Great pizza and breadsticks, great atmosphere, 5 star service! Will definitely come again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Garlic Bread Strips
Aidan Donahoe
Hands down the best thin crust in Milwaukee, maybe the only flawless pizza in the city.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza
Samella J.
They have the best pizza and are always so welcoming. Prices are reasonable and the food and service are excellent.
Michael Veloskey
Pizza was good. Their menu online says the pizza we ordered was $20.90. When I got there, they charged me $29.75. That's quite a difference. Did I get over charged? Is the pricing on your own website wrong?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
Mike Zussman
You want a snapshot of what it’s like to grow up in Milwaukee, this is it! I remember when I was growing up, restaurant owners would often give special attention to the kids, special treats, little toys, etc. it’s hard to find that kind of care, but Cardaro’s provides that type of service. If you eat there, plan on having Gary (front of house) sit down and share stories with you, he’s the best! This place cares so much about making their customers comfortable.Then the pizza came… it was awesome. We did half green peppers/tomatoes and half The Special. Everything about it was delicious and you can tell Wally (the owner) takes such pride in making his pies… he even takes pictures of his best work. We will be back for both the pizza and their friendliness!Kid-friendliness: If you bring your kid(s), they will be well taken care of!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Special Pizza
Jim Engeriser
Why is Caradaro Club Pizza Milwaukee the best in the USA? There's this fight between NYC pizza and Chicago pizza. I get it. New York City pizza has an ingenious chemistry of flavor. Fold it in half and walk down the street and you are John Travolta in 1977. It's Awesome. Chicago deep dish is a pot pie of Italian flavor scoop after scoop! Yum! Don't choke on that crust! I'm just taking this little time out to tell you what I love. Caradaro pizza landed directly to Milwaukee in 1945. It is realistically crust to top the best you will taste. This is the pizza that came to America to stay! From your grandparents to grandchildren, taste it, ask around, and you will definitely get it. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick
Great pizza, friendly service, low key inside. They have a thin crust that is more St. Louis style than NY style. Highly recommend.
Nicole Holm
Gary, the owner, is amazing! He is super friendly and the atmosphereis great!! Best pizza we have ever had!!! Blows Zaffaros out of the water!! Thin crispy crust, well-balanced flavor and amazing service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Mozzarella Marinara, The Special Pizza
Denise Johnson-Sherard
Great crispy, thin crust pizza right in my neighborhood! Wally, and others are really friendly folks. It's definitely worth the short wait for a freshly made and hot pizza pie!! Have a glass of wine ? while ya wait!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Daniel Stevens
Pizza lived up to everything I want in a thin crust pizza. Crust was ultra thin, but crispy with bubble pockets. Sauce was sweet and delicious. The rest of the ingredients were decent. Overall, this is without a doubt, the best thin crust pizza within 20 miles or more for the best value. Worker was incredibly friendly and inviting. Definitely an older restaurant but you will not regret eating food here.
Pizza taste very good. I will continue to order pizza from here.cheesy garlic bread and club fries taste soo good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Large Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread
Aja Allen
I hate to do this but very disappointing. Had high expectations looked great but overall the pizza wasn't cooked long enough and on top of that I believe I've been Overcharged. Guy who took my order on the phone took way too long adding up my total and when he finally said $23.42 it didn't sound right. On top of that I didn't even get a receipt either from the delivery guy which made me even further believe they overcharged me because they may or may not have known I'm a person of color ordereing from their establishment. $23.42 for a small 3 topping pizza and a can soda.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Bethany Auble
We wanted to try a new pizza place on a random Friday evening, and we played restaurant roulette to find Caradaro Pizza Club on Vliet St. The gentleman who served us was just a gem! He spoke to our kids, brought them a halloween toy, and took time to chat. My family felt truly at home in this lovely space! We want to send a heartfelt thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Klawikowski
My wife and I ate there last week, and even though they were hosting a large tour group, they're still able to give us personal and attentive service! The pizza- - oh my goodness it was so good! The cheesy garlic bread really sent it over the top! They have a great wine and beer selection to compliment their incredible pizzas! Gary was a gracious host and very attentive- we will be going there again most definitely!
Ron D.
