The best fish fry in Milwaukee. You can't beat all you can eat. Randy's will be surely missed. Get it while you still can.
Barbara Thompson Roethle
My husband heard great things about the fish fry so we stopped by, he loved it!! I had the burger, very good. We will stop by again.
tab blomberg
Small place...should make reservations for fish fry Friday. Fish fry is all you can it and it was good. Also had a appetizer platter that was good. Prices were reasonable.
Toni Toni
We had a wonderful fish fry at Randy's and we will definitely be back. We did arrive early hoping to grab a table because reservations do book up quickly. We were fortunate to be seated immediately, and wish we had brought a bigger appetite. The fish was perfectly cooked, the fries were crispy, the coleslaw was creamy and the potato salad was simply delicious. Definitely one the best in town.
Barbara E.
The best fish fry in Milwaukee, bar none! I travel from Texas for this fish fry every summer
Katherine S.
First time stopping in to this neighborhood jewel for their fish fry. Everyone I was with greatly enjoyed the experience and would highly recommend their Friday Fish fry to anyone who enjoys a good, classic and delicious dinner experience!
John Scott Rugg
(Recently edited, but visit's ~1mo. ago; Still germane, though.)I don't know what's changed here!?, or seems different...but this place seemed less than "neighborly" when compared to previous visits. The food was O.K...or even GOOD, but the service & price was akin to an "oil spill in the gulf"; toxic and costly; in that order!!!That being said, they were less than friendly, in fact blatantly offensive. Frankly, I'm at a loss here, but it may just explain why, for being a Friday nite, they were NEARLY EMPTY when, in the past they WERE "bursting at the seams". Left not much of a tip,...except for maybe the fish; like 'Look for a different Sea!'I guess "neighborhoods" DO change.Some can even turn Snotty! But don't blame this on the pandemic...'SNEIGHBOR'?!!!
Scootaloo prime
Took a while to get a table and the food was ok just didn't like weight for 50 minutes to get the bill
Nick Podushak
Fish was okay, so were the French fries. It's all you can eat. Service was a mix, waitress was nice but had no plates when the fish came and they forgot the bread and coleslaw.The place is a dump and not conducive to eating. Kind of like eating on card tables in my parents basement in the '60s and '70s.
Scott L.
Get there while you have time--sounds like they are going to close some time this summer. Friendly people in a very nice neighborhood bar. Fish fry is excellent--order in advance, or take your chances on Friday! Lots of regulars who enjoy this fun spot.
Amazing staff and service. Delicious All you can eat fish fry at a good price.
P. Kahn
Had to try out the fish fry here after hearing so much about it being the classic and it didn't disappoint. A total "dive" bar feel with a local atmosphere and a traditional fish fry. Food came out piping hot and even though it was all you can eat, the portion they brought out for the 3 of us to start was more than enough. All of it was very good. Give it a try!
Chas Rooney
Local Mom and Pop Restaurant. It is my preferred method of dining. Every 5 star review they have received is accurate. The All you can eat Friday Fish Fry is delicious AND they do not skimp. I was amazed at the portions. Even when I asked for a side of mayonnaise they gave me a bowl of mayo. WOW!!!I would give them 6 stars if they had potato pancakes. ???❤❤❤
Virginia S.
Fantastic fish fry!!! Great prices and delicious cocktails. Wonderful servers and staff. I love that it's an all you can eat family style fish fry our server was so sweet and prompt bringing extra fish and lemons.
Erin P.
No frills/divey, neighborhood joint with a dining room of about 12 tables on one side and a bar with 3-4 hightops and bar service on the other side. You enter through the bar and it was packed with regulars-the kind place where everyone knows everyone. Luckily we were able to get two seats at the bar right away as reservations are recommended and the business they turn is nonstop. Although there is a small menu available with standard bar food and apps- it was Friday and we didn't see one order that wasn't their AYCE family style fish fry, which is what we had. The fish is lightly breaded- almost a dusting. The cod is meaty and each piece cooked to perfection served with fresh rye bread, green cole slaw, and your choice of potato salad, fries or potato pancake. They were out of potato pancakes so we just went with the fries. They had a light seasoning on them and no one could tell us what it was but it was delicious. In fact, everything was delicious. It's no surprise that's this place is as busy as it is. The staff/service was good. Sassy, familiar yet friendly and attentive. Note: Cash only and there is an ATM in the bar if you need it.
