A small-town, homey atmosphere for a company that genuinely loves and cares for the community (they frequently sponsor Verona Area High School events and their sports teams and you can also find their slices at little league games). AJ is an outstanding guy with decades of experience and a love for what he does, and you can taste this in the pizza. Try the AZ Ranch pizza, it's my go-to whenever I visit!
T
Quality pizza will be ordering again in the future. Thanks.
Kyler O'Neil
First pizza was wrong and not even cut. Said 45min was an hr and a half. The second pizza was sent again missing a topping not cooked all the way and I asked for well done twice. Used to be a good place to eat. Got some training to do I understand being busy but I do not understand multiple mistakes back to back.
Phil B
It's ok. Got the basic pepperoni thin crust pizza and cheese sticks. Cheese sticks were way better than the pizza. The pizza was not much better than a frozen pizza. The service was excellent, though. One of the friendliest places I've dealt with in town.
Chad Ogden
Excellent as always!
Patrick Hart
I got a thin crust and deep dish. Both were perfectly cooked with a good amount of toppings.
Sid B.
Is this place fancy? Heck no, but if you could imagine an old neighborhood in Queens NY , this place would fit in , damn good pizza has some seating , 99% of the time I just picked it up!
Lori Veldhuis (McVeldy)
Delicious pizza (we had the AJ Special, thin crust.). Staff and service were both great, nice location across the street from a nice city garden. Want to try the deep dish next time. Peppers, mushrooms, onions on pizza tasted so fresh!
Experience521706
I called to order a pizza... no answer! Great customer service. I read the reviews and was really looking forward to trying one. Nope!
Always great. Ordered a thin crust pepperoni. Great sauce. No gimmicks. Just great pizza
Teresa Amonett
The best pizza around!! It is by far our favorite! Also, they are very responsive if there is ever any issue. That is definitely a sign of a business that cares about their customer and their reputation.
AUXID3
I got a calzone and I'm honestly astonished that AJ's managed to defeat my lowest expectations. The Calzone itself was soggy, the sauce tasted off, and the whole thing smelled weird. Imo, get sugar river.
Kellie K.
I love this place! The pizza is always amazing, with fresh ingredients and great flavor! The owner and staff are friendly and go out of their way to make sure you get exactly what you want. Love the (crust) options too! My favorite is the pizza sauce. It just makes the pizza taste great no matter what style of crust or what toppings!
James Herkert
Best pizza in the whole Madison area. The thin crust is perfect and the sauce has the right amount of spice. Delivery arrived 10 minutes earlier than expected.
A small-town, homey atmosphere for a company that genuinely loves and cares for the community (they frequently sponsor Verona Area High School events and their sports teams and you can also find their slices at little league games). AJ is an outstanding guy with decades of experience and a love for what he does, and you can taste this in the pizza. Try the AZ Ranch pizza, it's my go-to whenever I visit!
Quality pizza will be ordering again in the future. Thanks.
First pizza was wrong and not even cut. Said 45min was an hr and a half. The second pizza was sent again missing a topping not cooked all the way and I asked for well done twice. Used to be a good place to eat. Got some training to do I understand being busy but I do not understand multiple mistakes back to back.
It's ok. Got the basic pepperoni thin crust pizza and cheese sticks. Cheese sticks were way better than the pizza. The pizza was not much better than a frozen pizza. The service was excellent, though. One of the friendliest places I've dealt with in town.
Excellent as always!
I got a thin crust and deep dish. Both were perfectly cooked with a good amount of toppings.
Is this place fancy? Heck no, but if you could imagine an old neighborhood in Queens NY , this place would fit in , damn good pizza has some seating , 99% of the time I just picked it up!
Delicious pizza (we had the AJ Special, thin crust.). Staff and service were both great, nice location across the street from a nice city garden. Want to try the deep dish next time. Peppers, mushrooms, onions on pizza tasted so fresh!
I called to order a pizza... no answer! Great customer service. I read the reviews and was really looking forward to trying one. Nope!
Delicious! Great service.
Restaurantji Recommends
Always great. Ordered a thin crust pepperoni. Great sauce. No gimmicks. Just great pizza
The best pizza around!! It is by far our favorite! Also, they are very responsive if there is ever any issue. That is definitely a sign of a business that cares about their customer and their reputation.
I got a calzone and I'm honestly astonished that AJ's managed to defeat my lowest expectations. The Calzone itself was soggy, the sauce tasted off, and the whole thing smelled weird. Imo, get sugar river.
I love this place! The pizza is always amazing, with fresh ingredients and great flavor! The owner and staff are friendly and go out of their way to make sure you get exactly what you want. Love the (crust) options too! My favorite is the pizza sauce. It just makes the pizza taste great no matter what style of crust or what toppings!
Best pizza in the whole Madison area. The thin crust is perfect and the sauce has the right amount of spice. Delivery arrived 10 minutes earlier than expected.