Polito's Pizza

1951 8th St S, Wisconsin Rapids
(715) 423-4343

Recent Reviews

Tami Norris

Amazing pizza you won't be

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loretta Prescott

Great!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza

Brooke Ott

Needs to be remodeled

Atmosphere: 1

Debra Shaw

I called in and ordered a large vegetarian pizza, I wanted chicken added, I asked for feta cheese, spinach, and extra tomatoes. I asked for it to be cut in squares too. Person that took my order was RUDE, he was short with me and seemed like it was a huge inconvenience to even take my order. I called about 8:40 pm asked what time they closed and I still had plenty of time to pick it up before they closed. Person on phone said when they closed depended upon “how busy they were”.I picked pizza up about 9:15 pm. They had a lot of pizza left on counter and I asked him what they did with excess pizza? He said we throw it away! I said for real? He said yes. I asked if I could take it and give it to some folks I knew that would really appreciate it. Other guy in store said he would ask manager, which he did , manager’s answer was no. Manager was outside smoking and couldn’t be bothered to come in and talk to me. I said again I’d really like to talk to your manager. He went back out manager still couldn’t be bothered to talk to me but instead said they could give me 2 “free” pieces of leftover pizza. Again! Not the point! I wasn’t looking for a handout for myself.I paid for my large pizza and it was $27 something, I was surprised and I said does that include extras I asked for? He assured me it did. In the past it has cost around $35 for this pizza with extras I ordered. I paid for pizza, left.Came home opened pizza box. They did not give me what I ordered. There was no feta cheese, no spinach, no chicken, and no extra tomatoes. They didn’t cut it in squares like I asked.It was too late to take it back but they’re going to hear from me tomorrow and they can remake it the way I asked to begin with. This is the first time I’ve had issues for real I’ve had some frustration in the past but not a complete flub up like this. If they do the right thing by me I will update my post and maybe change rating.Vegetarian options: Their vegetarian pizza is good but adding feta, spinach and more tomatoes and I add chicken is a fantastic combination.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: 20 Spinach Feta, 20 Tomato Basil, 20 Greek

Ashley Kelnhofer

My daughter cannot have gluten and Pulido's offers a gluten-free option! She was so excited! Now we can all enjoy Pizza!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christian Brown

Called at 9:12 and asked if I can order a takeout and they send they was closed like it’s says 10:00 and the guy sounds hesitated

Patrick Fuller

I came in 12-12-23 for lunch. I got take out. I got back to work had my lunch. Not 20-30 minutes later I felt really sick. I had to leave work with how sick I got. I will NOT be returning. Lady was rude n stuck up also.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

regina harrod

It was kinda late and that made a fresh pizza for us steak and fries so so good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots 8, Meat Pizza

Andrew Lancaster

Pizza was wrong and garlic knots were burnt black. Got attitude from the person in charge. This place is a

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ellie Dale

The good: pizza is good and prices are decent.The bad: the last two times I ordered online, they didn't make my order. I showed up to get it and they had no record of my order. (Good thing I had my phone/confirmation email to prove I'd already paid.) I had to wait an additional 15+ minutes both times. Not cool. The first time, I figured it was a fluke since I'd been ordering online for 2+ years without problems. But now, it's been two "we didn't get your order" situations in less than a month. Not cool.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Trinidad Ysquierdo

Always good. I like the way they reheat the pizza, makes it taste like its fresh out of the oven

Ellie D.

The good: pizza is good and prices are decent. The bad: the last two times I ordered online, they didn't make my order. I showed up to get it and they had no record of my order. (Good thing I had my phone/confirmation email to prove I'd already paid.) I had to wait an additional 15+ minutes both times. Not cool. The first time, I figured it was a fluke since I'd been ordering online for 2+ years without problems. But now, it's been two "we didn't get your order" situations in less than a month. Not cool.

Stephanie Bradley

Would've gotten 5 stars if they still had their hot wings...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Nick Boyle

Absolute joke of a pizza place. Ask for my pizza to be cooked longer because I’ve received raw dough before and was told their cooks can’t do that. Turns out they don’t actually cook pizza. They should close or find new owners and new

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bryan Chilewski

Seems to be going down hill. Not as clean not as many choices on the menu. Kind of sad really. Bright spot the pizza is still great.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 2

Load More