Was looking forward to this... what a shame. Sat around 4:25, received dinner plates, napkins, and menus from the very nice hostess. But no server ever came. We waited. My disabled mother had time to use the restroom. She said it was nice. But we waited. I waved at the bar man. He smiled. We waited. I got up and walked around but wasn't able to get anyone's attention... no one seemed to want to serve us. Don't you want customers? Won't be back.
Alcindo Correa Filho
At this point the best pizza in Wisconsin. Nice place, beer (foxtown) and wine (try tap wine) and of course a delicious pizza. We had a mix of Hawaiian and Pizza Man Special. Fresh and crunchy. Love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Tiramisu
Kimberly Schmidt
Fantastic night at Pizza Man! We ordered the cheese curds with aioli dipping sauce, eggplant fries and Topher pizza and everything was incredible! Service was great and food was served quickly. Definitely going to be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Mestrovich
Food was good, but the service was atrocious. I wasn't even able to get a refill of water. I ate my whole meal without liquid.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Elizabeth Scott
I got a small pizza to go. When I got home and took a bite I found a small black hair. Upon closer inspection there were 3 small black hairs on my pizza. Needless to say I didn’t eat it. But the one bite I did have tasted flavorless. Would not recommend.
Food: 1
Ms. FeFe
I truly love this placeParking: I keep going back because of the food as well as the kind stuff
It was disappointing today. I intentionally ordered the large shaved Brussel sprout salad (this is our favorite and it usually provides us with 3 nice size side salads, but this time it was a handful of arugula with 1 brussel sprout cut in half that I had to peel apart so we could all get a few leaves. Hoping next time this won't happen - we expect more especially when pay and tip ahead before we pick it up.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
sdennison
Stopped for a quick lunch, first time patron. Outstanding industrial decor, friendly staff and outstanding pizza. Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dale Marki
Too pricey
John Johnson
I would give this place less than 1 star rating. Server was slow 45 min after being seates, we finally were able to order, server was very rude. Order was cold and incomplete. They had to resubmit and cook order. When it came out after most of the party had finishedEating. The bills were all wrong took them almost an hour to fix. Items we had asked for were never brought out. Management never stepped in to hel his servers.The food was very low quality for high quality prices. Most members of our party have worked in the restaurant and service industry's.I would never recommend this place.
Every time we’ve been here in the past 6 months we’ve had to wait double the amount of time for our food. We were willing to look past the first time (where we waited 2.5 hours to get our food at our table for 2 people) because the chicken Alfredo and salad was really good! Probably the best chicken Alfredo I’ve ever had. The sauce was homemade, lots of different cheeses, and the noodles were done perfectly. But today we ordered that same dish for take out and it wasn’t the same at all. The Alfredo sauce tasted like something you could buy from the grocery store, bland and just bad. The noodles didn’t taste as good either, another store bought taste. The dressing for the salad tasted bad as well, not nearly as good as last time. We are so disappointed, especially bc they charge you close to $25 for this chicken Alfredo! This place really needs to get its act together, we are so sad we probably won’t be back because our favorite dishes are changed, probably to make a better profit for them but at the same time greatly diminishing the flavor. Such a waste of money and time!
Jen W.
The service here is genuinely disappointing. We had a reservation (with a text confirmation) for 13 people and when we arrived the system didn't show our reservation. The hostess essentially walked away from us and barely said anything for several minutes (during which time we stood in the doorway awkwardly). When she came back she said "good news, we can accommodate you" and acted like this was a favor - when it was a system error on their end. Our server was nice enough but everything was incredibly slow, and given our party size there probably should have been a second server. It took us nearly 45 minutes to get drinks after ordering, and the food also took a long time to come out. I don't think she was very accessible and didn't really check in on us once we got the food or if we needed more drinks or water. The pizzas were done well and very tasty - thin crust and lots of great topping combinations. The interior was also very well done - a rustic and welcoming space with lots of wood beams, though they had really begun closing up by 7:30 on a Saturday night with lots of chairs already stacked on top of tables. We also had some issues with the QR code system for payment not reflecting that our payments had gone through, which was just another event in this unfortunate comedy of errors.
Guillermo Diaz Ordaz
The food sucks. Management seems lazy and unorganized. Staff is inattentive. Never coming back. ????
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike Harloff
Excellent service, outstanding pizza, VERY noisy. Some sound absorbing materials would greatly enhance the experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Milwaukee
Gintare Lapunaite
Decent pizza. But for the price it's a reach. $26 for an extremely thin crust large that leaves you hungry in a bit of time.... ehhhh. Tastes good but still nowhere near worth the cost in my opinion.
