“Oh my gosh, Terri is a cake magician! I still can’t believe how amazingly delicious all of her sweets are. She made the cake, cupcakes, and cookies for our wedding. She was one of the first vendors I knew I had to have, as I got to have one of her cupcakes at another wedding several years ago. As soon as I tasted that cupcake, I was determined to have that same cake at my own wedding (I wasn’t even engaged at the time). The cake, cupcakes, and cookies were just as delicious as that first cupcake, if not even better. Everything she makes is the best thing you’ll ever taste. She is also just the sweetest person to work with. She wants to make all of your cake dreams come true and will work with you to figure out how to get as close to that as possible. The way she set up our dessert and cake tables was so adorable, too. She’s just amazing at what she does! I only wish I lived closer and could get treats from her more often!“
“It smells so good when you walk in the door, and it tastes even better. Good service too, even though as newbies we were a little indecisive. We got "hot dogs" and see why they are so popular. Look forward to many more visits to try all of it!“
“I ordered a cake for my daughters birthday. It was beautiful and delicious but I was disappointed that they didn't get happy birthday on the cake with my daughters name. I specifically asked for that at least twice in email. The whole email ordering process did not feel smooth and I don't think I was asking for much. Responses took days over the course of a few emails. I got the vibe that they didn’t care about me as a customer.“
“We had the best experience with Montanaro Cakery for a family baby shower this weekend. They took my inspiration pics and made them come to life!! the macarons were stunning and delicious. Their customer service was 10/10 and we will definitely be using them again! ❤️“