Simply Cinnamon Bakery

115 Oakton Ave, Pewaukee
(262) 691-4022

Recent Reviews

MIgielski1

Best place for cinnamon rolls!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll

Jay Krutsch

Tried the breakfast sandwich. It was really just ok. The cinnamon rolls, however, ... that is all the reason you need to stop in there. I love cinnamon rolls and these really hit the spot. They're not too sense and the frosting is amazing. I got the 6 pack for $6 and will absolutely be back. My only complaint is we only bought 1 pack. They did not last long at all. Go get some cinnamon rolls. You'll be glad you did.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll

Thomas Bradley

Always a happy day when I get to stop in at Simply Cinnamon. Tasty treats and some smiles. Thank you!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll

Pete Swan

Just stopped in for a bacon egg and cheese breakfast sandwich and lemme tell you, it does not disappoint! Definitely stop in and grab one!

Robyn G.

Delish cinnamon Rolls, Ham and homemade rolls, stollen,cookies.....all amazing! Recommend this Bakery. Everything Barb makes is over the top! Yum x 100 :) Best Service as well!

Tracy DaRonco

Hot ham and rolls are absolutely amazing!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gina Weber

Delicious hot ham & rolls! Don’t forget to treat yourself to a cinnamon roll, you’ll thank me later ?

Mrs IrocCamarofan

First timer here: Stopped in on Saturday and the owner was more than pleasant and welcoming. Came all the way from Eagle. She was nice enough to sell us some ham and rolls early and both were absolutely delicious. The rolls are amazing and ham has an amazing flavor. Cinnamon rolls were prepackaged and a very decent price. Those were also delicious. MUCH BETTER than kwik trip and not sickeningly sweet like a Cinnabon. Will definitely be back for more!!

Kim Krueger

1st time there for hot ham and rolls, the ham was extremely flavorful. The cinnamon rolls were so delicious heated up, makes me want one now

Meghan R.

The first time I tried Simply Cinnamon's cinnamon rolls, I purchased them at the local Woodman's. I liked them so much that I looked the company up online and was excited to learn that they were close to my family's home. Since then I've been waiting for a visit to the area to go to the source of the delicious cinnamon rolls.Simply Cinnamon is a small business in a small town. They don't offer tables, so you can't stay to enjoy your treats. It's unlike other bakeries that I've been to, there's no big, shiny glass display case full of goodies. We got the mini cinnamon rolls and they were scrumptious. I also tried an iced brownie and it was delightful. There was a sign for hot ham and rolls and I thought it meant that they offered a breakfast sandwich made up of hot ham on a roll. I was sad to learn that they only sell it by the pound. (You need to buy a pound of the ham and then you get a bag of rolls.) I definitely recommend stopping by Simply Cinnamon Bakery, especially for my fellow cinnamon roll lovers.

smith smithy

Fantastic cinnamon rolls! follow the instructions on the label and warm them in the oven at 350 for 5 minutes wrapped in foil! Also the staff was very friendly had a lovely chat with her. I'd skip the breakfast sandwich though it's kind of sub-par.

M Lynch

Fantastic cinnamon rolls! follow the instructions on the label and warm them in the oven at 350 for 5 minutes wrapped in foil! Also the staff was very friendly had a lovely chat with her. I'd skip the breakfast sandwich though it's kind of sub-par.

Matt W

By far the best cinnamon rolls I've ever had! I used to get them at my local Woodmans but haven't seen them in a while?

Chris T.

The owner is amazing. She's super talented, her creations are always amazing and delicious. My favorite is the peanut butter brownies, they are the best brownies I've ever had. She's very helpful with your needs and treats you like a friend, not a customer. My dogs love her handmade dog treats!

Jake Powell

I was out for a Saturday morning drive, and this place just happened to catch my eye, and I’m sure glad it did! Some of the best bakery I have had in a long time! I look forward to going back!

Load More