Is it bad that my child’s first words were “Macs” (Macarons) and “Coo-coos” (Cookies) because we visit McKayla Marie Sweets so often? Some say that’s bad parenting, I say my child is a genius for having such great taste at a young age.It’s such a joy visiting McKayla and Keegan, they greet you with a smile, and every baked good they sell is somehow better than the last one. We’ve been enjoying their treats for over a year now and I don’t think we will ever tire of how tasty they are!McKayla has done 3 cakes for us so far and they have always been delicious. The process of ordering the cakes was simple and SO easy to understand from the website, and if you have any questions it’s fun to stop in and bounce questions and ideas off McKayla. (Plus you have an excuse to buy a lil snack)The cream puffs EASILY beat the ones at the state fair, and don’t walk, RUN whenever she has tuxedo cake or death by chocolate cake in the case because holy moly they’re the most incredible desserts you will ever try. Don’t sleep on her S’Mores Cookies - They taste like childhood summers, so yummy and nostalgic!As someone who lives by the philosophy of “I always need a little treat.” MMS checks that box each and every time we visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lucy
It does not say anywhere that they need your order a week in advance, they need to update their website.
Service: 1
Cassandra Franta
Delicous desserts, I have loved every item we have tried and the cake that was made for my daughters birthday, with short notice, was perfect. I do wish you were open later, I would stop more often then just the weekends. Maybe its good for my waistline that you're not ? Highly recommend stopping for anyone who comes from out of town, as well as someone bringing a dessert to impress for a function. You will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dustin Butch
I stopped in for the first time today and bought a dozen macarons to share. The quality exceeded my expectations. They were the best macarons I’ve had. They have an amazing flavor lineup, and each one has great flavor and texture.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macarons
Sophia Zey
Seriously Instagram Pinterest worthy AND delicious cakes and baked goods! We had a farm and lunar new year kids birthday party and McKayla Marie Sweets knocked it out of the park. The cake was adorable and delicious! We got so many compliments on the cake. Definitely coming back for more cakes in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Fritz
McKayla made my cake and dessert bar for my wedding! I highly recommend her. Everything was delicious and reasonably priced! We got to go to her store to trial out flavors and then we picked our favorites! She is also so nice and easy to work with!
The cookies and macarons from McKayla Marie sweets are to die for. You can taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite. The macarons were a huge hit at my baby shower and at my work donor event. McKayla and her sister are always so friendly and welcoming and her shop is the cutest!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macarons
allison kuc
Easily one of the BEST bakery’s in Green Bay. Her cookies are amazing and the menu changes constantly so there is always something new to try. Also the best cakes in town. Delicious and they are pretty. We stop by several times per month for a sweet treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Naomi Sladky
Absolutely love love!! These are honestly the best macaroons I’ve ever had. Even compared to Paris. And the flourless cake with vanilla bean.. wow. McKayla has always been so accommodating when I need a cake even last minute. She’s been a staple to all our family birthdays. It’s so hard to find good gluten free items and her flourless is my favorite!!❤️ and such amazing girls every time I come in.Look no further, this is the best bakery in town!
I can’t express enough how amazing McKayla Marie Sweets is!!!Making yummy cakes, cookies, macarons, and more is her game!! Everyone is always friendly and helpful at the store. This is one of the BEST small businesses around!!! If you are looking for a delicious treat.. check MMS out! ☺️
Without hesitation I can say these are the best cookies I’ve ever had, period!They are crispy and crunchy on the outside but oozing soft on the inside. The flavors are wonderfully balanced.My favorites are classics such as chocolate chip but you can’t go wrong with one of the specialty one as well.Outstanding
Derek Johnson
Best baked goods in Green Bay hands down. The cookies are amazing, but the cream puff is what keeps me coming back! McKayla always provides exceptional customer service, and a product that’s offered at a fair price.
Heather Mason
I tried your Macaroons earlier this week from someone who had bought them for me who knows I am GF. I ate 3 of them and couldn’t believe how delicious they were. I came back today before my hair appointment and got some more macaroons and your flourless chocolate cake was so delicious!!!! I will defiantly be back soon to get more delicious treats!!!
Brian Fischer
This my family's absolute favorite treat place, we look forward to the new and returning treats every month. We will be visiting quite often.
