Pricing is reasonable for seafood and food is delicious. Crab legs were AMAZING!
Chandra Munroe
Tanner, Liz, and Rob are great - the tiki bar is the place to be all the time, but especially when it’s 0 degrees out. The Lobster Bloody Mary is sooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Suzanne L
Coming here for years!! Always great service, great food, and so much fun!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Johnathan Briggs
Best place for a fish fry by far
Sarah V.
Food has been great! Every time I have gone. No complaints. The service was okay and the vibe of the place is pretty casual but all together I'd say a 9/10.
Jenny C.
I highly recommend eating here when visiting the Milwaukee public market! It's in the corner of the market with seating next to the restaurant and open seating upstairs.We got the lobster roll with a side of coleslaw and fries, and a clam chowder as well.The lobster roll came with a buttery bun and extremely fresh and flavorful lobster fillings. The side of fries and coleslaw paired really well with this entree and the clam chowder warmed us up from the cold weather outside.The food came out fast as we ordered takeout and sat upstairs with open seating. I would definitely come here again to try more of their entrees!
Alex S.
This is what seafood dreams are made of! THE spot to get your fix on freshly prepared food that is not easily found in the Midwest. All of their fish & seafood is flown in regularly, and it shows by the fresh taste of their food. I'm normally someone who tries something different each time I go out to eat, but at St Paul I always get the same-Buffalo grouper cheeks & steamed clams. My bf got the lobster roll this visit. We arrived right at opening time and there were plenty of people already seated for lunch. There was only one server for the entire area, service was thorough and we were checked on periodically. We're lucky to have such a gem of a seafood restaurant in MKE!
daikin
We came here for lunch on Sunday it was really crowded and we waited for 30 minutes before we got our seats but it was worth it the lobster boil was worth every penny
reddevil069
We were all excited to try st.Paul company. We started out at the bar with cocktails and appetizers and everything was very good at the bar. Then it came time to sit down for dinner and as we were walking in to be seated we noticed that a lot of people were wearing jackets. When we sat down we knew right away why there were quite a few people wearing jackets as they ate dinner. It was very cold in the room we were sitting in and there was a air vent right above us blowing down on the tables. So we asked are server if she could ask for the air to be turned off as it was very cold. She said that she would talk to the manager. After about 20 minutes the air was still blasting away so we asked are server if she talk to the manager and she said that she did and the manager would see what she could do. After about another 20 minutes I got up and asked to speak to the manager she came over and said that she talk to the large party that was in the same room as us and that they said that they were all ok but she never talked to any of the other tables in the same room. She came to are table and told us that she turned the air to 69. There is nothing worse than having to eat dinner with a jacket on and having to eat fast so your food doesn’t get cold and that is exactly what happened! How often do you go out to dinner and see multiple people wearing jackets as they eat? It was very disappointing in what little the manager did to rectify the problem. The temperature out side was 55 degrees.
The Borg Cooking Show
The Margarita's are great and strong. The bar is usually too crowded, to get a seat with personally space but the atmosphere is great. Its like a small tiki oasis in the concrete jungle.You just have to put up with the bartenders' personalities while sipping on some mai tais
Cruisin thru the public market, sportin your Harley Davidson and/or Brewers gear and looking for some good eats? Well you wouldn't be alone because that's pretty much everyone else in the entire frickin market. Being first timers thru Milwaukee we were looking for some good grub while on a self guided walking tour thru the city. We shot from the hip, checked good ol' yelp for confirmation of the goodness and landed at St. Paul Fish Company. I'm still feeling some major Happy Days/Fonzarelli vibes after hanging out with the Bronz Fonz...if you know, you know. Well, It didn't disappoint folks. Shrimp cocktail...bam! Lobster roll...boom! Shrimp po boy...Aaaahhhhhhyyyyyy (enter thumbs here). It's got seating, you can be waited on, and most importantly it's absolutely delish. St. Paul Fish Company...I'm cool, your cool, let's be cool together. Eat up.
George L.
I ordered the food to my hotel, unfortunately they didn't send me the oysters I ordered which was a huge letdown because I'd already paid through Uber eats, but everything else was delicious. I'd love to come in person and eat oysters, I just really miss eating fresh oysters.It's been years.Thank you for the food and I understand why oysters can't be delivered.
Toyourtown
Threw the clam chowder in garbage because it was inedible. My wife wanted to take it back to the counter but i`ll just be a silent dissatisfied customer. Walleye fry was not much better dry and tasteless. Was so looking to eat here after all the reviews and what a let down.
Lauren Northington
Drinks and service were awesome!! Carly is an absolute ray of sunshine!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Billie S
One of the best seafood restaurants in town. The Lobster Roll is great. Also the Boullibase with assorted seafood. Located on the Milwaukee Public Market, which is an adventure in itself. Lots of choices for those in your group who may not like seafood.
