Very friendly and helpful waitress, Nicole! Loved the ribs and also the steak pasta! Menu had many many options. Ambiance was great with beautiful fireplace and privacy for conversation. Cocktail and wine very satisfactory.
Holl
Had the pizza and garlic bread. Always delicious when not in the mood for a full course meal. Super thin crust and tasty. Very good cocktails as well. Been going there for many years.
Very much an enjoyable experience with our group of 6. At nearly $109/pp with a couple inexpensive bottles of wine and drinks, and dessert, it is a bit pricey even with today's pricing. Several had scallops and lobster risotto, couple pork chops all above expectations. Food quality and service (Alex exceptional!) what a tremendously enjoyable evening. We had the crown room so the private dining experience and conversations was above par. Have visited several times previously and will definitely return.
JeffreyR
The ambiance, wine list and service were outstanding. We all had entries, several of which were specials yet the entrees were flawed (cold, overcooked, poor presentation). Thank you to our waitress who made the evening enjoyable.
Great experience from start to finish! All the vibes of a supper club with ambiance and amazing drinks. Food was phenomenal. Perfectly cooked to order and the service was outstanding!! Highly recommend
Stacee Brtmk
Fantastic food, service and ambiance!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service from beginning to end was outstanding! Food is and has always been great. The host and waitress were personable, polite, prompt and very professional. Thank you, Johnny Manhattan, what a wonderful time we had and plans to come back soon.
Denny M.
The food and ambiance at Johnny Manhattans never disappoints. The service provided by Nicole is amazing. She simply knows how to take care of her guests and enhances the experience at this wonderful establishment. Highly recommended!
Holl
I've been going to Johnny Manhattans since they opened over 20 years ago....when it used to just be a small place on Hubertus Road and Johnny was still with us. In all those years, I have never had a bad meal. It has consistently had excellent food and the service I have had has always been friendly and helpful. I continue to go back. Don't have a bad word to say about the place. 
Thomas M.
Went there to pickup a pizza it was ready at the time scheduled the pizza it self is the best I can find in the area and I tried just about everyone around. The only negative thing I can say is they only have one size and it's a large being single the only time I go there is when I have company over (once a month). I would have given them five stars but, due to just having one size I gave them four stars. If they had a medium pizza I would probably be eating there at least once a week if not more.
Everything was wonderful, this place never disappoints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua0 Trewhella
Had the New York strip was very good!The only thing that was understandable but they ran out of Prim rib special.Maybe next time on that.We went there to celebrate my body Richs Birthday. Happy birthday! ? bro
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Schmidt
My wife and I visited Johnny Manhattan's for the first time tonight and we will definitely be back!!!!! From the captivating ambiance, to our most attentive waitress, Rebecca, to the reasonably priced entrees and the large portions of exquisitely prepared food, the restaurant did not miss a beat. My wife's pork chops were HUGE (she now has take home meals for all of next week). My champagne battered cod was the best I have ever had (sorry, Culvers, you are now in second place). But, all that aside, it was Rebecca that raised our experience to another level. She was knowledgeable, attentive and, above all, most pleasant. As I wrote earlier, "We will be back" and we will be sure to ask for Rebecca.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bourbon Peppercorn Sauce, Fish Fry
Dan W
I’ve always had great food and a great experience here. It would be a 5 star review, but tonight we just stopped in for a couple drinks at the bar and I was charged $52 for two pours of Buffalo Trace. That’s just criminal. I know nice places mark up bourbon, but charging $52 for 2 pours from a $24 bottle is ridiculous. I’ll return for the food, but I’ll get my drinks elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ra Na
Crazy sizes, but super nice service!Wheelchair accessibility: Access with wheelchair possible
Very friendly and helpful waitress, Nicole! Loved the ribs and also the steak pasta! Menu had many many options. Ambiance was great with beautiful fireplace and privacy for conversation. Cocktail and wine very satisfactory.
Had the pizza and garlic bread. Always delicious when not in the mood for a full course meal. Super thin crust and tasty. Very good cocktails as well. Been going there for many years.
Very much an enjoyable experience with our group of 6. At nearly $109/pp with a couple inexpensive bottles of wine and drinks, and dessert, it is a bit pricey even with today's pricing. Several had scallops and lobster risotto, couple pork chops all above expectations. Food quality and service (Alex exceptional!) what a tremendously enjoyable evening. We had the crown room so the private dining experience and conversations was above par. Have visited several times previously and will definitely return.
The ambiance, wine list and service were outstanding. We all had entries, several of which were specials yet the entrees were flawed (cold, overcooked, poor presentation). Thank you to our waitress who made the evening enjoyable.
Great experience from start to finish! All the vibes of a supper club with ambiance and amazing drinks. Food was phenomenal. Perfectly cooked to order and the service was outstanding!! Highly recommend
Fantastic food, service and ambiance!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service from beginning to end was outstanding! Food is and has always been great. The host and waitress were personable, polite, prompt and very professional. Thank you, Johnny Manhattan, what a wonderful time we had and plans to come back soon.
The food and ambiance at Johnny Manhattans never disappoints. The service provided by Nicole is amazing. She simply knows how to take care of her guests and enhances the experience at this wonderful establishment. Highly recommended!
I've been going to Johnny Manhattans since they opened over 20 years ago....when it used to just be a small place on Hubertus Road and Johnny was still with us. In all those years, I have never had a bad meal. It has consistently had excellent food and the service I have had has always been friendly and helpful. I continue to go back. Don't have a bad word to say about the place. 
Went there to pickup a pizza it was ready at the time scheduled the pizza it self is the best I can find in the area and I tried just about everyone around. The only negative thing I can say is they only have one size and it's a large being single the only time I go there is when I have company over (once a month). I would have given them five stars but, due to just having one size I gave them four stars. If they had a medium pizza I would probably be eating there at least once a week if not more.
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything was wonderful, this place never disappoints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the New York strip was very good!The only thing that was understandable but they ran out of Prim rib special.Maybe next time on that.We went there to celebrate my body Richs Birthday. Happy birthday! ? bro
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I visited Johnny Manhattan's for the first time tonight and we will definitely be back!!!!! From the captivating ambiance, to our most attentive waitress, Rebecca, to the reasonably priced entrees and the large portions of exquisitely prepared food, the restaurant did not miss a beat. My wife's pork chops were HUGE (she now has take home meals for all of next week). My champagne battered cod was the best I have ever had (sorry, Culvers, you are now in second place). But, all that aside, it was Rebecca that raised our experience to another level. She was knowledgeable, attentive and, above all, most pleasant. As I wrote earlier, "We will be back" and we will be sure to ask for Rebecca.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bourbon Peppercorn Sauce, Fish Fry
I’ve always had great food and a great experience here. It would be a 5 star review, but tonight we just stopped in for a couple drinks at the bar and I was charged $52 for two pours of Buffalo Trace. That’s just criminal. I know nice places mark up bourbon, but charging $52 for 2 pours from a $24 bottle is ridiculous. I’ll return for the food, but I’ll get my drinks elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Crazy sizes, but super nice service!Wheelchair accessibility: Access with wheelchair possible
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5