Pizza At Hwy 44

2350 WI-44, Oshkosh
(920) 479-7013

Recent Reviews

Alexis Salzsieder

Excellent pizza at an excellent price. Cooked just perfectly the way I like it. Love their sauce!!

Laurie Stemler

The food is great! The Customer Service is aweful. I had 3 extremely disappointing visits with Customer Service there. One visit I wanted to call ahead so my order would be ready when I got there but the phone just rang and rang. I tried calling multiple times but no one ever answered. When I got there the employee told me he could not answer because there was 1 customer in the store. YES, 1 customer. On another visit I stopped for breakfast on my way to work. When I got to work I had an omelette to eat with no silverware and no ketchup for tots. Today I stopped in to eat there. I set my dessert on a table as I was waiting for my pizza to finish. When I got my pizza, I turned around to find an employee had taken over my table with their papers. All tables were empty and they had to take my table. When I grabbed my desert off the table, she said did u want to sit here. I dont think it takes to much intelligence to figure out if a customer sets their stuff down, they r going to sit there. Employee takes customers table when all tables are empty Really? Where is the Customer Service!

Denny Ellenbecker

Great pizza!!! Super fast in and out in about 10 minutes. First time here and will definitely return. Keep up the great work guys

Michael Lawrence

Some of thee best pizza has to offer!! Personally my favorite is the Aloha Onie.... It's got some heat but omg it's so good!!

Brenda Francis

Great pizza. Good price. Fresh ingredients. Bakes quickly as you wait. I suggest eating there, if you can, so you can have a good firm crust.

Jack C.

Food was excellent but it is so noisy in there and they keep it at 40 degrees in summer need a jacket and ear plugs No caffeine free soda

Chase Bohan

I go here quite often with a coworker, and have never been disappointed. They don’t have a single bad menu item, and everything is always fresh. Friendly staff as well! I quite like the gyro pizza.

Cindy trader

We ordered two pizzas. One a simple sausage pizza, it was fine. The other was suppose to be a Hawaiian pizza. What we got was a ridiculous pizza covered in green peppers and something super spicy, no pizza sauce and covered in some sort of beef or pork and BBQ sauce!!! The outside crust was so hard I couldn't bite into it! I couldn't even break it! Thought it would be a convenient place to stop for supper on our way home. Never ever again. Done!

Michael Blevins

Food was very good. Super tasty and fresh ingredients. Everyone was super friendly and even though they were busy I was still served in a timely manor. I will definitely be going back for more. 10 out of 10 must try again ??

Alex Xx

Price is really high for subpar pizza. Got the Hawaiian style one, and ordered a calzone that was even worse than the pizza. Using ricotta for the cheese is really weird both kids were conplaining so thanks for that. Will not be ordering again.

Charles L.

Ordered delivery to my hotel a couple weeks ago. This pizza was great. It tasted like pretty fresh ingredients and had that crushed tomato sauce that is delicious. I would definitely go back if/when I'm in the area.

Lisa Tiedje

Best pizza with a cauliflower crust hands down, ordered spicy sauce with ricota and tons of veggies. Absolutely delicious and the owner and staff are so friendly!! Highly recommended!

Lisa M.

What a great place. I love the flatbreads, I have had all varieties and they are on point! Delivery is also good. The SALADS THO'! Finally a place that understands we need BIG salads with "any way you like" ingredients at a reasonable price. I won't quit you pizza@44. Keep those salads coming!

Katie Hutchinson

Pizza was awesome and reasonably priced considering the high quality ingredients they use. Owner and staff were very friendly and helped us find the best value. This was our first visit and we had no clue what to do so the owner picked helped us pick out the perfect thing for our group. The cheese bread was amazing. The owner is also very committed to helping serve the community.

Mary Schuman

I have been there twice and I think the food is terrific. The first time I had a regular pizza and cheesy garlic bread. The garlic bread was amazing. I really liked the pizza too. Second time was for breakfast. I had the breakfast pizza on a cauliflower crust. It was very good. And of course I had to have the cheesy garlic bread. Both times the owner was super friendly and made conversation with us while we ate. I will go back again. I think it's my new favorite pizza place.

Load More