It was a little after lunch but I still got a 4/5 fish fry. The beer on tap was excellent and the atmosphere was exactly what you want from a cozy Wisconsin bar, cheers! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Dana C.
Great local bar downtown Sun Prairie. Nice clean space with pool table & dart board. Small visible kitchen very efficient & fun to watch. Good burgers. They have every beer you could possibly think of, really great selection!
S G
Great beer selection. Amazing music. And the wings were perfect. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah Bauer
The first time we came, it was during the week and there was barely anyone, so it was great, which prompted my fiancé and I to come back. When we tried to order tonight, upon ordering, we realized there were 2 different menus. The bartender told us ours was wrong and traded menus. When we went back to get our next beer as our food has t come, he told us our menu was wrong again. Once again we had to change our beer choices. While waiting, the table next to us became frustrated and asked where their food was. The bartender said it was taking over an hour for orders which he had not told them or my table. At that point, we had been there for over an hour, so I knew they had been waiting longer. Our food came about an hour and a half later (keep in mind this is bar food). Considering you have to go up and order your own food, I’d expect service to be better. Additionally, instead of turning people away that they were unable to keep up with demands for, they moved people from tables or made them move around the bar to fit more people that they weren’t even fit to serve.Editing to add that my fiancé and I also got food poisoning. I originally rated the food 4 stars, but it definitely wasn’t worth spending the entire day in the bathroom.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lisa F.
Went in a few weeks ago for a perch fry, I asked them if it was lake perch or ocean perch they assured me it was lake perch. Got home and took one bite and I knew immediately it was NOT lake perch, it was absolutely HORRIBLE. I will NEVER go back there again
John Mckoy
Im a tourist in from out of town. I believe I had 3-4 small interactions with possibly the owner. I asked a few questions, had a shot and 3 beers. I wouldn’t say the owner was rude, but he didn’t offer any help or advice when asked. He pointed to a beer list which was old and not accurate, and didn’t seem to care if I enjoyed the experience or not. As a vodka drinker, I don’t know much about beers, yet like to try/sample tap beer from different areas. He just didn’t offer help or seem friendly at all, hopefully he just had an off nite. Their was also a lady working her service was fine. Didn’t try the food, but I wouldn’t recommend going their
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Lisa Falk
Ordered a perch fry to go, thought I would give them a try I have lunch there many times and it has been great however this fish fry is horrible, I DO NOT recommend it at all. What a waste of $15.50
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Lindi W.
Great sandwiches and atmosphere! Always enjoy coming here, no matter what day of the week.
Matthew S.
I used to love this place but it's twice now that I've had a bad experience. The bartender took my money and assumed a tip tonight. That's actually fine. Things were good at this point. I paid for one beer with $5 after my first round and when I was finished, I left to pull the car around for my wife and friends. The bartender forced my wife to pay for my beer again. He told her I hadn't paid. It won't mean much, I'm one person, but I won't be back.
We had the burgers and fries. Burgers were cooked perfectly. We really appreciated the French fries. I had fried onions on my hamburger. They were sweet, cooked just perfect, no bitter char on them, buttery and delicious. Our server was friendly and attentive. We tipped her over 20% because she deserved it.
Elliot Holzwarth
As a Digital Media Consultant I know how powerful reviews are. I live close to this establishment and every time I’ve been there to grab some food, Glen the bartender laughs and snickers in a corner like a little school girl with his regulars if someone new comes in and he doesn’t even remotely try and take my order. I’ve seen it with other male customers as well.This evening when I walked in and sat down with no service forever and a very empty bar; after watching him hang with his boys and I sat there patiently waiting, 3 women and a gentleman walked in, take a guess what happened. Glen walked right by me and straight to the ladies taking about how big his hands are and what that represents. SMH.If you want a good burger and great service in Sun Prairie I highly recommend the Pit Stop. The staff is amazing, attentive, and even if you’re a new face, they treat you as if you’re a regular.If you want a profitable establishment that people rate 5 stars, contact me because Eddie’s is a sinking ship with that cat behind the bar. It’s too bad because it’s a nice space.
Timothy Nott
If you are a fan of "rude" themed service, this is your spot. I walked up to the bar near where the bartender was standing and was chastised for not being in the right spot. "See the sign?!" He said and pointed at. The. Ceiling.No, I did not see the sign hanging from the ceiling. But, having been directed, I made my way to the sign. The thing is, the sign is right above the waitress station. I have had it drilled into me by many hard working wait staff that one NEVER stands there.It was weird. I tried to instruct others in my group about the expected protocol and they just started at me, not quite believing, until they were also roughly directed to the proper spot.Some might find this eccentricity charming. I just wanted to have a beer and chat with some friends.Another quirk, the tap list is only available at the Order Here spot. If you try to look at the tap heads while waiting for someone else to order instead of reading the list, you'll get more curt instructions. Not wanting to cause a back up at the Order Here spot so that I could take in the entire list, I asked the bartender what his favorite thing on tap was and he said it's too hot for beer.I wish I made this up. It's pretty amusing in the third person.
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Sergia Natario
Perfect place to land while out riding your bicycle. There's a shiny new bike rack out back, to lock up to. I stopped in for a quick beer early afternoon. The owner is a great guy.Service is casual and quick.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
John V.
Very casual. Very clean. Nice little selection of bar food. Jalapeño Poppers & Mini Corndogs are a nice go to. But there are burgers and chicken sandwiches with fries or onion rings too. The staff are always friendly. Prices will save you a little vs surrounding spots to eat and drink.
