Wanted to get a quick lunch, and with the place basically being dead when we got there you would assume quick service wouldn't be an issue...we waited 30 minutes just to get an appetizer of okay fries and only then did she take our official order which took 45+ minutes to come out. There were maybe 5 other customers in the entire place...Makes sense though, because they have an automatic 20% gratuity (no warning or heads up about this when we were given the check..and there was only 3 of us), so the waitress knew she'd get a nice tip no matter how terrible her service was.I've heard good things about this place, bummer that we had such a poor and overpriced experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Caroline Cavalcante
Excellent spot for great food in Milwaukee. But the pancake batter cheesecurds are THE
One of our go-to places for happy hour! They have great drink deals and the food is also so good. I normally get the house sangria but this time I tried some sour cherry and lime spritzer. It wasn't on the menu for some reason but the bartender recommended it, as it's very popular. for food, we went with the breakfast poutine - always a good choice. And we tried the pancake batter fried cheese curds which were AMAZING. They come with maple syrup for dipping and it's unreal. Such a cute spot and it never disappoints!
Alyssa H.
I had read about this place being one of the must do places in Milwaukee and I see why. We came for lunch and one of the best things is they offer 1/2 off starters and $3 taps. They offer brunch every day which is great! Why does brunch have to just be on the weekend?? Everything here was delicious and very fresh. The service was great and it was a super cool vibe too. I don't think anything here is bad.
Allison H.
Brunch risotto changed my life!! Something I never knew I needed until I had it and I swear I can't go to black sheep for brunch with out ordering it!! I believe it does slightly change seasonally but every time I've had it the risotto has been so, so good! I also love coming to black sheep for their sangria (one of the best in Milwaukee in my opinion, and even better when it's happy hour!!) whether sitting at the bar or in the back corner booth the service as black sheep has never disappointed.
Dave Beaumier
Great place for lunch with nice specials for food and drink.
A great place for a decadent date night. All the food was perfectly prepared. Flavors are very rich, intense, and fantastically balanced. Not really much "light fare" to be had. Cocktails were similar, bold strong and balanced flavors. Love it. The ambiance is dark and tasteful. I like the lighting and the layers of design in the space. Service was good, but could have been a little more attentive. (They gave us a small 4oz water glass, and didn't refill the whole meal. With my spicy chicken sandwich, and jalapeño cocktail, I was craving more water to put out the flames.) My biggest complaint is the noise level. With the brick walls and hard floors, conversation noise bounces all over, and one must yell to be heard. Some acoustic treatments would help tremendously.
Abby M.
I have been to Black Sheep multiple times and have absolutely loved it every time! Their house sangria during happy hour is such a steal, I highly recommend their Salmon BLT during their lunch hour, the Brussel Sprouts, and their truffle fries as well. The waitstaff is always super friendly, I would also recommend a reservation during their happy hour to ensure you get a table. Definitely one of my favorite restaurants in Milwaukee!
Jenna Klaus
Went for Brunch and enjoyed the Pancake Battered Cheese Curds, delicious and great for 3-4 people. The Chilaquiles was a perfect size. It appeared to have no chorizo on it so it was sent back to the kitchen and I was informed they added more. Chorizo was not spicy, the dish had good flavors!Service was good and they have a button at your table for when you are ready or need or a server. The server was attentive to our table and we used the button once.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Rachel L.
Like, don't love this place. Food, decent. Drinks, decent. I'm sorry but there is nothing drawing me in for more. Service is kind, staff nice enough. Location is great! But nothing really wowed me. If you are in Milwaukee and looking for a casual bar for a decent drink, definitely check it out!
Mark S.
Scotty was our bartender. First time here in search of a happy hour. Glad we came. Scotty was very knowledgeable and gave great advice on drinks and appetizers. The pancake batter cheese curds were awesome. Definitely can't go wrong with the roasted brussel sprouts either. Scotty, thanks for the experience.