The best fish fry in Milwaukee. You can't beat all you can eat. Randy's will be surely missed. Get it while you still can.
My husband heard great things about the fish fry so we stopped by, he loved it!! I had the burger, very good. We will stop by again.
Small place...should make reservations for fish fry Friday. Fish fry is all you can it and it was good. Also had a appetizer platter that was good. Prices were reasonable.
We had a wonderful fish fry at Randy's and we will definitely be back. We did arrive early hoping to grab a table because reservations do book up quickly. We were fortunate to be seated immediately, and wish we had brought a bigger appetite. The fish was perfectly cooked, the fries were crispy, the coleslaw was creamy and the potato salad was simply delicious. Definitely one the best in town.
The best fish fry in Milwaukee, bar none! I travel from Texas for this fish fry every summer
First time stopping in to this neighborhood jewel for their fish fry. Everyone I was with greatly enjoyed the experience and would highly recommend their Friday Fish fry to anyone who enjoys a good, classic and delicious dinner experience!
(Recently edited, but visit's ~1mo. ago; Still germane, though.)I don't know what's changed here!?, or seems different...but this place seemed less than "neighborly" when compared to previous visits. The food was O.K...or even GOOD, but the service & price was akin to an "oil spill in the gulf"; toxic and costly; in that order!!!That being said, they were less than friendly, in fact blatantly offensive. Frankly, I'm at a loss here, but it may just explain why, for being a Friday nite, they were NEARLY EMPTY when, in the past they WERE "bursting at the seams". Left not much of a tip,...except for maybe the fish; like 'Look for a different Sea!'I guess "neighborhoods" DO change.Some can even turn Snotty! But don't blame this on the pandemic...'SNEIGHBOR'?!!!
Took a while to get a table and the food was ok just didn't like weight for 50 minutes to get the bill
Fish was okay, so were the French fries. It's all you can eat. Service was a mix, waitress was nice but had no plates when the fish came and they forgot the bread and coleslaw.The place is a dump and not conducive to eating. Kind of like eating on card tables in my parents basement in the '60s and '70s.
Get there while you have time--sounds like they are going to close some time this summer. Friendly people in a very nice neighborhood bar. Fish fry is excellent--order in advance, or take your chances on Friday! Lots of regulars who enjoy this fun spot.
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing staff and service. Delicious All you can eat fish fry at a good price.
Had to try out the fish fry here after hearing so much about it being the classic and it didn't disappoint. A total "dive" bar feel with a local atmosphere and a traditional fish fry. Food came out piping hot and even though it was all you can eat, the portion they brought out for the 3 of us to start was more than enough. All of it was very good. Give it a try!
Local Mom and Pop Restaurant. It is my preferred method of dining. Every 5 star review they have received is accurate. The All you can eat Friday Fish Fry is delicious AND they do not skimp. I was amazed at the portions. Even when I asked for a side of mayonnaise they gave me a bowl of mayo. WOW!!!I would give them 6 stars if they had potato pancakes. ???❤❤❤
Fantastic fish fry!!! Great prices and delicious cocktails. Wonderful servers and staff. I love that it's an all you can eat family style fish fry our server was so sweet and prompt bringing extra fish and lemons.
No frills/divey, neighborhood joint with a dining room of about 12 tables on one side and a bar with 3-4 hightops and bar service on the other side. You enter through the bar and it was packed with regulars-the kind place where everyone knows everyone. Luckily we were able to get two seats at the bar right away as reservations are recommended and the business they turn is nonstop. Although there is a small menu available with standard bar food and apps- it was Friday and we didn't see one order that wasn't their AYCE family style fish fry, which is what we had. The fish is lightly breaded- almost a dusting. The cod is meaty and each piece cooked to perfection served with fresh rye bread, green cole slaw, and your choice of potato salad, fries or potato pancake. They were out of potato pancakes so we just went with the fries. They had a light seasoning on them and no one could tell us what it was but it was delicious. In fact, everything was delicious. It's no surprise that's this place is as busy as it is. The staff/service was good. Sassy, familiar yet friendly and attentive. Note: Cash only and there is an ATM in the bar if you need it.