Potbelly

$ • Sandwich Shops, Fast Food, Salad

Hours:
2245 Zeier Rd, Madison
(608) 819-5022

Customers' Favorites

Potbelly Sandwich Shop Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
2.7 (41)
Restaurantji Rating

When ordering off the menu when they ask you what you want, specify exactly what you want on it, because if you say everything on it, everything on the entire menu is put on the sandwich, not everything that the menu says comes on the sandwich. Still good but for a sandwich with no mods make sure to say just what comes on the menu

Restaurantji Rating

The staff seemed annoyed that we even came here… as if we were intruding on a party we weren’t invited to. The amount of meat given was utterly abysmal. If a sandwich costs $10, I expect more than 25 cents worth of meat on it. Go to any other potbelly if you actually want a hearty sandwich. First time Potbelly’s has ever let me down. They are normally very generous with their meat portions, hence my return visits to this establishment.

Restaurantji Rating

This was takeout, 4 sandwiches. I always order A Wreck Skinny with double meat. My wife did an online order and didn't request the double meat. The sandwich had barely 2 slices of meat, should have been one of each kind for a total of 4 slices, and a measly little thin THIN slice of cheese. Mostly I had a bread sandwich. The other 3 sandwiches were ok.

More Reviews(136)

Ratings

Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Potbelly
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 9AM - 10PM
Tuesday 9AM - 10PM
Wednesday 9AM - 10PM
Thursday 9AM - 10PM
Friday 9AM - 10PM
Saturday 9AM - 10PM
Sunday 9AM - 10PM
Updated on: