Excellent pizza! Great crusty chewy real crust. Exceptional sausage. Generous with ingredients. We always get carry out because I am disabled and cannot leave home. The pizza is securely boxed, and because I order it uncut tastes just like it came out of the oven freshly made. I'm 74, and have had pizzas from all over Milwaukee, this is my favorite. Great job! Thank you, don't ever change!
David Watters
Pietro’s is great. The service is always spot on and the delivery driver is wonderful. Their pizza, cheese bread and mozzarella sticks are fantastic.Oh yeah… make sure you do yourself a favor and order the Cannoli. Absolutely amazing. Scrumptious and delicious!
Had a lovely conversation about New York with Pietro Saturday night. Lovely respectful man. He’s from Italy and Omgosh sorry New Yorkers THIS pizza is the best I’ve ever had. EVER! His sauce is unbelievable and cheese is so fresh! Get the supreme it’s not on menu but order it. Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, yummy sausage and pepperoni. Wow I couldn’t stop saying wow with my mouth full! Love this guy. It’s “a hole in the wall”and that means it’s good in New York language, it’s take out only, on the KK.
Recommended dishes: Extra Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Robert Mentecki
Damn good pizza!!! Also, I enjoy their meatball sandwiche, although I never get enough meatball on my meatball sandwiche.
Jacob D
Currently my favorite pizza place at the moment! They also have great meatball subs.
Christine Frahm
Haven't had their pizza for many years but very satisfied with my pizza order of a supreme. Very good!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Happy P.
5 stars all around. Amazing, hot delivered pizza. Actually blew my mind it was so good. Then add the service, both on the telephone and delivery. Both were beyond 'just' business. Kind and friendly.
Michelle Evans
Ordered a 14 inch pizza for delivery. It arrived, it was clearly not the correct size. I call the restaurant and the owner proceeded to yell at me on the phone and tell me that I'm wrong. I said I wasn't going to argue with him, and he continued yelling at me. Absolutely horrible customer service. Super unfortunate because the food is really good. However, being yelled at and told I'm wrong was so off putting that I haven't gone back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Carrie Karvonen
Best pizza in the area if you like thin with crust! And it's consistently good. Always on time when we pick up. May not be great inside but idc if they spend the money on the ingredients and technology. Pay and even get reciept to your phone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Toasted Ravioli, Half and Half Pizza
Mike Doss
Delicious food, friendly staff authentic but cluttered atmosphere. I recommend it to anyone looking for amazing takeout pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Hot Wings, Pepperoni Pizza, Half and Half Pizza
I had Pietros when I was at my relatives house. I went all out on a huge order. I enjoyed the pepperoni pizza, it has some tang to the sauce, the crust was nicely baked, bread was pretty good and the mozzarella sticks were to. I will be ordering again!
Great pizza. The sausage has a real unique flavor not found anywhere else.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ross
Authentic amazing pizza!
Gary H.
Delicious pies, hot, ready for pick up on time! What's not to like? Lately I've struggled to get responsive carry out on short notice. Pietro's was a welcome exception.
JPC
Drove by this place millions of times but never stopped I did stop a couple months ago and I'm glad I did! I usually go on Thursdays because Maria is working and I love the way she makes my pizza! Everybody is friendly there and I never had a complaint going there about maybe eight times now. I hope I never get disappointed because then I'll have to look for a new pizza place and it's hard these days!
Excellent pizza! Great crusty chewy real crust. Exceptional sausage. Generous with ingredients. We always get carry out because I am disabled and cannot leave home. The pizza is securely boxed, and because I order it uncut tastes just like it came out of the oven freshly made. I'm 74, and have had pizzas from all over Milwaukee, this is my favorite. Great job! Thank you, don't ever change!
Pietro’s is great. The service is always spot on and the delivery driver is wonderful. Their pizza, cheese bread and mozzarella sticks are fantastic.Oh yeah… make sure you do yourself a favor and order the Cannoli. Absolutely amazing. Scrumptious and delicious!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza, Half and Half Pizza, Garlic Bread, Cannoli
Had a lovely conversation about New York with Pietro Saturday night. Lovely respectful man. He’s from Italy and Omgosh sorry New Yorkers THIS pizza is the best I’ve ever had. EVER! His sauce is unbelievable and cheese is so fresh! Get the supreme it’s not on menu but order it. Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, yummy sausage and pepperoni. Wow I couldn’t stop saying wow with my mouth full! Love this guy. It’s “a hole in the wall”and that means it’s good in New York language, it’s take out only, on the KK.
Recommended dishes: Extra Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Damn good pizza!!! Also, I enjoy their meatball sandwiche, although I never get enough meatball on my meatball sandwiche.
Currently my favorite pizza place at the moment! They also have great meatball subs.
Haven't had their pizza for many years but very satisfied with my pizza order of a supreme. Very good!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
5 stars all around. Amazing, hot delivered pizza. Actually blew my mind it was so good. Then add the service, both on the telephone and delivery. Both were beyond 'just' business. Kind and friendly.
Ordered a 14 inch pizza for delivery. It arrived, it was clearly not the correct size. I call the restaurant and the owner proceeded to yell at me on the phone and tell me that I'm wrong. I said I wasn't going to argue with him, and he continued yelling at me. Absolutely horrible customer service. Super unfortunate because the food is really good. However, being yelled at and told I'm wrong was so off putting that I haven't gone back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Best pizza in the area if you like thin with crust! And it's consistently good. Always on time when we pick up. May not be great inside but idc if they spend the money on the ingredients and technology. Pay and even get reciept to your phone.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Toasted Ravioli, Half and Half Pizza
Delicious food, friendly staff authentic but cluttered atmosphere. I recommend it to anyone looking for amazing takeout pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Hot Wings, Pepperoni Pizza, Half and Half Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I had Pietros when I was at my relatives house. I went all out on a huge order. I enjoyed the pepperoni pizza, it has some tang to the sauce, the crust was nicely baked, bread was pretty good and the mozzarella sticks were to. I will be ordering again!
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Bread
Great pizza. The sausage has a real unique flavor not found anywhere else.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Authentic amazing pizza!
Delicious pies, hot, ready for pick up on time! What's not to like? Lately I've struggled to get responsive carry out on short notice. Pietro's was a welcome exception.
Drove by this place millions of times but never stopped I did stop a couple months ago and I'm glad I did! I usually go on Thursdays because Maria is working and I love the way she makes my pizza! Everybody is friendly there and I never had a complaint going there about maybe eight times now. I hope I never get disappointed because then I'll have to look for a new pizza place and it's hard these days!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza