I have had two incredible experiences at Craig’s Cake Shop and just had to share! The cakes are absolutely delicious, especially the mousse filling. It’s my FAVORITE part of their cakes!The owner was incredibly responsive and transparent when I had questions about pricing, which I really appreciated. It’s clear that they value their customers and strive for excellent service.Not only are they kind and accommodating, but they can also make essentially any design you desire. Last year, I got a custom-designed cake and added my own toppers, and it was exactly what I had imagined. This year, I chose to go with a more simple design, and they executed it flawlessly as well.I was amazed at the creativity and skill they put into every cake. Overall, I highly recommend Craig’s Cake Shop for anyone looking for delicious cakes and exceptional service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Katie Larocco
This is my second year getting a cake for my partners birthday and once again they have knocked it out of the park. The decorating. On point. The flavor. To die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Wedig
We had the most amazing wedding cake- so delicious, flavorful and a beautiful design. Everyone at our wedding said it was the best cake they’ve ever had. They also have the most talented team who can make your cake design dreams come true. I would highly recommend working with Elisa and the Craig’s Cakes team for your cake at your next special event!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marilyn Rhodes
Incredible cake decorating skills and fabulous cake! I ordered a “vintage“ style cake for a 70th birthday. The cake was simply stunning. Delicate flowers with petite swirls and stars cascaded down three sides of the cake. The pattern was repeated on top. It was neither too much nor too little. Just the right balance. If you’re looking for a cake with amazing flavor and just too pretty to eat, go to Craig’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Custom Cake
Kels
The actual cake was good. However, we were not told that the sides of the cake would be covered in white chocolate curls. We also did not know that when we asked for butter cream frosting, it would only have buttercream on the top of the cake. The sides were covered with a “light whipped frosting” which tasted like fake whipped cream. Tip: Please explain fully what will be on your cakes. This was my first time ordering a cake from you. If I knew you automatically cover your cakes with white chocolate, I would’ve requested that they not be used. (Unfortunately, I did not go to your website- I phoned the order in- because then maybe I would have had a better idea of how you make your cakes). Lastly, I was told I HAD to order a mousse filling which I really had only wanted a jam layer.I did appreciate the friendliness of the staff and the decorations were pretty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Bird House
I recently had my wedding 11/11/23. The cake was absolutely delicious. Everyone loved the cake and raved about it. I'm still getting messages about how people loved the cake. We had three different flavors for each tier and each one turned out perfect. I would highly recommend for the taste alone. The cake was simple, but pretty. The branch design matched my centerpieces which added to the overall theme of my wedding.The downside was the process. We didn't get to see our cake until we walked into our venue on our wedding day. Our cake toppers weren't on the cake, which was a bummer. We had some hiccups during the order with a lost deposit and the wrong flavors being written down. It didn't ruin the experience, but it did make things difficult to give them a glowing review.But even with all that, we are excited to get our anniversary cake from them next year!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Jordan Gravlin (JGSeliot)
Got our wedding cake on time and set up and it was the best cake I've ever had. Everyone thought it and the sheet cake we got was amazing. Thank you for a beautiful cake and will definitely order cakes from here in the future for other events.
Natalie Nordeen
We bought our wedding cake from Craig's Cakes. The process started with a private tasting at their store to sample their wedding cake sponges, fillings, and frostings. Be warned, you will likely want to order every combination because they were all so GOOD! Elisa was awesome with communication and the delivery and setup went smooth as butter(cream) thanks to her.The picture below speaks for itself, but it must be said that the cake was GORGEOUS. Elisa came in and arranged the floral accents during setup and put our little corgi figurine on for the finishing touches.Our guests were very complimentary of both the gluten-free/vegan cake and the traditional wedding cake. We can't wait for our anniversary cake!Thank you, Craig's Cakes
Katie Will
The customer service at Craig’s is impeccable and the cake is delicious. I ordered a beach-themed cake for my son’s first birthday; in a profound fail, I messed up the hours and didn't come to get it before the shop closed on pickup day. Elisa left me two voicemails, both of which I missed. I eventually called and emailed back, assuming I was out of luck, but she responded quickly, stayed in contact throughout the afternoon, and took time to return to the shop that evening so I could get the cake after all (!!!) I was so grateful that she went the extra mile despite my mistake, especially because it was for a special occasion. And the cake was lovely—the shop asked me to provide an image to use, which they reproduced faithfully and adorably. The raspberry cream cheese filling was excellent, too. I can’t recommend Craig’s enough!
Amber Sherrill
Put together a super cute cow cake for my daughter's birthday!
We had a carrot cake for a birthday party with over 200 people attending and everyone raved about how great the cake was. even my sister a professor baker said it was awesome‼‼‼
Jennifer Kim
I got a cake made for my boyfriend's birthday and it turned out great and tasted absolutely amazing! It was a vanilla cake with lemon mousse and raspberry jam with a custom message on top and the price was affordable! I will definitely come back here again!
Jessica Steadman
Craigs Cake Shop recently provided my wedding with cupcakes, cake pops, and a cutting cake. Everything was so delicious and beautiful. We got so many compliments on the uniqueness of the cake pops and the flavors.They have so many flavors to choose from and they are all so good! We specifically chose Strawberry Key lime, Double Chocolate, and Neapolitan Cake Pops.
Samantha Arnston
We got a sample platter to figure out what to get for our wedding, and it was a very difficult experience. How are you supposed to narrow down 24+ flavors when they are all amazing? We simply couldn't decide, so went with a variety of flavors in the forms of cupcakes, donuts, and we even threw in some cream puffs. Our guests LOVED everything, especially the lemon poppyseed donuts that were a huge hit. People simply couldn't get enough, it was like a pack of piranhas. One of our friends went back for their 6th cupcake and I had to stop him. We ordered plenty and thankfully our coordinator saved us 1 of each type because everything was gone. My body is now like 2% cupcake. No regrets.
Caughey Zachery
Craig’s provided the cake and desserts for our wedding and everything was absolutely phenomenal. The shop owners and staff are so kind and helpful and we loved working with them for our event. The flavors we picked for our tiers totally ended up being our favorites of the night but the small desserts were just as good!
I have had two incredible experiences at Craig’s Cake Shop and just had to share! The cakes are absolutely delicious, especially the mousse filling. It’s my FAVORITE part of their cakes!The owner was incredibly responsive and transparent when I had questions about pricing, which I really appreciated. It’s clear that they value their customers and strive for excellent service.Not only are they kind and accommodating, but they can also make essentially any design you desire. Last year, I got a custom-designed cake and added my own toppers, and it was exactly what I had imagined. This year, I chose to go with a more simple design, and they executed it flawlessly as well.I was amazed at the creativity and skill they put into every cake. Overall, I highly recommend Craig’s Cake Shop for anyone looking for delicious cakes and exceptional service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
This is my second year getting a cake for my partners birthday and once again they have knocked it out of the park. The decorating. On point. The flavor. To die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had the most amazing wedding cake- so delicious, flavorful and a beautiful design. Everyone at our wedding said it was the best cake they’ve ever had. They also have the most talented team who can make your cake design dreams come true. I would highly recommend working with Elisa and the Craig’s Cakes team for your cake at your next special event!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible cake decorating skills and fabulous cake! I ordered a “vintage“ style cake for a 70th birthday. The cake was simply stunning. Delicate flowers with petite swirls and stars cascaded down three sides of the cake. The pattern was repeated on top. It was neither too much nor too little. Just the right balance. If you’re looking for a cake with amazing flavor and just too pretty to eat, go to Craig’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Custom Cake
The actual cake was good. However, we were not told that the sides of the cake would be covered in white chocolate curls. We also did not know that when we asked for butter cream frosting, it would only have buttercream on the top of the cake. The sides were covered with a “light whipped frosting” which tasted like fake whipped cream. Tip: Please explain fully what will be on your cakes. This was my first time ordering a cake from you. If I knew you automatically cover your cakes with white chocolate, I would’ve requested that they not be used. (Unfortunately, I did not go to your website- I phoned the order in- because then maybe I would have had a better idea of how you make your cakes). Lastly, I was told I HAD to order a mousse filling which I really had only wanted a jam layer.I did appreciate the friendliness of the staff and the decorations were pretty.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I recently had my wedding 11/11/23. The cake was absolutely delicious. Everyone loved the cake and raved about it. I'm still getting messages about how people loved the cake. We had three different flavors for each tier and each one turned out perfect. I would highly recommend for the taste alone. The cake was simple, but pretty. The branch design matched my centerpieces which added to the overall theme of my wedding.The downside was the process. We didn't get to see our cake until we walked into our venue on our wedding day. Our cake toppers weren't on the cake, which was a bummer. We had some hiccups during the order with a lost deposit and the wrong flavors being written down. It didn't ruin the experience, but it did make things difficult to give them a glowing review.But even with all that, we are excited to get our anniversary cake from them next year!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Got our wedding cake on time and set up and it was the best cake I've ever had. Everyone thought it and the sheet cake we got was amazing. Thank you for a beautiful cake and will definitely order cakes from here in the future for other events.
We bought our wedding cake from Craig's Cakes. The process started with a private tasting at their store to sample their wedding cake sponges, fillings, and frostings. Be warned, you will likely want to order every combination because they were all so GOOD! Elisa was awesome with communication and the delivery and setup went smooth as butter(cream) thanks to her.The picture below speaks for itself, but it must be said that the cake was GORGEOUS. Elisa came in and arranged the floral accents during setup and put our little corgi figurine on for the finishing touches.Our guests were very complimentary of both the gluten-free/vegan cake and the traditional wedding cake. We can't wait for our anniversary cake!Thank you, Craig's Cakes
The customer service at Craig’s is impeccable and the cake is delicious. I ordered a beach-themed cake for my son’s first birthday; in a profound fail, I messed up the hours and didn't come to get it before the shop closed on pickup day. Elisa left me two voicemails, both of which I missed. I eventually called and emailed back, assuming I was out of luck, but she responded quickly, stayed in contact throughout the afternoon, and took time to return to the shop that evening so I could get the cake after all (!!!) I was so grateful that she went the extra mile despite my mistake, especially because it was for a special occasion. And the cake was lovely—the shop asked me to provide an image to use, which they reproduced faithfully and adorably. The raspberry cream cheese filling was excellent, too. I can’t recommend Craig’s enough!
Put together a super cute cow cake for my daughter's birthday!
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a carrot cake for a birthday party with over 200 people attending and everyone raved about how great the cake was. even my sister a professor baker said it was awesome‼‼‼
I got a cake made for my boyfriend's birthday and it turned out great and tasted absolutely amazing! It was a vanilla cake with lemon mousse and raspberry jam with a custom message on top and the price was affordable! I will definitely come back here again!
Craigs Cake Shop recently provided my wedding with cupcakes, cake pops, and a cutting cake. Everything was so delicious and beautiful. We got so many compliments on the uniqueness of the cake pops and the flavors.They have so many flavors to choose from and they are all so good! We specifically chose Strawberry Key lime, Double Chocolate, and Neapolitan Cake Pops.
We got a sample platter to figure out what to get for our wedding, and it was a very difficult experience. How are you supposed to narrow down 24+ flavors when they are all amazing? We simply couldn't decide, so went with a variety of flavors in the forms of cupcakes, donuts, and we even threw in some cream puffs. Our guests LOVED everything, especially the lemon poppyseed donuts that were a huge hit. People simply couldn't get enough, it was like a pack of piranhas. One of our friends went back for their 6th cupcake and I had to stop him. We ordered plenty and thankfully our coordinator saved us 1 of each type because everything was gone. My body is now like 2% cupcake. No regrets.
Craig’s provided the cake and desserts for our wedding and everything was absolutely phenomenal. The shop owners and staff are so kind and helpful and we loved working with them for our event. The flavors we picked for our tiers totally ended up being our favorites of the night but the small desserts were just as good!