34 Best Pizza Restaurants near North Lake

“Donna was our server & could not have been more attentive, our group of 4 ordered all different dishes & fantastic, each year we select a new place to go for our high school friends Christmas get together, we all agreed we don’t need to select another place next yearParking: Easy in and out“

“Had the pizza delivered to an assisted living facility for a little family reunion. The family really enjoyed the pizza and made for an easy get together. The delivery was right on time and the delivery guy was very congenial. Thanks. Will do that again!“

“I took home a cheese , sausage , mushroom , and onion pizza , and was impressed with the quality of the cheese and the flavorful sausage , the fresh mushrooms , all abundantly portioned on a crisp crust . The sauce was tasty and also flavorful , I hate bland sauce . A very good pizza .“

“Their sandwiches are absolutely phenomenal. Each one is packed generously and the flavor combinations are perfect. I've visited this restaurant close to 10 times over the past year, and each time the food tastes as good as the last. From my experience, they never serve a dud sandwich.“

“Exceptional pizza in a hard-to-find (but worth it when you do) location. You can drive, boat or swim to Doc's (on Pewaukee Lake's North Shore) to find out why Wisconsin's cracker-thin crust and piping hot toppings, of the finest quality, piled on in huge quantities PLUS a friendly atmosphere and wicked-good service just beats the pants off of those thick, stuffed, overfilled, mostly-dough pies they call deep dish pizza just south of here! Come to Wisconsin, Eat at Doc's and you'll be forever changed for the better!“

“This is a nice local bar in Pewaukee. ***In all fairness, my food rating is based on a frozen pizza cooked after the grill was closed. It was available and ok. If it were about ten pm and I wanted a bar pizza, I would order this again.That being said, the server was attentive and very nice. I ordered a Bloody Mary hot. It was reasonably priced and came with a nice amount of fixings. I also received a decent amount for a beer chaser.I was meeting a friend briefly as she drove through town, so we didn't explore the many things available at the bar.They had pool tables and other machines there. ( I wasn't looking too closely, I'm sorry.)I will probably plan another late meeting with my friend as she finishes her classes at WCTC.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, they have a wheelchair ramp. I did not use the facilities.“

“My family had a hankering for some pizza, and lo and behold, Google indicated that there was a local place that recently opened up- D'Eli Pizza. We gave it a shot and are glad that we did. We ordered a single pizza, Chicago style, with a small request in the instructions for takeout. It took a good minute to find the location since they don't have a light up business sign like other establishments in the strip mall, but after taking a second pass we spotted D'Eli Pizza to grab our order. It was a surprisingly small location, and seating was limited as far as I can tell. Parking, however, I cannot see being an issue given that it's in the strip. The staff was exceptionally friendly and accommodating- lots of smiles; food was even walked directly out to the car, which was sweet. How well the customer service holds up as time goes on is something only time will tell, but for now, you can tell that everyone there is happy to be in business. The pizza was surprisingly good. The dough was unique- very low moisture, slightly cracker-y taste, but of good texture and by no means bad. The toppings were well prepared. The sauce, however, was the star of the show. Like most places around here, the sauce is on the sweeter side; it had great flavor and texture, though, setting it apart from other places we have gone to in the past. The pizza was super filling, the cheese had a good pull, and nothing was greasy. The only thing that bummed us out a bit was that the pizza was not deep dish like we had originally assumed, a real shame given that the sauce was the highlight. That being said, it was never advertised to be a deep dish pizza; for those also looking for a deep dish pizza, just be aware that there does not appear to be any on the menu at this time. The day after, leftovers were surprisingly good both cold and reheated- no chewy nor super hard crust, no funky flavor profiles, just good pizza. It felt like the pizza was almost designed to be reheated the day after, which is a rarity. The price point was right for the product. With pizza alone, we spent about $10/person with some leftovers for the next day. That cost I would imagine goes up to about $15/person with appetizers and maybe dessert, if there's more variety, or if you get delivery. For supporting a local business that's getting off the ground and having some meal-worthy leftovers, I am extremely pleased, definitely more so than I have been with Falbo Bros in the past. I recommend giving this place a try for yourself! In it's infancy, D'Eli Pizza is a hidden gem in Hartland; I'm excited to see where they go from here.“

“Pizza by the slice is always available around the lunch hour. We pick up a lot for work meetings. These slices are twice the size of an average large size of pizza (you have to slice the piece down the center to eat it basically) and they are 4 bucks each! If you call ahead and say you are coming and what you need and how many they will have it ready for you. Instead of ordering an XL pizza with half the people unhappy with either sausage or pepperoni, everyone can get what they want. Love this place. The girls at the counter are always super sweet too.“