Great selection of beer.
It was a little after lunch but I still got a 4/5 fish fry. The beer on tap was excellent and the atmosphere was exactly what you want from a cozy Wisconsin bar, cheers! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great local bar downtown Sun Prairie. Nice clean space with pool table & dart board. Small visible kitchen very efficient & fun to watch. Good burgers. They have every beer you could possibly think of, really great selection!
Great beer selection. Amazing music. And the wings were perfect. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The first time we came, it was during the week and there was barely anyone, so it was great, which prompted my fiancé and I to come back. When we tried to order tonight, upon ordering, we realized there were 2 different menus. The bartender told us ours was wrong and traded menus. When we went back to get our next beer as our food has t come, he told us our menu was wrong again. Once again we had to change our beer choices. While waiting, the table next to us became frustrated and asked where their food was. The bartender said it was taking over an hour for orders which he had not told them or my table. At that point, we had been there for over an hour, so I knew they had been waiting longer. Our food came about an hour and a half later (keep in mind this is bar food). Considering you have to go up and order your own food, I’d expect service to be better. Additionally, instead of turning people away that they were unable to keep up with demands for, they moved people from tables or made them move around the bar to fit more people that they weren’t even fit to serve.Editing to add that my fiancé and I also got food poisoning. I originally rated the food 4 stars, but it definitely wasn’t worth spending the entire day in the bathroom.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Went in a few weeks ago for a perch fry, I asked them if it was lake perch or ocean perch they assured me it was lake perch. Got home and took one bite and I knew immediately it was NOT lake perch, it was absolutely HORRIBLE. I will NEVER go back there again
Im a tourist in from out of town. I believe I had 3-4 small interactions with possibly the owner. I asked a few questions, had a shot and 3 beers. I wouldn’t say the owner was rude, but he didn’t offer any help or advice when asked. He pointed to a beer list which was old and not accurate, and didn’t seem to care if I enjoyed the experience or not. As a vodka drinker, I don’t know much about beers, yet like to try/sample tap beer from different areas. He just didn’t offer help or seem friendly at all, hopefully he just had an off nite. Their was also a lady working her service was fine. Didn’t try the food, but I wouldn’t recommend going their
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Ordered a perch fry to go, thought I would give them a try I have lunch there many times and it has been great however this fish fry is horrible, I DO NOT recommend it at all. What a waste of $15.50
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Great sandwiches and atmosphere! Always enjoy coming here, no matter what day of the week.
I used to love this place but it's twice now that I've had a bad experience. The bartender took my money and assumed a tip tonight. That's actually fine. Things were good at this point. I paid for one beer with $5 after my first round and when I was finished, I left to pull the car around for my wife and friends. The bartender forced my wife to pay for my beer again. He told her I hadn't paid. It won't mean much, I'm one person, but I won't be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
We had the burgers and fries. Burgers were cooked perfectly. We really appreciated the French fries. I had fried onions on my hamburger. They were sweet, cooked just perfect, no bitter char on them, buttery and delicious. Our server was friendly and attentive. We tipped her over 20% because she deserved it.
As a Digital Media Consultant I know how powerful reviews are. I live close to this establishment and every time I’ve been there to grab some food, Glen the bartender laughs and snickers in a corner like a little school girl with his regulars if someone new comes in and he doesn’t even remotely try and take my order. I’ve seen it with other male customers as well.This evening when I walked in and sat down with no service forever and a very empty bar; after watching him hang with his boys and I sat there patiently waiting, 3 women and a gentleman walked in, take a guess what happened. Glen walked right by me and straight to the ladies taking about how big his hands are and what that represents. SMH.If you want a good burger and great service in Sun Prairie I highly recommend the Pit Stop. The staff is amazing, attentive, and even if you’re a new face, they treat you as if you’re a regular.If you want a profitable establishment that people rate 5 stars, contact me because Eddie’s is a sinking ship with that cat behind the bar. It’s too bad because it’s a nice space.
If you are a fan of "rude" themed service, this is your spot. I walked up to the bar near where the bartender was standing and was chastised for not being in the right spot. "See the sign?!" He said and pointed at. The. Ceiling.No, I did not see the sign hanging from the ceiling. But, having been directed, I made my way to the sign. The thing is, the sign is right above the waitress station. I have had it drilled into me by many hard working wait staff that one NEVER stands there.It was weird. I tried to instruct others in my group about the expected protocol and they just started at me, not quite believing, until they were also roughly directed to the proper spot.Some might find this eccentricity charming. I just wanted to have a beer and chat with some friends.Another quirk, the tap list is only available at the Order Here spot. If you try to look at the tap heads while waiting for someone else to order instead of reading the list, you'll get more curt instructions. Not wanting to cause a back up at the Order Here spot so that I could take in the entire list, I asked the bartender what his favorite thing on tap was and he said it's too hot for beer.I wish I made this up. It's pretty amusing in the third person.
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Perfect place to land while out riding your bicycle. There's a shiny new bike rack out back, to lock up to. I stopped in for a quick beer early afternoon. The owner is a great guy.Service is casual and quick.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Very casual. Very clean. Nice little selection of bar food. Jalapeño Poppers & Mini Corndogs are a nice go to. But there are burgers and chicken sandwiches with fries or onion rings too. The staff are always friendly. Prices will save you a little vs surrounding spots to eat and drink.