Tally's Tap & Eatery

S31W24661 W Sunset Dr, Waukesha
(262) 446-3153

Recent Reviews

Scott P.

Great local general American cuisine restaurant. Good service (though busy as they seemed a bit short staffed), solid drinks, and reasonable prices. Gets a bit loud with music late at night if you are just eating dinner.

David D.

The Best Cobb salad I ever had. Was almost too big. Friendly staff and patrons also.

Laura Turk

Came for a fish fry with 2 "starving kiddos" and a 50 minute wait. The owner, Jessica, sent crackers for my kids to munch on during our wait. talk about family friendly!! 5 stars all the way!!

Rena Rodriguez

Great drink prices, LOVED the reuben rolls and the wings were good.

Laurie Evert Aldrich

Great drinks, food and service

Ana T.

Second time we sat and waited at our table for 10-15 minutes without being acknowledge and left disappointed. I can appreciate that many places are understaffed with the present day COVID outbreak, but a quick hello to acknowledge we were there would of been great. The deal breaker was when 2 tables that came after us were served drinks. Sorry Tally's, but your non-regulars deserve the same welcome especially when our intention is wanting to support our communities local businesses.

Kandice Cross

Great atmosphere, wonderful owners and staff. The owners aren't humps either. They are almost always working the bar/restaurant/kitchen to make things easier on their staff (on top of their business running duties) AMAZING food!! Overall, a great place to grab a drink or a bite

Renee M.

They have a large selection of delicious food. They treat their patrons like family. A great place for the whole family.

Varla Bernett Bishop

Very good food. Large quantities and great flavors awesome Bloody Mary’s

Wayne M Groth

Stop here anytime we are in the area - great food and very nice people!

Dawn K.

We ordered two cod fish fries to go. Order was correct and hot. Plenty of food in each dinner and it was great!

Shannon C.

We have yet to be able to visit in person, but we have ordered food from them quite a few times and it NEVER disappoints. Can't wait to stop in soon and get the full experience!

Sivali P.

This used to be one of my favorite spots for wings but today we went in and had horrible service. We went in for their usual 65 cent wing deal and upon arriving to the restaurant we were told by the bartender "Oh sorry we just changed our prices today. It should be updated online." We pulled up their menu on their website and it still displays the 65 cent wing deal. Very unprofessional to not update the website and then to not honor the price that is written. The bartender was very rude and stated that they updated their prices on facebook. How does it make sense to have facebook updated but not your own website. Also, how is $1 wing a deal? We will not be coming back after that experience.

r01313

Second visit and once again pleased with the food and service. Had the loaded mushroom swiss burger with chips and it was very good. Our server and server-in-training were great.

Erin V.

Needed to feed our faces while driving through to Milwaukee for a long weekend. Decided to stop here based on reviews and I wasn't looking for a chain restaurant that I can get in Minnesota. Parking was easy. Restaurant was semi busy for the draft. Seated right away which is good because remember we needed to feed our faces lol Drinks came (all sodas) and our server disappeared for a good 10-15 minutes. Finally after we started staring at every server that came by she finally made it back to us so we hurried and ordered just in case it would be lengthy before her next visit. Cheesecurds, Panko Avocado for apps both ok. I was surprised for being in WI how little and meh the curds were. Getting our food took about 20-25 minutes as my lovely 11 year old reminded us...but Dinner was the TurkeyABLT with fries, Build your own grilled cheese and the Dip. I messed up my grilled cheese but it was still good and everyone killed their food..cause again feed our faces to make that last 40 min stretch to the Airbnb. I feel for our server she seemed like she hates her job...not a smile nothing!

Load More