Mahoney' one of our staples when coming to Oshkosh. We got cheese curds to start. They were a little greasy but still very good. I got a burger with the truffle Parmesan fries. The fries were amazing and I could not stop eating them. The burger was also good. Everyone at my table said that they loved their food. Highly recommend!
Austin Schwartz
I was very dissapointed in the food. The food was cold and not fresh. The whole atmosphere just didn't seem good. I'd give them another shot someday but not sure how they stay in business if the food was like it was.:(
Denise L'Hommedieu
Great service and quick seating on a Friday night! Food was good, drinks were reasonable too.
Joe Schmidt
The food was really good! Nice selection of options. The service was slow considering how empty the place was. I know that food can take time and I'm ok with that. Getting a first glass of water shouldn't take that long and then never getting asked or checked on about the empty beer glass was disappointing.
Greg Hawley
Mahoney’s is a good place to eat outside during the warmer weather. On slightly cooler evenings, they have a fire place on the patio to keep warm. Visited a number of Wednesday’s after group bicycle rides. Food is very good. During the summer of 2021, they were a bit under staffed. If it weren’t for that, they would get five stars.
Melissa Rossow
Stopped at Mahoney’s when coming back from Green Bay. Amazing food! Great Atmosphere and awesome service. Scott was our bartender and he did a great job he was very attentive and welcoming! Best water in town for sure ?
wolfepack4
My husband and I went to Mahoney’s for dinner and it was amazing. We got the pulled pork tacos and the grilled cheese and homemade tomato basil soup. Every thing was delicious. It was our server’s first night and she did an incredible job! She provided excellent service and was very attentive. The outdoor patio was a great place to enjoy our meal. We will be back!
Laine Shields
First time here came for the Bloody Mary's that were highly recommended by Camille on a Venture Wisconsin video they were Excellent
P I.
How anyone can screw up a pre-made "boil 'n bag" entree from the Sysco truck is beyond me. Also - the place is in need a complete cleaning - another want-to-be Irish Pub - trying waaaay too hard
paulfQ5739KO
This was a great place to dine. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. I will definitely go to this restaurant again if I am in the area. I had a mushroom Swiss burger that was cooked perfectly and the fries were delicious! They also have a wonderful patio area.
Very disappointed with my experience. Went during a non busy time waitress seemed to only want to take a drink order and rush off then finally got our appetizers ordered and the food was nothing special. Would not recommend the meatloaf or the restaurant. If I could give less than 1 star I would***Edit to respond**I left my review not knowing my 18 yr old son did as well.. that being said my meal was not comped we paid the complete 96.00 and change. Thank you for responding in such a defensive way. I may have been more understanding had the restaurant been busy but there were no other tables in the area we were in and only a handful in the bar area.
Kathryn Hughett
We had supper here. We were going to go to the Mineshaft but decided to go somewhere quiet and not crowded. Good food and service. It was 4:30 when we were seated so therefore few customers at that time.I had Mac "n" Cheese with chicken and a Ceasar Salad. Hubby had a flatbread with pulled pork, barbecue sauce, and some other stuff. And a cup of chili. It was all quite good.
Kevin L
We were told a 30 minute wait by host staff we said ok, 45 mins goes by as we see people after us getting seated. So I go back to the host stand and he asked my name, he said we don't have you on the list we thought you left. But I can put you on it, so he took my name this time, 15 minutes goes by, still seeing others getting seated, now we have waited 1 hour. At this point we left without eating or a drink.. a little training is needed up front I think.
volkswagendriver
Our first visit back to Mahoney;s in a long time was awesome, great service and the food was super tasty. We went back a few weeks later w/ our kids and it was a totally different story. They were fully staffed, but service was really slow, the wait staff mainly hung out at the host/ess station and just talked among themselves. A couple near us was seated, but no one ever stopped over so after about 10 mins they got up and left. After a long wait our food came out, even thought we got the same items as the first time, it was bland and even our kids said their food wasn't that great.