Best thin crust pizza in MKE . Crispy flaky crust top with SMO - Sausage Mushrooms Onion, that's MKE style pizza. It so good. If your into thin crust , it's a must try when in MKE . Not only you'll learn a little bit of Pizza history but also leave satisfied.
Great pizza and breadsticks, great atmosphere, 5 star service! Will definitely come again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Garlic Bread Strips
Hands down the best thin crust in Milwaukee, maybe the only flawless pizza in the city.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza
They have the best pizza and are always so welcoming. Prices are reasonable and the food and service are excellent.
Pizza was good. Their menu online says the pizza we ordered was $20.90. When I got there, they charged me $29.75. That's quite a difference. Did I get over charged? Is the pricing on your own website wrong?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
You want a snapshot of what it’s like to grow up in Milwaukee, this is it! I remember when I was growing up, restaurant owners would often give special attention to the kids, special treats, little toys, etc. it’s hard to find that kind of care, but Cardaro’s provides that type of service. If you eat there, plan on having Gary (front of house) sit down and share stories with you, he’s the best! This place cares so much about making their customers comfortable.Then the pizza came… it was awesome. We did half green peppers/tomatoes and half The Special. Everything about it was delicious and you can tell Wally (the owner) takes such pride in making his pies… he even takes pictures of his best work. We will be back for both the pizza and their friendliness!Kid-friendliness: If you bring your kid(s), they will be well taken care of!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Special Pizza
Why is Caradaro Club Pizza Milwaukee the best in the USA? There's this fight between NYC pizza and Chicago pizza. I get it. New York City pizza has an ingenious chemistry of flavor. Fold it in half and walk down the street and you are John Travolta in 1977. It's Awesome. Chicago deep dish is a pot pie of Italian flavor scoop after scoop! Yum! Don't choke on that crust! I'm just taking this little time out to tell you what I love. Caradaro pizza landed directly to Milwaukee in 1945. It is realistically crust to top the best you will taste. This is the pizza that came to America to stay! From your grandparents to grandchildren, taste it, ask around, and you will definitely get it. :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, friendly service, low key inside. They have a thin crust that is more St. Louis style than NY style. Highly recommend.
Gary, the owner, is amazing! He is super friendly and the atmosphereis great!! Best pizza we have ever had!!! Blows Zaffaros out of the water!! Thin crispy crust, well-balanced flavor and amazing service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Mozzarella Marinara, The Special Pizza
Great crispy, thin crust pizza right in my neighborhood! Wally, and others are really friendly folks. It's definitely worth the short wait for a freshly made and hot pizza pie!! Have a glass of wine ? while ya wait!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Pizza lived up to everything I want in a thin crust pizza. Crust was ultra thin, but crispy with bubble pockets. Sauce was sweet and delicious. The rest of the ingredients were decent. Overall, this is without a doubt, the best thin crust pizza within 20 miles or more for the best value. Worker was incredibly friendly and inviting. Definitely an older restaurant but you will not regret eating food here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza taste very good. I will continue to order pizza from here.cheesy garlic bread and club fries taste soo good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Large Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread
I hate to do this but very disappointing. Had high expectations looked great but overall the pizza wasn't cooked long enough and on top of that I believe I've been Overcharged. Guy who took my order on the phone took way too long adding up my total and when he finally said $23.42 it didn't sound right. On top of that I didn't even get a receipt either from the delivery guy which made me even further believe they overcharged me because they may or may not have known I'm a person of color ordereing from their establishment. $23.42 for a small 3 topping pizza and a can soda.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
We wanted to try a new pizza place on a random Friday evening, and we played restaurant roulette to find Caradaro Pizza Club on Vliet St. The gentleman who served us was just a gem! He spoke to our kids, brought them a halloween toy, and took time to chat. My family felt truly at home in this lovely space! We want to send a heartfelt thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I ate there last week, and even though they were hosting a large tour group, they're still able to give us personal and attentive service! The pizza- - oh my goodness it was so good! The cheesy garlic bread really sent it over the top! They have a great wine and beer selection to compliment their incredible pizzas! Gary was a gracious host and very attentive- we will be going there again most definitely!
Best thin crust pizza in MKE . Crispy flaky crust top with SMO - Sausage Mushrooms Onion, that's MKE style pizza. It so good. If your into thin crust , it's a must try when in MKE . Not only you'll learn a little bit of Pizza history but also leave satisfied.