Wanted to get a quick lunch, and with the place basically being dead when we got there you would assume quick service wouldn't be an issue...we waited 30 minutes just to get an appetizer of okay fries and only then did she take our official order which took 45+ minutes to come out. There were maybe 5 other customers in the entire place...Makes sense though, because they have an automatic 20% gratuity (no warning or heads up about this when we were given the check..and there was only 3 of us), so the waitress knew she'd get a nice tip no matter how terrible her service was.I've heard good things about this place, bummer that we had such a poor and overpriced experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Excellent spot for great food in Milwaukee. But the pancake batter cheesecurds are THE
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Avocado Toast, Truffle Fries, Biscuits & Gravy, Pancake Battered Cheese Curds
One of our go-to places for happy hour! They have great drink deals and the food is also so good. I normally get the house sangria but this time I tried some sour cherry and lime spritzer. It wasn't on the menu for some reason but the bartender recommended it, as it's very popular. for food, we went with the breakfast poutine - always a good choice. And we tried the pancake batter fried cheese curds which were AMAZING. They come with maple syrup for dipping and it's unreal. Such a cute spot and it never disappoints!
I had read about this place being one of the must do places in Milwaukee and I see why. We came for lunch and one of the best things is they offer 1/2 off starters and $3 taps. They offer brunch every day which is great! Why does brunch have to just be on the weekend?? Everything here was delicious and very fresh. The service was great and it was a super cool vibe too. I don't think anything here is bad.
Brunch risotto changed my life!! Something I never knew I needed until I had it and I swear I can't go to black sheep for brunch with out ordering it!! I believe it does slightly change seasonally but every time I've had it the risotto has been so, so good! I also love coming to black sheep for their sangria (one of the best in Milwaukee in my opinion, and even better when it's happy hour!!) whether sitting at the bar or in the back corner booth the service as black sheep has never disappointed.
Great place for lunch with nice specials for food and drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pancake Battered Cheese Curds, Brunch Poutine
The atmosphere was great. Very cool place. I had the golden beet salad. Less beets than you would think. ? I would return to try something else.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Haley was the most amazing server and I will be back all the time. So fun and friendly! Love the happy hour sangria.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great. Service was excellent! Maddie was a wonderful server and a pleasure to chat with! Good night all around, def recommend.
Celebrated Valentine's Day with my partner and had the best service, food, and drinks. Maddie was the absolute best and made our night memorable!
Restaurantji Recommends
A great place for a decadent date night. All the food was perfectly prepared. Flavors are very rich, intense, and fantastically balanced. Not really much "light fare" to be had. Cocktails were similar, bold strong and balanced flavors. Love it. The ambiance is dark and tasteful. I like the lighting and the layers of design in the space. Service was good, but could have been a little more attentive. (They gave us a small 4oz water glass, and didn't refill the whole meal. With my spicy chicken sandwich, and jalapeño cocktail, I was craving more water to put out the flames.) My biggest complaint is the noise level. With the brick walls and hard floors, conversation noise bounces all over, and one must yell to be heard. Some acoustic treatments would help tremendously.
I have been to Black Sheep multiple times and have absolutely loved it every time! Their house sangria during happy hour is such a steal, I highly recommend their Salmon BLT during their lunch hour, the Brussel Sprouts, and their truffle fries as well. The waitstaff is always super friendly, I would also recommend a reservation during their happy hour to ensure you get a table. Definitely one of my favorite restaurants in Milwaukee!
Went for Brunch and enjoyed the Pancake Battered Cheese Curds, delicious and great for 3-4 people. The Chilaquiles was a perfect size. It appeared to have no chorizo on it so it was sent back to the kitchen and I was informed they added more. Chorizo was not spicy, the dish had good flavors!Service was good and they have a button at your table for when you are ready or need or a server. The server was attentive to our table and we used the button once.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Like, don't love this place. Food, decent. Drinks, decent. I'm sorry but there is nothing drawing me in for more. Service is kind, staff nice enough. Location is great! But nothing really wowed me. If you are in Milwaukee and looking for a casual bar for a decent drink, definitely check it out!
Scotty was our bartender. First time here in search of a happy hour. Glad we came. Scotty was very knowledgeable and gave great advice on drinks and appetizers. The pancake batter cheese curds were awesome. Definitely can't go wrong with the roasted brussel sprouts either. Scotty, thanks for the experience.