“I have not been in here since it was OTR, I heard great things about the food so my family and I gave it a try tonight—I was super impressed with the food, the portions were large and delicious. Our waitress was extremely friendly and proficient and juggling waitressing and bartending.“

“This place is awesome! If you're in the mood for a burger and some curds this is the place on the lake. The Owner "Hollywood" is the first single female proprietor on the lake. And is absolutely hilarious, super fun environment.“

“They don't have a lot of tables indoors, Looking forward to warmer weather with doors open to dine outside !Parking: Lot is small, so not a lot of spots on Fridays. Usually end up parking on the street. If you are riding a motorcycle,then you should get a spot. Designated parking for motorcycles.“

“We had fun stopping in for a fish fry. The vibe is excellent (though busy on a Friday! not surprisingly), and the staff are all very friendly. The fish fry was small in portion, but yummy. And the floors are sticky, but in the friendly, and not dirty, neighborhood bar way. I am looking forward to coming back in the daylight and warmer weather for what I'm sure will be a very fun experience.“

“We have been going to Papa Murpheys the last handful of Tuesdays for the $10 large pizza deal and depending on what we have going on we pickup at different locations. At this location the staff is always friendly ( nice on the phone, greet you when you arrive, thank you) This location is also very organized and has our orders ready and correct at the time we say we want it ready. We always try to order at this location whenever we can. Also- we got a free 5 cheesy bread last week that was delicious.“

“We love pizza and have had tried many establishments. Genoa's is by far the best we have had. The crust is just right, the toppings are plentiful and delicious. We have had them deliver several times and each time the pizza is hot and still crispy fresh. We won't be using anyone else. Thanks for great service and delicious pizza.“

“Great selection of Italian food here. The pizza has been the most consistently good pizza since we started picking up a few years ago. Plenty of toppings and always cooked to perfection. This has been our go to when we want a delicious high quality pizza in Lake Country.“

“Bought 4 separate types of pizzas for my son's 14th birthday party and every pizza was a hit. Teenagers liked the original pan the best, I liked the Detroit style the best, and my wife said her gluten free pizza was very good as well (one of only two gluten free pizzas she likes). Also, I called to seek help with my online order regarding the gluten free pizza and received unusually good service over the phone.“

“This was a really great dining experience. The service was outstanding, good atmosphere, great drinks, and the food was very good with generous portion sizes. The reason for 4 stars was that the desert was a miss for me. I would absolutely eat here again.“

“Stopped here for lunch with a coworker last week. I was very pleased with how quickly our order was processed. Very impressive. I ordered the chicken parm sub, I'm so glad I got that. it hit the spot. I hope to return to order off the pizza menu. I had a hard time not ordering an entire pizza. That will be for next time for sure.Thank you to the staff at Eric's for the great dining experience. hope to visit again sometime soon. keep up the great work.“

“A great local spot for great food served by friendly staff. The Asiago Cheese dip appetizer, Lasagna & Miss Piggy pizza & Walleye Fish Fry are favorites. Friendly bar with a good variety of specialty beers on tap. Tom Basil Collin’s is a great go to in all the seasons. Soft serve custard is delicious. Specials every day. There’s outdoor seating when the weather allows, plenty of free parkingKid-friendliness: A great place for families of all ages.“

“I was in town for some training over at WCTC and our group decided to visit Gina's. I've never been there before....and what a treat it was. A nice clean establishment...great service and the young man who was cooking...sure knows how to make a burger. It was hot and juicy with great toppings and a pile of fries on the side....all for $10.00.....and for us teatottlers....bottomless soda....you won't be disappointed....give Gina's a try...I know I'll be back.“

“Been coming here for nearly 20 years. Overall, a decent place. I wouldn't say it's a "must try" or that there's any "must haves" here. It's just a nice little place to go with a group of loved ones.I think they've probably achieved the atmosphere they were going for. It feels cozy enough to relax but still open and friendly without feeling too exposed or crowded. It's not anything fancy or special but it does the trick.The service is usually run by younger kids and adults who are learning their first job so they're not usually too organized or attentive. They are however well mannered and for the most part fairly competent. Again nothing special but it gets the job done without too many or large complaints.The food is rather difficult to assess as there are some things they do rather well and others they should have never tried. Generally speaking most of their food isn't anything to write home about. As pizza places go they are better than the big chains but pretty par for local hand crafted food. Their subs are basically the same as anywhere that offers them. Their buffalo wings used to draw my friends and I here for the sauce but were always disappointingly small and brittle. The chickens must have been diseased babies whose bones would all snap in half with ease. They have recently changed to larger pieces that didn't break but then they were still over cooked tough and crispy. Honestly couldn't tell you if the sauce was even still the same. There are, however, a few gems of deliciousness on their menu. Like their breads, and lasagnas.“

