Island Fever Rum Bar & Grill

6301 WI-57, Sturgeon Bay
(920) 823-2700

Recent Reviews

Therese Lopez

Good food friendly service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Greg Oman

Had dinner there last night with friends, great service at the bar, Mexican entrees we had were great. Fair prices. Would recommend and we will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Taco

Meg Beyer

I've been going here weekly, for years after my shift in DC, and Ive never been dissapointed. The owners are the best company & truly care about your experience- thank you Hunter & Chase. Even with a full house, servers are on their game to provide the best to your party.Drinks are top notch. I stick with with DC Cherry Marg but they offer cocktail flights of their specialty mixed drinks- and much much more.Food ranges from Mexican to burgers & Mac (on Wed/ or Sun) and weekly delicious soups. The spicy cheese curds & loaded tater tots are phenomenal.Also! Dog friendly patio!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger

Matt Boch

Great bar/restaurant in Jacksonport. Came on a Saturday night in the winter and it was dead, no problem getting seating. Probably different in the summer. Good menu of burgers and Mexican.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger, Nachos

Ann Emmerich

Great burgers!! Interesting menu, good quality. And love being by the fireplace. Can't wait to see the outdoor portion this summer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bobbie Dohrwardt

We had a great experience in July so decided to drive an hour and a half last night to have the crab dinner again. It wasn't great. The crab didn't come out of the shells at all like the first time. We'll try it again sometime to figure out if this was a fluke.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

Jeremy Miller

Cute, vibey spot. Worth a stop on a date or with a group. For food or just for a drink.I loved the atmosphere here. It was as though a little surf stop on the beach fused with a Wisconsin cabin.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristin D

I’m always sad if we don’t get a chance to stop here at least once during a Door County trip - sitting outside is definitely our preference, because there are fun yard games and picnic tables, which make you feel you’re really on vacation, but the cocktail flights don’t hurt either! We also love the burgers and fries and lobster rolls. Such a great spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll, Cocktail Flight, French Fries, Burger

Michael Lacenski

Have stopped in quite a few times to begin our weekends in Door County. Have never been disappointed. A great place with great owners that have built a great business. Also the dedicated screen that shows the webcam to Jost Van Dyke in BVI, love it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Buhr

Food is always good. Our waiter was very friendly and checked on us often. Drinks are delicious! It was just a little too dark in the dining room.otherwise, I would have given the atmosphere a 5 star.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

Cindi Rella

Loved all the food options! They have vegetarian options too. Such a good variety.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cocktail Flight, Fish, Nachos

Russ H

This place is great! I don’t give many 5 stars but it earned it! Cool older place, the best patty melt my g/f and me have ever had!! The perch basket was fantastic. Service is very good. Highly recommend trying this place.

paulacC218MT

The servers were friendly. And perhaps it was good they did not ask how things were. Food on 9.29 was awful. My husband had walleye which came deep fried in cubes. His side onion rings were terrible. Barely ate any of it. I had a hamburger that was terrible! And the fries were cold. Advice to cook: serve fries and onions that you fry fresh. Taste what you make.

Global39490322047

AVOID this place! One of the worst services and managers I've ever encountered. My girlfriend and two of our friends stopped in to get food for her to go before our last hike before heading home. We were told it would take about 15-20 minutes. We only had one order of popcorn shrimp. Super simple. After 45 minutes of waiting and my girlfriend asking 3 times where our food was, I went to the bar and asked for the manager. The bartender tried to lie to me and say it hadn't been 45 minutes so I asked to pull the ticket and tell me what time we put the order in. Sure enough it had been. Turns out the food was waiting on the other side of the bar for over 25 minutes. I told the manager we weren't paying for the food after such a long wait and it was cold. The manager was so unprofessional. He shoved the food towards me and said "Here's your food. Your not getting a refund." I told him he could refund it or we'd dispute it. At this point we were leaving and he chased us over to the door to tell us to get out then called me an a**hole. We were already leaving! Even after we were walking to the parking lot, he stalked us out the back door saying to get off his property. The little red mustache guy was seriously creepy and weird and I'm surprised the owners haven't heard of this manager's poor behavior before. Or they're neglecting it because this guy has never been trained in hospitality. This was a perfect opportunity to win over a long time customer by making it right. But instead none of our friends, who own cabins and frequent Door County almost every weekend, will ever give this place another chance. And the food was cold, soggy, and poorly flavored. Save your money, go somewhere where they care about keeping customers. The Covid situation has ruined many establishments since employees haven't been taught to put customers first. Unfortunately this is one place where ownership really let go of their business. Reputation is destroyed among anyone we know. You can tell just by how poor the Health Reviews are since 2020.

Kathleen R

I was super excited to try this spot. Understood it’s a seafood place but it smelled pretty gross…like long John silvers had a cologne. We weren’t greeted which was ok. The cocktails are on draft. Yeah. Draft. They were not good. The bartender seemed too preoccupied with who knows what to make any suggestions or be conversational at all. I’d definitely recommend not going if you’re expecting an inviting atmosphere with hand crafted cocktails.

Load More

Island Fever Rum Bar & Grill

6301 WI-57, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
(920) 823-2700