Joe M.
We all had a great time. The food and service were great. I especially enjoyed the cheese curds.
Mahoney' one of our staples when coming to Oshkosh. We got cheese curds to start. They were a little greasy but still very good. I got a burger with the truffle Parmesan fries. The fries were amazing and I could not stop eating them. The burger was also good. Everyone at my table said that they loved their food. Highly recommend!
I was very dissapointed in the food. The food was cold and not fresh. The whole atmosphere just didn't seem good. I'd give them another shot someday but not sure how they stay in business if the food was like it was.:(
Great service and quick seating on a Friday night! Food was good, drinks were reasonable too.
The food was really good! Nice selection of options. The service was slow considering how empty the place was. I know that food can take time and I'm ok with that. Getting a first glass of water shouldn't take that long and then never getting asked or checked on about the empty beer glass was disappointing.
Mahoney’s is a good place to eat outside during the warmer weather. On slightly cooler evenings, they have a fire place on the patio to keep warm. Visited a number of Wednesday’s after group bicycle rides. Food is very good. During the summer of 2021, they were a bit under staffed. If it weren’t for that, they would get five stars.
Stopped at Mahoney’s when coming back from Green Bay. Amazing food! Great Atmosphere and awesome service. Scott was our bartender and he did a great job he was very attentive and welcoming! Best water in town for sure ?
My husband and I went to Mahoney’s for dinner and it was amazing. We got the pulled pork tacos and the grilled cheese and homemade tomato basil soup. Every thing was delicious. It was our server’s first night and she did an incredible job! She provided excellent service and was very attentive. The outdoor patio was a great place to enjoy our meal. We will be back!
First time here came for the Bloody Mary's that were highly recommended by Camille on a Venture Wisconsin video they were Excellent
How anyone can screw up a pre-made "boil 'n bag" entree from the Sysco truck is beyond me. Also - the place is in need a complete cleaning - another want-to-be Irish Pub - trying waaaay too hard
This was a great place to dine. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. I will definitely go to this restaurant again if I am in the area. I had a mushroom Swiss burger that was cooked perfectly and the fries were delicious! They also have a wonderful patio area.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very disappointed with my experience. Went during a non busy time waitress seemed to only want to take a drink order and rush off then finally got our appetizers ordered and the food was nothing special. Would not recommend the meatloaf or the restaurant. If I could give less than 1 star I would***Edit to respond**I left my review not knowing my 18 yr old son did as well.. that being said my meal was not comped we paid the complete 96.00 and change. Thank you for responding in such a defensive way. I may have been more understanding had the restaurant been busy but there were no other tables in the area we were in and only a handful in the bar area.
We had supper here. We were going to go to the Mineshaft but decided to go somewhere quiet and not crowded. Good food and service. It was 4:30 when we were seated so therefore few customers at that time.I had Mac "n" Cheese with chicken and a Ceasar Salad. Hubby had a flatbread with pulled pork, barbecue sauce, and some other stuff. And a cup of chili. It was all quite good.
We were told a 30 minute wait by host staff we said ok, 45 mins goes by as we see people after us getting seated. So I go back to the host stand and he asked my name, he said we don't have you on the list we thought you left. But I can put you on it, so he took my name this time, 15 minutes goes by, still seeing others getting seated, now we have waited 1 hour. At this point we left without eating or a drink.. a little training is needed up front I think.
Our first visit back to Mahoney;s in a long time was awesome, great service and the food was super tasty. We went back a few weeks later w/ our kids and it was a totally different story. They were fully staffed, but service was really slow, the wait staff mainly hung out at the host/ess station and just talked among themselves. A couple near us was seated, but no one ever stopped over so after about 10 mins they got up and left. After a long wait our food came out, even thought we got the same items as the first time, it was bland and even our kids said their food wasn't that great.
We all had a great time. The food and service were great. I especially enjoyed the cheese curds.