Was looking forward to this... what a shame. Sat around 4:25, received dinner plates, napkins, and menus from the very nice hostess. But no server ever came. We waited. My disabled mother had time to use the restroom. She said it was nice. But we waited. I waved at the bar man. He smiled. We waited. I got up and walked around but wasn't able to get anyone's attention... no one seemed to want to serve us. Don't you want customers? Won't be back.
At this point the best pizza in Wisconsin. Nice place, beer (foxtown) and wine (try tap wine) and of course a delicious pizza. We had a mix of Hawaiian and Pizza Man Special. Fresh and crunchy. Love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Tiramisu
Fantastic night at Pizza Man! We ordered the cheese curds with aioli dipping sauce, eggplant fries and Topher pizza and everything was incredible! Service was great and food was served quickly. Definitely going to be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was good, but the service was atrocious. I wasn't even able to get a refill of water. I ate my whole meal without liquid.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
I got a small pizza to go. When I got home and took a bite I found a small black hair. Upon closer inspection there were 3 small black hairs on my pizza. Needless to say I didn’t eat it. But the one bite I did have tasted flavorless. Would not recommend.
Food: 1
I truly love this placeParking: I keep going back because of the food as well as the kind stuff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Eggplant Fries, Garlic Bread
It was disappointing today. I intentionally ordered the large shaved Brussel sprout salad (this is our favorite and it usually provides us with 3 nice size side salads, but this time it was a handful of arugula with 1 brussel sprout cut in half that I had to peel apart so we could all get a few leaves. Hoping next time this won't happen - we expect more especially when pay and tip ahead before we pick it up.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Stopped for a quick lunch, first time patron. Outstanding industrial decor, friendly staff and outstanding pizza. Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Too pricey
I would give this place less than 1 star rating. Server was slow 45 min after being seates, we finally were able to order, server was very rude. Order was cold and incomplete. They had to resubmit and cook order. When it came out after most of the party had finishedEating. The bills were all wrong took them almost an hour to fix. Items we had asked for were never brought out. Management never stepped in to hel his servers.The food was very low quality for high quality prices. Most members of our party have worked in the restaurant and service industry's.I would never recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Every time we’ve been here in the past 6 months we’ve had to wait double the amount of time for our food. We were willing to look past the first time (where we waited 2.5 hours to get our food at our table for 2 people) because the chicken Alfredo and salad was really good! Probably the best chicken Alfredo I’ve ever had. The sauce was homemade, lots of different cheeses, and the noodles were done perfectly. But today we ordered that same dish for take out and it wasn’t the same at all. The Alfredo sauce tasted like something you could buy from the grocery store, bland and just bad. The noodles didn’t taste as good either, another store bought taste. The dressing for the salad tasted bad as well, not nearly as good as last time. We are so disappointed, especially bc they charge you close to $25 for this chicken Alfredo! This place really needs to get its act together, we are so sad we probably won’t be back because our favorite dishes are changed, probably to make a better profit for them but at the same time greatly diminishing the flavor. Such a waste of money and time!
The service here is genuinely disappointing. We had a reservation (with a text confirmation) for 13 people and when we arrived the system didn't show our reservation. The hostess essentially walked away from us and barely said anything for several minutes (during which time we stood in the doorway awkwardly). When she came back she said "good news, we can accommodate you" and acted like this was a favor - when it was a system error on their end. Our server was nice enough but everything was incredibly slow, and given our party size there probably should have been a second server. It took us nearly 45 minutes to get drinks after ordering, and the food also took a long time to come out. I don't think she was very accessible and didn't really check in on us once we got the food or if we needed more drinks or water. The pizzas were done well and very tasty - thin crust and lots of great topping combinations. The interior was also very well done - a rustic and welcoming space with lots of wood beams, though they had really begun closing up by 7:30 on a Saturday night with lots of chairs already stacked on top of tables. We also had some issues with the QR code system for payment not reflecting that our payments had gone through, which was just another event in this unfortunate comedy of errors.
The food sucks. Management seems lazy and unorganized. Staff is inattentive. Never coming back. ????
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent service, outstanding pizza, VERY noisy. Some sound absorbing materials would greatly enhance the experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Milwaukee
Decent pizza. But for the price it's a reach. $26 for an extremely thin crust large that leaves you hungry in a bit of time.... ehhhh. Tastes good but still nowhere near worth the cost in my opinion.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3