“First visit to Noah’s and very impressed with the pizza. Recommended to by a friend for the pizza and it did not disappoint!We took our pizza to go, so by the time we got home the box was a bit greasy from the cut pizza, but easily remedied by putting it on a pan. Impressed that the pizza was still warm after the 10 minute drive.We had sausage and pepperoni, 16-inch, traditional crust ($21.00) along with an appetizer of chicken tenders (6 for $7.99–dipped in their Caesar dressing. Yum!).The pizza sauce is there and noticeable but compliments the toppings—not to sweet and not to acidic. The meat toppings came next and a generous helping of mozzarella covered it all. The pizza was in the oven long enough to get a little color on the cheese (good cheese pull) and the bottom of the crust was nicely marbled brown and not flimsy at all.Will definitely return for more pizza, and, the menu is huge with Mexican, pasta, soup, sandwiches, salad, and catering offerings , too. Will have to try more foods here at a later time.“

“This Rocky’s location has been consistently the best for almost a decade. I’ve ate at Rocky’s in lacrosse & Madison & to all of them around MKe… this location always has the freshest pizza & it’s always made hot & correct. We always get a large pizza, & the family meal deal. Feeds a family of 4-5 well. the sausage is the best. We were happy to get the holiday cookies today with our order“

“Very few things in life are consistent, but the food from Papa Murphy's is one of them.The people working here are hard working and polite, and I've never had to worry about a bad order or mistakes. Order, pick up, enjoy.Great work, guys.“

“I ordered from door dash. Maybe the best fried chicken ever! Fresh tasty moist chicken with the perfect crispy coating. Not to salty or over seasoned so you can really taste the delicious chicken! And the chicken dumpling soup is amazing! I will visit the restaurant soon!“

“From out of town & ordered delivery. Best pizza we've had in a while. Couldnt believe how low the prices were. We also ordered the boneless wings with boom boom sauce and garlic parm, the sauces were good, but the wings were not tossed in the sauce so they were still dry, which could have been for delivery sake, but for us it turned out to be soggy bottom wings. Overall 5 stars, they just need a little work on their wings.“

“Great staff! Always perfect pizzas! Best ranch! 10/10 This location has the friendly staff out there! They definitely know how to take care of the customers and make sure each order it right ?We get half baked and uncut! Perfect every time when cooked! Uncut is the way to go!“

“This queer-friendly and trendy pizza joint has vegan crust (make sure to order the double thickness option if you're not a huge fan of thin crust), vegan red sauce and BBQ sauce. They also have delicious plant based sausage and dairy free cheese options, and tons of veggies. The staff is accommodating and conscious, using separate gloves for the plant based sausage and asking about dairy allergies. Most importantly, the finished pizza is incredibly tasty!“

“Had a longer wait then told (40 mins rather than 15) but the hostess was apologetic. Pizza was excellent! We loved the taco pizza! Also tried the garlic bread, haystack onion rings and a sausage pizza. Everything was good but especially loved the taco pizza! Our waitress was prompt, efficient and friendly. They were pretty busy too. Definitely will come again. Thanks Park Ave Pizza!“

“This the best pizza I’ve ever had. I got the deep dish, it’s filling & good for leftovers. I walked in & was greeted, everyone is in the back working hard. The ingredients are quality ingredients & they don’t short you on the toppings. I suggest starting with something small like thin crust & work your way to try something else. If you want pizza go to Falbo Bros. Good wings too.“

“A good bar with decent food. Enjoyed the grilled salmon with a nice heep of mashed potatoes with garlic butter sauce, side of grilled veggies. I ordered a grilled shrimp skewer add-on and got 5 medium shrimp for $14. That was a major disappointment.“

“This place has the best wings in town! They're so delicious and I can't believe how cheap they are! The food comes out so insanely fast. Even when the place is packed, I haven't had to wait long. Employees are very kind and hard working and make it a great experience.“

“Pizza and Wings were delicious, ready when I stopped to pick it up. Only downside was the wing container, the sauce leaked out the edges and onto the seat of my car, so not anything to do with the staff and their work, so will definitely go here again.“

“Finally tried this place on a rainy Thursday afternoon during a Badgers Big 10 tournament basketball game. Newly updated but still maintained the perfect dive bar atmosphere. The bathrooms were super clean. It looked clean and organized behind the bar. Food ingredients looked and tasted fresh. Hubby had the philly because he can't say no to cheese sauce, and I had the newer to the menu southwest wrap with crispy chicken which was HUGE and delicious. Homemade chips were super thin and crispy and not burnt tasting like some can often be. Tracy behind the bar gave us great service. We will be back!“