The lemon cookie and cream puff were both great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Is it bad that my child’s first words were “Macs” (Macarons) and “Coo-coos” (Cookies) because we visit McKayla Marie Sweets so often? Some say that’s bad parenting, I say my child is a genius for having such great taste at a young age.It’s such a joy visiting McKayla and Keegan, they greet you with a smile, and every baked good they sell is somehow better than the last one. We’ve been enjoying their treats for over a year now and I don’t think we will ever tire of how tasty they are!McKayla has done 3 cakes for us so far and they have always been delicious. The process of ordering the cakes was simple and SO easy to understand from the website, and if you have any questions it’s fun to stop in and bounce questions and ideas off McKayla. (Plus you have an excuse to buy a lil snack)The cream puffs EASILY beat the ones at the state fair, and don’t walk, RUN whenever she has tuxedo cake or death by chocolate cake in the case because holy moly they’re the most incredible desserts you will ever try. Don’t sleep on her S’Mores Cookies - They taste like childhood summers, so yummy and nostalgic!As someone who lives by the philosophy of “I always need a little treat.” MMS checks that box each and every time we visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It does not say anywhere that they need your order a week in advance, they need to update their website.
Service: 1
Delicous desserts, I have loved every item we have tried and the cake that was made for my daughters birthday, with short notice, was perfect. I do wish you were open later, I would stop more often then just the weekends. Maybe its good for my waistline that you're not ? Highly recommend stopping for anyone who comes from out of town, as well as someone bringing a dessert to impress for a function. You will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped in for the first time today and bought a dozen macarons to share. The quality exceeded my expectations. They were the best macarons I’ve had. They have an amazing flavor lineup, and each one has great flavor and texture.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macarons
Seriously Instagram Pinterest worthy AND delicious cakes and baked goods! We had a farm and lunar new year kids birthday party and McKayla Marie Sweets knocked it out of the park. The cake was adorable and delicious! We got so many compliments on the cake. Definitely coming back for more cakes in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
McKayla made my cake and dessert bar for my wedding! I highly recommend her. Everything was delicious and reasonably priced! We got to go to her store to trial out flavors and then we picked our favorites! She is also so nice and easy to work with!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macarons, Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Chocolate Cake
The cookies and macarons from McKayla Marie sweets are to die for. You can taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite. The macarons were a huge hit at my baby shower and at my work donor event. McKayla and her sister are always so friendly and welcoming and her shop is the cutest!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macarons
Easily one of the BEST bakery’s in Green Bay. Her cookies are amazing and the menu changes constantly so there is always something new to try. Also the best cakes in town. Delicious and they are pretty. We stop by several times per month for a sweet treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Absolutely love love!! These are honestly the best macaroons I’ve ever had. Even compared to Paris. And the flourless cake with vanilla bean.. wow. McKayla has always been so accommodating when I need a cake even last minute. She’s been a staple to all our family birthdays. It’s so hard to find good gluten free items and her flourless is my favorite!!❤️ and such amazing girls every time I come in.Look no further, this is the best bakery in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macarons, Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Chocolate Cake
Restaurantji Recommends
I can’t express enough how amazing McKayla Marie Sweets is!!!Making yummy cakes, cookies, macarons, and more is her game!! Everyone is always friendly and helpful at the store. This is one of the BEST small businesses around!!! If you are looking for a delicious treat.. check MMS out! ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macarons, Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Chocolate Cake
Without hesitation I can say these are the best cookies I’ve ever had, period!They are crispy and crunchy on the outside but oozing soft on the inside. The flavors are wonderfully balanced.My favorites are classics such as chocolate chip but you can’t go wrong with one of the specialty one as well.Outstanding
Best baked goods in Green Bay hands down. The cookies are amazing, but the cream puff is what keeps me coming back! McKayla always provides exceptional customer service, and a product that’s offered at a fair price.
I tried your Macaroons earlier this week from someone who had bought them for me who knows I am GF. I ate 3 of them and couldn’t believe how delicious they were. I came back today before my hair appointment and got some more macaroons and your flourless chocolate cake was so delicious!!!! I will defiantly be back soon to get more delicious treats!!!
This my family's absolute favorite treat place, we look forward to the new and returning treats every month. We will be visiting quite often.