Pizza Pit pizza!!
Jayson Seiler
Great food. Great service. Best pizza in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dena J.
11/24/2023 - My husband left a review earlier outlining how Pizza Extreme, on Monroe Street in Madison, WI, didn't have the correct hours online. It said it would be open at 11a.m., when he arrived there was a note stating that they would be open at 4pm. My husband called at 4p.m. to see if they had our order. When my husband began telling him our order, he was told by the employee that he saw our order. HOWEVER, even with the order being correct online, the guy STILL messed up our order! They pizza taste good, but it wasn't what we ordered. There was no apology, no offer to discount the pizza and no offer to deliver them. Not a great experience. It'll be a while before we by pizza from Pizza Extreme, at least the one on Monroe Street. If you want a tip, get the order correct and value your customers time and money.
Aldro J.
11/24/2023 - Today is my birthday, and my husband ordered two of my favorite pizzas for us all to eat. The website said the Pizza Extreme on Monroes Street in Madison would be open at 11:00 a.m. My husband placed the order online and it confirmed that the order would be ready at 11:33. He drove from the Warner Park area to Monroe Street only to find out that they would not open until 4p.m. This information should have been listed online. Other restaurants either indicate online that their hours are different (not a note on the door, wasting peoples time and gas), or disable their online ordering until the establishment is open for business. We LOVE the taste of the pizza, but were not pleased with having to make ANOTHER trip after they open at 4p.m. We would cancel the pizzas, but there's no way to do that online. They SHOULD deliver our pizza to us at 4p.m. today. Very annoyed.
Laurie Miller
Don't order the Hawaiian pizza, not good at all, bread sticks not good
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
kristy herling
Best customer service and top quality food. Reasonable prices. Just wish that they were open later in evening.
The Chicago Deep Dish is THE BEST!!! There is no other pizza like it In Wisconsin. The cheese, the sauce, the crust...... So good.
Lillian Williams
The employees are friendly, caring and the chef is second to none, all his pizzas are made with tinder love and care.
Violet S
Homemade pizza crust and amazing sauce too! Had the Supreme and it was soo good, I definitely recommend this hidden gem
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jetlife Andretti
This is Hands DOWN….best pizza in Wisconsin, 10 out of 10, the employees are friendly, caring and the chef is second to none, all his pizzas are made with tinder love and care. I have ate there the last 5 days in a row for a reason??? best pizza in Wisconsin and I’m willing to die on that hill I never been hooked on pizza until I ate here.
Best chicago style in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you're going to Massacre, the Gyros sandwich , I have a feeling should stick to ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Had Gyros one night Chicago style stuff pizza the second night. Both were great. Serving sizes are huge, reasonable prices and delivery on time. Highly recommend them.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Stuffed Create Your Own Pizza, Lamb & Beef Gyros
The Chicago style is by far the best pizza available for delivery in Madison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was craving for a Pizza Pit pizza. Guy said 45-1 hour for delivery. It was terrible. Hardly any beef, more mushroom than anything! Tasted like cardboard , hardly any good Wisconsin cheese. Pizza was cold after waiting 50 minutes. Never this place again! Sure wasn't a Pizza Pit pizza!!
Great food. Great service. Best pizza in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
11/24/2023 - My husband left a review earlier outlining how Pizza Extreme, on Monroe Street in Madison, WI, didn't have the correct hours online. It said it would be open at 11a.m., when he arrived there was a note stating that they would be open at 4pm. My husband called at 4p.m. to see if they had our order. When my husband began telling him our order, he was told by the employee that he saw our order. HOWEVER, even with the order being correct online, the guy STILL messed up our order! They pizza taste good, but it wasn't what we ordered. There was no apology, no offer to discount the pizza and no offer to deliver them. Not a great experience. It'll be a while before we by pizza from Pizza Extreme, at least the one on Monroe Street. If you want a tip, get the order correct and value your customers time and money.
11/24/2023 - Today is my birthday, and my husband ordered two of my favorite pizzas for us all to eat. The website said the Pizza Extreme on Monroes Street in Madison would be open at 11:00 a.m. My husband placed the order online and it confirmed that the order would be ready at 11:33. He drove from the Warner Park area to Monroe Street only to find out that they would not open until 4p.m. This information should have been listed online. Other restaurants either indicate online that their hours are different (not a note on the door, wasting peoples time and gas), or disable their online ordering until the establishment is open for business. We LOVE the taste of the pizza, but were not pleased with having to make ANOTHER trip after they open at 4p.m. We would cancel the pizzas, but there's no way to do that online. They SHOULD deliver our pizza to us at 4p.m. today. Very annoyed.
Don't order the Hawaiian pizza, not good at all, bread sticks not good
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best customer service and top quality food. Reasonable prices. Just wish that they were open later in evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The Chicago Deep Dish is THE BEST!!! There is no other pizza like it In Wisconsin. The cheese, the sauce, the crust...... So good.
The employees are friendly, caring and the chef is second to none, all his pizzas are made with tinder love and care.
Homemade pizza crust and amazing sauce too! Had the Supreme and it was soo good, I definitely recommend this hidden gem
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is Hands DOWN….best pizza in Wisconsin, 10 out of 10, the employees are friendly, caring and the chef is second to none, all his pizzas are made with tinder love and care. I have ate there the last 5 days in a row for a reason??? best pizza in Wisconsin and I’m willing to die on that hill I never been hooked on pizza until I ate here.
They were closed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5