Asadero Fiesta Garibaldi

3086 S 20th St, Milwaukee
(414) 988-9527

Recent Reviews

Imani Ryan

Went to the restaurant for a second time tonight, was not at all disappointed! Receive complementary drinks upon arrival. My party was immediately seated with no reservations. The food looks beautiful and tasted even better! Our waiter was amazing, The show that he puts on when you order a steak is so cool! ? I will be back for sure. Definitely doesn’t feel like a Milwaukee experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chiken Alfredo, Steak

Jennifer Ward

Oh my the food is divine. I got a skirt steak w grilled veggies. Wonderful drinks. If you love quality steaks you have to try it. We went in Monday for a bday celebration and really felt like a place ill come back to again and again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mashed Potato, Steak

Douglas Roa

Quality

Jeffrey Kleczka

What a great dining experience. Everything was deliciously prepared, amazingly flavorful. Our waiter “Shorty” did a great job making recommendations, we crushed the menu and will be back soon and often. Run don’t walk to this southside gem.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari Calamar Frito, Steak

Sarah Mueller

I think they could have potential but definitely need some work. The creativity is there but the execution needs improvement. The presentation of the food was very nice however none of our food was served very hot. We had the Pardilla platter and steak tacos. All the meat on the platter was like warm at best. The chicken was very dry, the steaks were very rare and we had asked for medium rare. Everything just tasted charred, not actual flavor. Even the the loaded baked potato was charred. Their house made breads and sauces were the best part of our meal. If they want to charge those menu prices they really need to step up the quality of the food. You can get $16 tacos anywhere and the bone marrow that comes with those was mediocre basically just grease. I’d rather have rice and beans. The elote was our other side and that was just room temp charred corn with tajin sprinkled on it. I will say the blueberry margarita was fantastic. Servers were very kind. I laughed a little when I asked what they’d recommended from the menu and of course it was the most expensive item on the menu- the tomahawk steak. If I’m paying $150+ for dinner for two I’d expect to be wowed or at least hot food. Most likely a one and done for us.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Edwardo Villor

The food was amazing and the waiter was very attentive and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bread Bowl with Dipping Sauce, The Garibaldino Special, Rockefeller Oysters

Randall

Absolutely terrible service!!!! I waited for the bill for over a half hour while the waiter/owner took shots with another table. Then waited 20 minutes for my change from the bill. NWVER AGAIN!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Adrienne Torres

We came for happy hour which is from 4:30-630. However, when we asked staff, what was the happy hour menu or specials, they said there was no happy hour. Clearly, they do have a happy hour because online they post all about their happy hours. Then, after five minutes of talking to one another, they determine that there is happy hour which they were planning on having a menu for that they’re still working on. Their happy hour is $6 dollar margaritas and a $10 special on wings. After talking, they said six wings and you choose between 2 flavors. To me the happy hour on the margaritas is a great deal, but six wings that is not a deal at all. However, once our food came, it wasn’t just six wings it came with celery, carrots, and french fries so then for $10 it makes sense. The wings were average, one wing tasted as if it was re-heated or old? Considering we were the first people at the bar ordering food and no one else was seated in the dining area I would expect my food to be hot. There was new staff training behind the bar, which is understandable. I ordered a passionfruit margarita on the rocks. The first one was good. The second one didn’t compare to the first one, and the same bartender made the drink. And to be honest I seen the bartender try her drink she just made with the end of a straw, not only to put that same straw back into the drink for a customer. This place has been opened since before June If I’m not mistaken I think that’s plenty of time to have a developed happy hour menu. I’m glad I just tried here for a quick drink before bringing my girls or friends here for happy hour. Because this place isn’t it….

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

David Mascari

Spectacular food and amazing service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jomo Taylor

Delicious food with great cuts of steaks. Good tequila selection. The flowers & micro greens are pretty but they give aesthetic with no substance when it comes to the plates. Hope they have their cocktail menu ready next time I come. It's a fun date, group or family night spot. The Waiter we had, short Latino guy(I'm drawing a blank on his name), great guy a with a lot of character. Definitely go there if you have a birthday. They'll make you feel special. Order the tomahawk. Just trust me. I didn't & I regret it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Loaded Bake Potato

l

Food was just okay. They offered a birthday cake slice but then charged full price for it on the bill. When some other restaurants ask you if you would like one, it’s complimentary. If they would’ve said that it would be charged on the bill when they offered unprompted, that would be a different situation, otherwise it’s deceitful. It’s extra shady because it’s an expensive restaurant, with very expensive bills—they can afford it. People go to restaurants for the experience, so it soured the whole visit and memory of going there, especially since it was for a special occasion.(There are more things that contributed to rating, but this review is lengthy enough)

Jennifer Lovinus

Made a reservation and had to wait 40min for our table. While waiting at the bar, no one acknowledged us or was willing to get us a drink. Waited at the table forever for drinks and food. Margaritas didn’t taste like

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Celena Phommachanh

I had high hopes for the bone marrow tacos but was left disappointed. I received 3 bones and they barely had any marrow in it. I was lucky to get enough for one taco. I also ordered a cheeseburger and the bottom of the bun was left very burnt and the burger was extremely dry. On the plus side, the customer service was very friendly and I enjoyed the atmosphere but won’t be coming back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Bei Xaya

This place was a real disappointment when it came to food, but customer service and food presentation was good. The Steaks were okay, but who can't make a descent steak as long as there's a good dipping sauce to eat with it. I had the baked potato and French onion soup and those were terrible. We also had the fired calamari which turned out to be not good. We ordered drinks that were watered down. We had a table of 8 and our bill was almost $800. This place was a one and done for me. I'll never waste my money here again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Marlina Maly

I’ve been here twice. And both times I made reservations weeks in advance and still had to wait 15 minutes to be seated. The second time, the waiters took forever to give us menus and take our orders. We were seated for a whole hour, before an appetizer came out. Will not be returning.Parking: The parking lot only has about 10 spots. Otherwise you need to find street parking on ONE side of the street. Although it is a pretty small restaurant.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Prime Rib Taco

Load More