Pricing is reasonable for seafood and food is delicious. Crab legs were AMAZING!
Tanner, Liz, and Rob are great - the tiki bar is the place to be all the time, but especially when it’s 0 degrees out. The Lobster Bloody Mary is sooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Coming here for years!! Always great service, great food, and so much fun!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best place for a fish fry by far
Food has been great! Every time I have gone. No complaints. The service was okay and the vibe of the place is pretty casual but all together I'd say a 9/10.
I highly recommend eating here when visiting the Milwaukee public market! It's in the corner of the market with seating next to the restaurant and open seating upstairs.We got the lobster roll with a side of coleslaw and fries, and a clam chowder as well.The lobster roll came with a buttery bun and extremely fresh and flavorful lobster fillings. The side of fries and coleslaw paired really well with this entree and the clam chowder warmed us up from the cold weather outside.The food came out fast as we ordered takeout and sat upstairs with open seating. I would definitely come here again to try more of their entrees!
This is what seafood dreams are made of! THE spot to get your fix on freshly prepared food that is not easily found in the Midwest. All of their fish & seafood is flown in regularly, and it shows by the fresh taste of their food. I'm normally someone who tries something different each time I go out to eat, but at St Paul I always get the same-Buffalo grouper cheeks & steamed clams. My bf got the lobster roll this visit. We arrived right at opening time and there were plenty of people already seated for lunch. There was only one server for the entire area, service was thorough and we were checked on periodically. We're lucky to have such a gem of a seafood restaurant in MKE!
We came here for lunch on Sunday it was really crowded and we waited for 30 minutes before we got our seats but it was worth it the lobster boil was worth every penny
We were all excited to try st.Paul company. We started out at the bar with cocktails and appetizers and everything was very good at the bar. Then it came time to sit down for dinner and as we were walking in to be seated we noticed that a lot of people were wearing jackets. When we sat down we knew right away why there were quite a few people wearing jackets as they ate dinner. It was very cold in the room we were sitting in and there was a air vent right above us blowing down on the tables. So we asked are server if she could ask for the air to be turned off as it was very cold. She said that she would talk to the manager. After about 20 minutes the air was still blasting away so we asked are server if she talk to the manager and she said that she did and the manager would see what she could do. After about another 20 minutes I got up and asked to speak to the manager she came over and said that she talk to the large party that was in the same room as us and that they said that they were all ok but she never talked to any of the other tables in the same room. She came to are table and told us that she turned the air to 69. There is nothing worse than having to eat dinner with a jacket on and having to eat fast so your food doesn’t get cold and that is exactly what happened! How often do you go out to dinner and see multiple people wearing jackets as they eat? It was very disappointing in what little the manager did to rectify the problem. The temperature out side was 55 degrees.
The Margarita's are great and strong. The bar is usually too crowded, to get a seat with personally space but the atmosphere is great. Its like a small tiki oasis in the concrete jungle.You just have to put up with the bartenders' personalities while sipping on some mai tais
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Cruisin thru the public market, sportin your Harley Davidson and/or Brewers gear and looking for some good eats? Well you wouldn't be alone because that's pretty much everyone else in the entire frickin market. Being first timers thru Milwaukee we were looking for some good grub while on a self guided walking tour thru the city. We shot from the hip, checked good ol' yelp for confirmation of the goodness and landed at St. Paul Fish Company. I'm still feeling some major Happy Days/Fonzarelli vibes after hanging out with the Bronz Fonz...if you know, you know. Well, It didn't disappoint folks. Shrimp cocktail...bam! Lobster roll...boom! Shrimp po boy...Aaaahhhhhhyyyyyy (enter thumbs here). It's got seating, you can be waited on, and most importantly it's absolutely delish. St. Paul Fish Company...I'm cool, your cool, let's be cool together. Eat up.
I ordered the food to my hotel, unfortunately they didn't send me the oysters I ordered which was a huge letdown because I'd already paid through Uber eats, but everything else was delicious. I'd love to come in person and eat oysters, I just really miss eating fresh oysters.It's been years.Thank you for the food and I understand why oysters can't be delivered.
Threw the clam chowder in garbage because it was inedible. My wife wanted to take it back to the counter but i`ll just be a silent dissatisfied customer. Walleye fry was not much better dry and tasteless. Was so looking to eat here after all the reviews and what a let down.
Drinks and service were awesome!! Carly is an absolute ray of sunshine!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
One of the best seafood restaurants in town. The Lobster Roll is great. Also the Boullibase with assorted seafood. Located on the Milwaukee Public Market, which is an adventure in itself. Lots of choices for those in your group who may not like seafood.