“Great local food! The pizza is cooked very well and every time we come to Rustique, we are impressed. Very good cocktail menu, salads, and pizzas. They will definitely have something that will please everyone on the menu. It is usually busy, but we have never had a long wait!Update: Seven years later and many visits, this review holds up.“
“I had The Murphy Salad, without almonds it was delicious and I would highly recommend. I made the staff aware of my nut allergy and they went the extra mile to ensure there was no cross contamination. They even delivered my meal to my table next door at Station 1 brewery where I was listening to live music!“
“Great old school soda shop vibe place for kids young and old. Great soft serve, pizzas and burgers. Right by the Zoo so stop in before or after... OR, hear me out... BOTH since they have food and ice-cream AND 18 holes of MINI GOLF! Feed your troops, go to the Zoo. Feed the Giraffes then come back for the rest. There, your weekend is planned. Yes yes, you're welcome. Take pictures and have a great day, say hi to Zuri the giraffe for me.Bonus, good music playing that takes you back in time.“
“They make great pizzas they'll make them the way you would like them I do not like red sauce they have a great white sauce that you can use on your pizzas and they have wonderful desserts they are very friendly and have rewards that you can sign up for where you can get money off your pizza I love that place I will return there.“
“Great pizza and garlic knots. We were there for lunch & couldn't have had better service. The pizza had lots of cheese & toppings. We definitely left full. The restaurant itself was clean but outdated. Think of any late 90's Italian restaurant with red faux leather chairs & checkered table clothes.“
“I love this pizza! The hand tossed classic brings me back to when I was younger and Godfathers was my favorite. Delivery is good but you need to eat this pizza hot to experience it true deliciousness! Melty stretchy cheese,best Italian sausage, sauce is fantastic,perfect amount of veggies! Do yourself a favor and order here!“
“My Gluten Free Flatbread pizza was great! You get to pick 2 toppings, (pay for more if u want them). My husband said his calzone was Wonderful. Again, pick 2 topping(inside it).The place was nice! Service was slim(2 people working the floor)but they did their best on St Patricks Day with a craft sale going on. It was busy.We will be going back.“
“It's a damn good fish fry!Haddock, perch, and walleye options that are crispy and delicious; with slaw, rye bread, onion and potato.There was kind of a slow turnaround for service, about an hour and a half from arrival to the bill, but the food definitely made up for it!“