If i could i would leave no stars. Ordered here for the first and our order dame terrible. We ordered tossed Buffalo wings and the came raw and with no sauce. The pizza looked like someone had taken a bite out of one of the slices. When we called to let them know no-one answered. Wastes $70 on food that was not edible. Will not be ordering again and will tell friends and family to stay away.
David B.
If i could i would leave no stars. Ordered here for the first and our order dame terrible. We ordered tossed Buffalo wings and the came raw and with no sauce. The pizza looked like someone had taken a bite out of one of the slices. When we called to let them know no-one answered. Wastes $70 on food that was not edible. Will not be ordering again and will tell friends and family to stay away.
T T
Disappointing! Ordered 12 wings with two different sauces; there was barely any sauce but they were oddly soggy, as though they'd been sitting in water. We tried to air fry, which didn't make a difference. Pizzas and breadsticks were overcooked like cardboard. Not worth the $100 spent. First and last time.
Food: 1
Service: 3
RushTwig75
Wings looked like they were dipped in water. Honestly the worst wings I have ever been served. Pizza was not worth the high price. If I'm being positive I liked the crust. We tried to order online but apparently that service was down,so we called it in. Person on the phone was nice. It was our first (and last) time ordering from here.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Ryan No Thanks
Pizza is good but honestly what are these wings? They are terrible and I’m scared to eat the rest.
Nicholas Skenandore
Just tried it for the first time and we loved it. The pie had a flaky crust that I love and the wings were plump and delicious with their Arizona sauce. Will be back again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deep Dish
Diane J.
The food is excellent---if you can get it. We ordered a stuffed pizza Wednesday evening for delivery on Wednesday through Slice, the onlineorderingportal. . About an hour and a half later, nothing arrived. We called the restaurant and we reached voice mail, which said they are closed for delivery. This wasn't mentioned online. Hubby drove to store, and the lights were off and the doors were locked. The only sign said "Tina's $2slices." We ended up going to a different restaurant. Thursday evening, I get a call from a wireless number saying our pizza was delivered. We didn't order anything that night. Sure enough, there was the stuffed pizza and salad we ordered the night before. Hubby called Falbo Bros., and they told him their order told them to deliver it Thursday evening. He tried telling the person answering the phone that no, it was for Wednesday evening. The woman insisted it was for Thursday and told him to take it up with Slice, the online ordering portal. He told her again no, it was for Wednesday evening and explained how we called and stopped at the store to find it closed. She insisted again to take it up with Slice. She didn't have a reply on being closed. We won't be ordering from there again. On a side note, I drove by there this evening, Saturday, and the lights again are off and there's no sign saying when they'll be open again. You are taking a risk ordering from there.
Omar Perez
Look for Tina she is amazing and food is always delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Garlic Bread
K. Caldwell
*Staff was rude and own class.*Had to make 2 trips to pick up food without any apologies or explanation.*refused a refund after food waburnt and smelled like it was burntI don't normally make reviews but I'm really dissapointed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mark and Carol Paus
They have the fastest delivery and the most awesome food we have had in a very long time excellent service
Small interior. Average food. Their stuffed is not true Chicago style. While not great, it wasn’t horrible. Garlic bread was good.Parking: Strip mall style parking.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Mac N
Araceli Esparza
We had a yummy deep dish pizza! Sorry no pictures, but I’m recommending this women owned business! The new owner is very welcoming ✅? Thanks for the
Tracy L.
Love the thin crust Italian Stallion Pizza, the Tony Falboni salad, and wings. Greek Salad is very good, also. They really pay attention to making a good salad. Always a ton of food and well-prepared. Best of the "chain" pizza providers in Sun Prairie, WI.
Fred Pocius
Worse pizza I've ever had. Hardly any cheese on it. Top was so liquidy, I couldn't even make it to my vehicle with out the pizza shifting all over. They did try to fix it but it was still a disaster. Waste of 32dollars
Austin Barlow
I called with short notice (less than 24 hours) for a large group order of 20 pizzas. I spoke with Becky and she didn’t even blink twice at this request. They had the pizzas ready to go at the stated time the next day and they tasted fantastic! Thanks again for the great service!
