“It was supposed to be self serve at the bar but we had a wonderful server. We got the chicken special, wing, breast, thigh, and leg along with mashed potatoes gravey, coleslaw and roll only $10.00. I love my food hot and it came out steaming hot. Just wonderful.“
“Great local food! The pizza is cooked very well and every time we come to Rustique, we are impressed. Very good cocktail menu, salads, and pizzas. They will definitely have something that will please everyone on the menu. It is usually busy, but we have never had a long wait!Update: Seven years later and many visits, this review holds up.“
“Always love coming here! Been driving for the last 10 years Atleast. Always delicious and I highly recommend the medium waffle cone twist with chocolate and vanilla. Literally the best thing they have. Sadly the last time I went they were closed for the season! Definitely remember to check out their Facebook before making the drive.“
“Went with some friends for dinner, clean plates all around! Cheese curds were divine with that smoked tomato jam! Salmon, lamb burger, and filet were all fantastic. Finished with the gelato and Crème brûlée… both delicious! Great atmosphere inside, and even had a mocktail list to keep those dry Jan goals alive. We’ll be back often!“
“Great little place. Mondays are $2 burgers. They are the best $2 burgers money can buy. Service is wonderful and friendly. Keep in mind it's not a white linen eatery, it's a great little bar just trying to make it in this crazy world and doing a great job at it.“
“First time ever stopping at this establishment. Last Friday night about 6pm. It's very clear there is a specific crowd of regulars catered to here over all others. Wait staff was great, when we saw her... Ten minute wait for a mixer refill isn't all that bad in a packed house. We get it. You're Chambers Hill, you're busy.One hour and thirty five minute wait on the fish plates. That to me is kind of ridiculous. Anywhere else in brown county you will be under an hour, even at River St Pier, the Rite Place, Redwood etc.Perch plate was so salty I couldn't even finish it. Could be a fluke batch of breading? Other halfs plate was perfect. Fries are to die for. Slaw and bread that comes with the perch are also perfect.Great if you have some time to kill. Not so great if you've worked up an appetite on a Friday along with a powerful thirst. Probably have to be at this place well before 5 on a Friday without having a long wait. You'll be tipsy by the time your food arrives otherwise.“
“Been searching all over for the best fish fry to my tastes. I am very fussy! I have found it right here! The fish is crispy, which is the way it is supposed to be. We ordered the Pollock and it was so delicious! The french fries were perfectly done and the beans were exactly the way they are supposed to be, a bit sweet and tender as the rye bread was super fresh. We will always come here from now on, and the good thing is, it is close to home. Thanks to you all for such a wonderful experience as we have now found our absolute favorite Friday night Fish spot!“
“I love Kacey the Bartender she's Alway's so friendly no matter how busy even serving food and drinks very on top of thing's and the food is Wonderful!!! Great Family BarParking: Parking lotKid-friendliness: Oh yeahWheelchair accessibility: I think a ramp??“
“Adorable atmosphere. Fantastic service. Drinks were great! Food was awesome. First time dining, and will be back. Pricy food? Sure. Worth it? Absolutely. You are paying for taste, presentation, service, and ambiance. All categories got an A+ from my boyfriend and I.“
“True Wisconsin Supper Club. Excellent service from start to finish. Food was a little rushed as they forgot to bring out our chicken gizzard spread and liver patee, but both were delicious. Fish and chicken breading is unique and very crispy. Brandy Alexander and grasshoppers were also delicious. Both the tenderloin and Ribeye were cooked to perfection. Love the old school vibe with great patrons.“
“Stopped on a Sunday afternoon after visiting the zoo.The bourbon cheeseburger is awesome. The bartenders were friendly, and made us some very satisfying drinks.It had a cozy atmosphere.Will definitely go back the next time we're in the area.“