Just had lunch at Nico’s. This was the best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Cracker thin crust, big pieces of sausage, sauce that was awesome! Our server was great. Can’t say enough good things about it. Will definitely be back!
Rob F.
Have been to West Allis location about five times in the last six weeks. Fresh Motz app is awesome love the tomatoes and balsamic glaze. Cracker crust pizza both classic and portobello are great. Love the sausage patty style on the pizza. It does however seem like the sauce on the pizza has changed since the first few visits. Much more spicier now. I personally don't care for it but I know others prefer it. Service is always good
Chris Smith
We had a pepperoni pizza and a sausage pizza. Both had a great sauce but didn't care for the frozen cracker style crust. Also had the garlic bread and garlic bread with cheese and they were both great. Our waitress was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Skyler Donner
Cool place to hang with friends and grab some pizza. Lots of good drink options. Pizza was ok but wasn't what I was expecting based on the hype. I'll be back, Maybe I need to try some other options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
Carol Sroka
Parking: Lots of spaces.Kid-friendliness: Family place to go.Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Shelly Judkins Jr.
We were told about Nico’s by a neighbor so we gave this place a try. We were very pleased, our waitress was great, checked on us 4-5 times making sure everything was alright. The restaurant looks to have been remodeled and was very clean, and the pizza was loaded with toppings. A thin crust, crispy, sauce a bit in the sweet side, nice spice, fresh onions, large pepperoni, was very delicious and surely will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
Nicole Krakow
The hostess immediately greeted us and we seated right away. Servers were young and new, friendly and attentive. The garlic bread was really good. There was a little hiccup with our entrees -the Italian sandwich came out long before the pizzas did, but it tasted great. The pizzas were extremely saucy, which isn't our preference, but other than that it was a good experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
Britney Moses
I've been hesitating to write this review for Nico's, simply because it's become one of our new favorite spots, and it seems to be gaining quite the stellar reputation, becoming busier by the day.Let's start with the staff - they're expanding, and each member has been consistently pleasant. However, our preference is always to sit at the bar and be served by Russ. He's not only knowledgeable but excels in creating a consistently positive experience every visit.Now, onto the food - it's simply divine, with the menu continually expanding. Admittedly, we've only sampled the cheese garlic bread and the pizza so far, but they've become our go-to choices. In fact, our current favorite pizza is the pepperoni and pepperoncini, which we've ordered for pickup and dined in with nearly a dozen times since late December. The consistency and quality keep us coming back for more.The homemade sauce is a standout, generously applied atop a perfectly balanced crust that's neither too thin nor too thick. The use of large pepperonis adds an extra layer of flavor that's simply scrumptious.As for the cheese garlic bread, while it's not personally my favorite of all time, but it's still undeniably delicious. Interestingly, we recently introduced it to some friends, and one of them became absolutely obsessed, claiming it's the best they've ever had. They even joked about returning solely for that garlic bread, and have talked about it several times since they had it.Nico's continues to impress with its delightful staff, delectable food, and welcoming ambiance. It's no wonder it's becoming increasingly popular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
Betty Baum
This was truly the best pizza compared to any. Nice crispy crust, loads of toppings, the sauce is flavorful. The cheesy garlic bread out compared competitor, and of course the tiramasu was fantastic!We look forward to coming back for more and sharing with friends.Thank you for the wonderful experience and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barry Badura
Unique pizza, no flop. Seeds ground in the sausage. Fresh ingredients starting at the appetizers.
Visited Nico's for the first time today. A friend raved about their Oconomowoc location, so I was looking forward to trying them. I bought one of their frozen pizzas at Metcalfe's Market for $16 and was disappointed. Today's experience at their new West Allis location, in the former Crawdaddy's and Shakey's space, was a great experience! I ordered the 12" Classic, which is topped with BIG chunks of Italian Sausage, red onions, and fresh mushrooms, and I added pepperoni. The first thing I noticed was how thick the pizza was with cheese and toppings. Then I picked up a slice and was surprised by how well the crispy, Tavern Cut, slice held the heavy toppings. This was true of the center slices, as well. Super thin crust that doesn't flop or get soft in the center! That speaks to the quality of the ingredients, how well the pizza dough is made, and the temperature of the oven. The pizza tasted great, and I will be back. It may already be in my top 5 favorite thin crust pizzas in Milwaukee.
stephanie k.
We had very good service and the pizza was incredible! Will be back to try out other things
Dan Schuyler
Mushroom Sausage and Motz drop pizza was well presented like artwork! Only complaint was that sauce is a pretty spicy! Service and atmosphere was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Graham Floreani
The pizza and appetizers at this place were really good and I'm a fan of the limited menu. The staff need to be better acquainted with restaurant service, we had a lot of awkward/ funny moments with them while dining in.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Truffle Fries, Sausage Pizza
Angela Damask
I took my daughter on a Saturday and it was pretty busy. The amazing hostess found us a table for two so we didn’t have to wait long. Our server was Ty and she was so sweet! Everyone there was so nice and the food was great too!