If i could i would leave no stars. Ordered here for the first and our order dame terrible. We ordered tossed Buffalo wings and the came raw and with no sauce. The pizza looked like someone had taken a bite out of one of the slices. When we called to let them know no-one answered. Wastes $70 on food that was not edible. Will not be ordering again and will tell friends and family to stay away.
If i could i would leave no stars. Ordered here for the first and our order dame terrible. We ordered tossed Buffalo wings and the came raw and with no sauce. The pizza looked like someone had taken a bite out of one of the slices. When we called to let them know no-one answered. Wastes $70 on food that was not edible. Will not be ordering again and will tell friends and family to stay away.
Disappointing! Ordered 12 wings with two different sauces; there was barely any sauce but they were oddly soggy, as though they'd been sitting in water. We tried to air fry, which didn't make a difference. Pizzas and breadsticks were overcooked like cardboard. Not worth the $100 spent. First and last time.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Wings looked like they were dipped in water. Honestly the worst wings I have ever been served. Pizza was not worth the high price. If I'm being positive I liked the crust. We tried to order online but apparently that service was down,so we called it in. Person on the phone was nice. It was our first (and last) time ordering from here.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Pizza is good but honestly what are these wings? They are terrible and I’m scared to eat the rest.
Just tried it for the first time and we loved it. The pie had a flaky crust that I love and the wings were plump and delicious with their Arizona sauce. Will be back again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deep Dish
The food is excellent---if you can get it. We ordered a stuffed pizza Wednesday evening for delivery on Wednesday through Slice, the onlineorderingportal. . About an hour and a half later, nothing arrived. We called the restaurant and we reached voice mail, which said they are closed for delivery. This wasn't mentioned online. Hubby drove to store, and the lights were off and the doors were locked. The only sign said "Tina's $2slices." We ended up going to a different restaurant. Thursday evening, I get a call from a wireless number saying our pizza was delivered. We didn't order anything that night. Sure enough, there was the stuffed pizza and salad we ordered the night before. Hubby called Falbo Bros., and they told him their order told them to deliver it Thursday evening. He tried telling the person answering the phone that no, it was for Wednesday evening. The woman insisted it was for Thursday and told him to take it up with Slice, the online ordering portal. He told her again no, it was for Wednesday evening and explained how we called and stopped at the store to find it closed. She insisted again to take it up with Slice. She didn't have a reply on being closed. We won't be ordering from there again. On a side note, I drove by there this evening, Saturday, and the lights again are off and there's no sign saying when they'll be open again. You are taking a risk ordering from there.
Look for Tina she is amazing and food is always delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Garlic Bread
*Staff was rude and own class.*Had to make 2 trips to pick up food without any apologies or explanation.*refused a refund after food waburnt and smelled like it was burntI don't normally make reviews but I'm really dissapointed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
They have the fastest delivery and the most awesome food we have had in a very long time excellent service
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Small interior. Average food. Their stuffed is not true Chicago style. While not great, it wasn’t horrible. Garlic bread was good.Parking: Strip mall style parking.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Mac N
We had a yummy deep dish pizza! Sorry no pictures, but I’m recommending this women owned business! The new owner is very welcoming ✅? Thanks for the
Love the thin crust Italian Stallion Pizza, the Tony Falboni salad, and wings. Greek Salad is very good, also. They really pay attention to making a good salad. Always a ton of food and well-prepared. Best of the "chain" pizza providers in Sun Prairie, WI.
Worse pizza I've ever had. Hardly any cheese on it. Top was so liquidy, I couldn't even make it to my vehicle with out the pizza shifting all over. They did try to fix it but it was still a disaster. Waste of 32dollars
I called with short notice (less than 24 hours) for a large group order of 20 pizzas. I spoke with Becky and she didn’t even blink twice at this request. They had the pizzas ready to go at the stated time the next day and they tasted fantastic! Thanks again for the great service!