Had the walley sandwich and it was quite salty, as were the fries. $7 Old Fashioned was good. Wouldn't really call it a supper club as it still feels like Pasquals on the inside.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Sir Pants
The brunch menu's double smash burger with a fried egg added was amazing. Whatever they do to the bacon on the burger is magical. The donut trio was good. I wish my wife's French toast was as good. The French toast wasn't very eggy at all and it was very moist, not in a good way. Good presentation on all of the above. I'd go back for all but the French toast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Trisha T
It took us a second to finally get here but we’re big fans now that we have! My husband got the burger which was very flavorful, and I got the walleye sandwich which was popping with flavor too! We also got the tartar and the iceberg salad, and we liked both of them too! The drinks were also nice - the Manhattan on the menu was the best I’ve had!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smash Burger
Mike Garvey
Casual chic environment. Great food, tasty craft cocktails. Friendly, relaxed service. A perfect spot for an enjoyable "supper club" evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Brian Oelberg
Different twist on classic supper club offerings, but all delicious.Pork chop with cherry compote was superb. Had the charred carrots based on reviews and they did not disappoint, unusual and delicious.The burnt apple jam cake was absolutely amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Charred Carrots
Steve Bernardo
Drinks are very expensive, $13 for a vodka martini. The fish fry was just ok. Service was good though.
Dawn Johnson
If you go to this place for drinks, and the bill is $22.51 for 2 drinks. And you pay with cash then they round up the price to $23.00 for the 2 drinks. They don’t want to have change in their cash register so they just take your change and keep it!!!!! What if Walmart did that? This cannot be legal!!! I will never return to this place!!
Service: 1
Ariana Sweeney-Field
Loved the food, service, and atmosphere. Very vibey and chill environment. Went for brunch on Sunday, it was absolutely fantastic. Will definitely be going back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charity Faith
Stopped here for dinner, and to try their fish fry. The fish fry was decent, but the beer batter was very heavy and thick in some parts. It seemed like you were having mostly batter. Their falafel sandwich was incredible, vegan aïoli, fresh, cucumbers, pickled onions, and fresh herbs.hands-down it was the best falafel sandwich I ever had. They gave an incredibly generous amount of french fries. The Wisconsin old-fashioned came with a cheese curd and maraschino cherry. The prices were reasonable. The atmosphere was quaint. The relish tray was fantastic and included their housemate chips and delicious dips. The pickled eggs were interesting. I have never had pickled eggs before, so I’m not the best judge.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Fries
Penny Lundgren
Wonderful atmosphere. Servers were amazing. Friendly ,informative,and upbeat! Entrees fell
Made reservations for a Thursday night. I had the trout which was very good but my only complaint was that it was a little bit too salty. The veggies…very tasty! My husband and niece had the steak which had good flavor but described it as stringy. Had left over steak at home the next morning and we thought it was pretty good (but overpriced). If they are going to call themselves a supper club, a better steak option or a couple options might help. For the kids, they enjoyed the buttered noodles, French fries and cheeseburgers. Loved the atmosphere! Very good service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fettuccine, Fries, Crispy Lake Trout
Jahlieh R. Henderson
Super swanky supper club vibe. Great servers. Delicious food. Get the relish tray and the cheese puppies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds, Smash Burger
Jerry McLain
I wanted to like this place in the worst way. Parking was awesome. Rare at best in the near downtown area. Our host seemed put off by us wanting to start with a cocktail , isn’t that Supper Club 101?First strike, no kids menu and clearly no understanding towards our kids. Cool but your food better be great. 2nd strike Fish Fry Haddock only no Walleye or Cod. Supper Club?I want to stop here to acknowledge the vibe is a bit alternative and the patrons dig it. That is cool but not what I angle for in a Supper Club.Old Fashions +Ok, Strike 3 for us…A super club that can’t put any cheese on a burger except smoked gouda.End of the night $200, little North of typical Supper Club.Hurts me to say, I won’t be back. ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Drew Leja
Situated in a historic building, the entrees and appetizers were prepared with great care and were delicious! Try the "Devils on Horseback" or the carmelized carrots to start. The staff recommended the Pull Tab Steak but the curried gnocchi was impressive as was the tagliatelle pasta.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pam J.