Just had lunch at Nico’s. This was the best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Cracker thin crust, big pieces of sausage, sauce that was awesome! Our server was great. Can’t say enough good things about it. Will definitely be back!
Have been to West Allis location about five times in the last six weeks. Fresh Motz app is awesome love the tomatoes and balsamic glaze. Cracker crust pizza both classic and portobello are great. Love the sausage patty style on the pizza. It does however seem like the sauce on the pizza has changed since the first few visits. Much more spicier now. I personally don't care for it but I know others prefer it. Service is always good
We had a pepperoni pizza and a sausage pizza. Both had a great sauce but didn't care for the frozen cracker style crust. Also had the garlic bread and garlic bread with cheese and they were both great. Our waitress was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Cool place to hang with friends and grab some pizza. Lots of good drink options. Pizza was ok but wasn't what I was expecting based on the hype. I'll be back, Maybe I need to try some other options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
Parking: Lots of spaces.Kid-friendliness: Family place to go.Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
We were told about Nico’s by a neighbor so we gave this place a try. We were very pleased, our waitress was great, checked on us 4-5 times making sure everything was alright. The restaurant looks to have been remodeled and was very clean, and the pizza was loaded with toppings. A thin crust, crispy, sauce a bit in the sweet side, nice spice, fresh onions, large pepperoni, was very delicious and surely will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
The hostess immediately greeted us and we seated right away. Servers were young and new, friendly and attentive. The garlic bread was really good. There was a little hiccup with our entrees -the Italian sandwich came out long before the pizzas did, but it tasted great. The pizzas were extremely saucy, which isn't our preference, but other than that it was a good experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
I've been hesitating to write this review for Nico's, simply because it's become one of our new favorite spots, and it seems to be gaining quite the stellar reputation, becoming busier by the day.Let's start with the staff - they're expanding, and each member has been consistently pleasant. However, our preference is always to sit at the bar and be served by Russ. He's not only knowledgeable but excels in creating a consistently positive experience every visit.Now, onto the food - it's simply divine, with the menu continually expanding. Admittedly, we've only sampled the cheese garlic bread and the pizza so far, but they've become our go-to choices. In fact, our current favorite pizza is the pepperoni and pepperoncini, which we've ordered for pickup and dined in with nearly a dozen times since late December. The consistency and quality keep us coming back for more.The homemade sauce is a standout, generously applied atop a perfectly balanced crust that's neither too thin nor too thick. The use of large pepperonis adds an extra layer of flavor that's simply scrumptious.As for the cheese garlic bread, while it's not personally my favorite of all time, but it's still undeniably delicious. Interestingly, we recently introduced it to some friends, and one of them became absolutely obsessed, claiming it's the best they've ever had. They even joked about returning solely for that garlic bread, and have talked about it several times since they had it.Nico's continues to impress with its delightful staff, delectable food, and welcoming ambiance. It's no wonder it's becoming increasingly popular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
This was truly the best pizza compared to any. Nice crispy crust, loads of toppings, the sauce is flavorful. The cheesy garlic bread out compared competitor, and of course the tiramasu was fantastic!We look forward to coming back for more and sharing with friends.Thank you for the wonderful experience and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Unique pizza, no flop. Seeds ground in the sausage. Fresh ingredients starting at the appetizers.
Restaurantji Recommends
Visited Nico's for the first time today. A friend raved about their Oconomowoc location, so I was looking forward to trying them. I bought one of their frozen pizzas at Metcalfe's Market for $16 and was disappointed. Today's experience at their new West Allis location, in the former Crawdaddy's and Shakey's space, was a great experience! I ordered the 12" Classic, which is topped with BIG chunks of Italian Sausage, red onions, and fresh mushrooms, and I added pepperoni. The first thing I noticed was how thick the pizza was with cheese and toppings. Then I picked up a slice and was surprised by how well the crispy, Tavern Cut, slice held the heavy toppings. This was true of the center slices, as well. Super thin crust that doesn't flop or get soft in the center! That speaks to the quality of the ingredients, how well the pizza dough is made, and the temperature of the oven. The pizza tasted great, and I will be back. It may already be in my top 5 favorite thin crust pizzas in Milwaukee.
We had very good service and the pizza was incredible! Will be back to try out other things
Mushroom Sausage and Motz drop pizza was well presented like artwork! Only complaint was that sauce is a pretty spicy! Service and atmosphere was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
The pizza and appetizers at this place were really good and I'm a fan of the limited menu. The staff need to be better acquainted with restaurant service, we had a lot of awkward/ funny moments with them while dining in.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Truffle Fries, Sausage Pizza
I took my daughter on a Saturday and it was pretty busy. The amazing hostess found us a table for two so we didn’t have to wait long. Our server was Ty and she was so sweet! Everyone there was so nice and the food was great too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5