Our favorite date place in Madison. Love the cocktails, ambiance and great service. My favorite meal is the smash burger with a side of fries and aioli. Cocktails change often which is fun to see what they come up with. Also in summer they have outdoor seating which we take advantage of. Great place!
Had the walley sandwich and it was quite salty, as were the fries. $7 Old Fashioned was good. Wouldn't really call it a supper club as it still feels like Pasquals on the inside.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
The brunch menu's double smash burger with a fried egg added was amazing. Whatever they do to the bacon on the burger is magical. The donut trio was good. I wish my wife's French toast was as good. The French toast wasn't very eggy at all and it was very moist, not in a good way. Good presentation on all of the above. I'd go back for all but the French toast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
It took us a second to finally get here but we’re big fans now that we have! My husband got the burger which was very flavorful, and I got the walleye sandwich which was popping with flavor too! We also got the tartar and the iceberg salad, and we liked both of them too! The drinks were also nice - the Manhattan on the menu was the best I’ve had!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smash Burger
Casual chic environment. Great food, tasty craft cocktails. Friendly, relaxed service. A perfect spot for an enjoyable "supper club" evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Different twist on classic supper club offerings, but all delicious.Pork chop with cherry compote was superb. Had the charred carrots based on reviews and they did not disappoint, unusual and delicious.The burnt apple jam cake was absolutely amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Charred Carrots
Drinks are very expensive, $13 for a vodka martini. The fish fry was just ok. Service was good though.
If you go to this place for drinks, and the bill is $22.51 for 2 drinks. And you pay with cash then they round up the price to $23.00 for the 2 drinks. They don’t want to have change in their cash register so they just take your change and keep it!!!!! What if Walmart did that? This cannot be legal!!! I will never return to this place!!
Service: 1
Loved the food, service, and atmosphere. Very vibey and chill environment. Went for brunch on Sunday, it was absolutely fantastic. Will definitely be going back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped here for dinner, and to try their fish fry. The fish fry was decent, but the beer batter was very heavy and thick in some parts. It seemed like you were having mostly batter. Their falafel sandwich was incredible, vegan aïoli, fresh, cucumbers, pickled onions, and fresh herbs.hands-down it was the best falafel sandwich I ever had. They gave an incredibly generous amount of french fries. The Wisconsin old-fashioned came with a cheese curd and maraschino cherry. The prices were reasonable. The atmosphere was quaint. The relish tray was fantastic and included their housemate chips and delicious dips. The pickled eggs were interesting. I have never had pickled eggs before, so I’m not the best judge.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Fries
Wonderful atmosphere. Servers were amazing. Friendly ,informative,and upbeat! Entrees fell
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Made reservations for a Thursday night. I had the trout which was very good but my only complaint was that it was a little bit too salty. The veggies…very tasty! My husband and niece had the steak which had good flavor but described it as stringy. Had left over steak at home the next morning and we thought it was pretty good (but overpriced). If they are going to call themselves a supper club, a better steak option or a couple options might help. For the kids, they enjoyed the buttered noodles, French fries and cheeseburgers. Loved the atmosphere! Very good service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fettuccine, Fries, Crispy Lake Trout
Super swanky supper club vibe. Great servers. Delicious food. Get the relish tray and the cheese puppies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds, Smash Burger
I wanted to like this place in the worst way. Parking was awesome. Rare at best in the near downtown area. Our host seemed put off by us wanting to start with a cocktail , isn’t that Supper Club 101?First strike, no kids menu and clearly no understanding towards our kids. Cool but your food better be great. 2nd strike Fish Fry Haddock only no Walleye or Cod. Supper Club?I want to stop here to acknowledge the vibe is a bit alternative and the patrons dig it. That is cool but not what I angle for in a Supper Club.Old Fashions +Ok, Strike 3 for us…A super club that can’t put any cheese on a burger except smoked gouda.End of the night $200, little North of typical Supper Club.Hurts me to say, I won’t be back. ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Situated in a historic building, the entrees and appetizers were prepared with great care and were delicious! Try the "Devils on Horseback" or the carmelized carrots to start. The staff recommended the Pull Tab Steak but the curried gnocchi was impressive as was the tagliatelle pasta.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our favorite date place in Madison. Love the cocktails, ambiance and great service. My favorite meal is the smash burger with a side of fries and aioli. Cocktails change often which is fun to see what they come up with. Also in summer they have outdoor seating which we take advantage of. Great place!