Recommended dishes: Brisket, Jalapeño Cheddar Brat, Peppered Turkey, Corn Bread and Coleslaw, Cornbread, Sandwiches, Pioneer, Chili Dog
Michael Probst
Love love love me some HBBQ!!! Whenever we come into town to play a gig we always hit up this place and it never disappoints! It's been great to get to know the owners and the staff. Rock on! We'll see you next show!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Pulled Pork, Apple Butter, Half Chicken, Cornbread
Courtney Werth
Quick and Dirty: if you like BBQ, this is an excellent option. Its not like “Famous Daves” bbq, this is like REAL BBQ. Like the??real??thing??.Situation: We were out of state visitors staying at Oglebay but looking for another “party of 10 including kids” food option that wasn’t overpriced Resort food. Luckily, we googled the area and this popped up, like 7 min down the road. Perfect.We got there around 4:30, they close at 6 on Thursday and they are the type of establishment that makes food in the morning and goes till they run out. So we didnt have full options available but were able to grab brisket, pulled pork, a bit of ribs, macaroni and cheese, and all the sauces.Plus ice creams. Like $50 worth of ice cream. No regrets. And some fresh Kombucha.Meat: was outstanding. Kids liked it, adults liked it. Meat was soft and delicious, fell off the ribs, seasoned but not overly, just the right amount. Id order any of them again, probably ranked Ribs>Brisket>Pulled Pork but thats just my natural preferences towards bbq.Sauces: Normally theres always a clear winner for me, but honestly i was a fan of all 4 options.Pioneer- was an excellent tangy bbq. Not too sour, not bitter at all, but i felt more on the Carolina style side than the sugar honey bbq sides. Which, i love tangy bbq and its one of the best Ive had on the road. Loved it.Appalachian - Ive never seen that before and i thought it was really good, if you like horseradish. It wasnt a thick sauce despite the mayo base description.Apple Butter- This one surprised me. I normally am not a fan of sweet bbq. Its ok, if i have no other option, but too often places make it thick and too sweet so its just lathering my meat in sugar. However this was DELIGHTFUL. It wasnt sickly sweet, it had a really nice apple note at the end and overall probably one of the nicest “sweet” bbq sauces ive had.Mustard - it was good, very mustard-y but thats the point. What i liked is it advertises spicy but its spicy in seasoning, not atomic buffalo nuclear orange mouth on fire spicy.So. Yeah. We loved it. Went over well for the whole group. Would probably do 2lbs next time instead of the 1lbs for our group size so we had more leftovers.Also, had the on tap Pina Colada Kombucha, it was delightful and effervescent. And the ice cream sandwiches were extra boujee, like “ginger cookie with lemon ice cream”. Check them out.Oh and 5 star staff, they were all really nice.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Pulled Pork, Leona's Ice Cream Sandwiches, Apple Butter, Pioneer, Ribs by the Rack
Jackie S.
Good place I like it there very comfortable and they are really friendly Fried RibJalapeno Cheddar Brats were both really good
wrangler99se
This is not for eating in but take out only. This food was amazing. We tried brisket, pulled pork, and turkey. The turkey blew us away with its flavor and juiciness. The pulled pork was done perfectly and the brisket just melted in your mouth. Do pair it with their amazing bbq sauces on the side for dipping! The sauces do not overpower the meat flavor but work perfectly with it to bring out both flavors at once. We will likely be back every time we visit Oglebay now that we know about it and being so close.
Eddie Cahoon
Great food, a little pricey for the portion sizes, but great quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Annie Truax
Listen, there are no words for how truly amazing the food and the people are here. So, just do yourself a favor and go try it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Macaroni Salad, Corn Bread and Coleslaw, Leona
Jay
The meet is definitely the star as it should be! I travel all over Ohio for work & this is the best bbq I have eaten in Ohio!
We came 15 minutes before they closed, they were super nice about it and happy to help. We got a few venison sausages and ribs. The food was fantastic and really hit the spot after a long day. Everyone was super friendly. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike M
One of the best ribs I've ever had if not thee best. Great flavor, pulled right off the bone. A Delicacy. Staff/owners were on point, very friendly. Compliments to the
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ribs by the Rack
Carl Carder
I stop here every time that I am back home in Wheeling. The food is really outstanding! Keep up the great work Billy and Stephanie!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork
Matt Poljak
This is a must stop when in the Wheeling area. I will remember the smoked wings (weekends only) for a long time. The mac and cheese was fantastic as well. Be sure to try the Appalachian (horseradish mayo base) sauce, it was delicious. I do wish the Atomic 79 (spicy mustard) had a bit more spice, but that is personal preference. They will close early when they run out so do not wait until dinner time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg N.
Top notch BBQ! Grabbed some lunch today and it was difficult deciding what to get. They have several specials available but ended up getting items off the regular menu. If I go back I'm gonna give one of the specials a shot. Reasonable prices, nice people, and quality food.
The best BBQ in the valley.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ribs by the Rack, Cornbread
Killer BBQ.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Jalapeño Cheddar Brat, Peppered Turkey, Corn Bread and Coleslaw, Cornbread, Sandwiches, Pioneer, Chili Dog
Love love love me some HBBQ!!! Whenever we come into town to play a gig we always hit up this place and it never disappoints! It's been great to get to know the owners and the staff. Rock on! We'll see you next show!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Pulled Pork, Apple Butter, Half Chicken, Cornbread
Quick and Dirty: if you like BBQ, this is an excellent option. Its not like “Famous Daves” bbq, this is like REAL BBQ. Like the??real??thing??.Situation: We were out of state visitors staying at Oglebay but looking for another “party of 10 including kids” food option that wasn’t overpriced Resort food. Luckily, we googled the area and this popped up, like 7 min down the road. Perfect.We got there around 4:30, they close at 6 on Thursday and they are the type of establishment that makes food in the morning and goes till they run out. So we didnt have full options available but were able to grab brisket, pulled pork, a bit of ribs, macaroni and cheese, and all the sauces.Plus ice creams. Like $50 worth of ice cream. No regrets. And some fresh Kombucha.Meat: was outstanding. Kids liked it, adults liked it. Meat was soft and delicious, fell off the ribs, seasoned but not overly, just the right amount. Id order any of them again, probably ranked Ribs>Brisket>Pulled Pork but thats just my natural preferences towards bbq.Sauces: Normally theres always a clear winner for me, but honestly i was a fan of all 4 options.Pioneer- was an excellent tangy bbq. Not too sour, not bitter at all, but i felt more on the Carolina style side than the sugar honey bbq sides. Which, i love tangy bbq and its one of the best Ive had on the road. Loved it.Appalachian - Ive never seen that before and i thought it was really good, if you like horseradish. It wasnt a thick sauce despite the mayo base description.Apple Butter- This one surprised me. I normally am not a fan of sweet bbq. Its ok, if i have no other option, but too often places make it thick and too sweet so its just lathering my meat in sugar. However this was DELIGHTFUL. It wasnt sickly sweet, it had a really nice apple note at the end and overall probably one of the nicest “sweet” bbq sauces ive had.Mustard - it was good, very mustard-y but thats the point. What i liked is it advertises spicy but its spicy in seasoning, not atomic buffalo nuclear orange mouth on fire spicy.So. Yeah. We loved it. Went over well for the whole group. Would probably do 2lbs next time instead of the 1lbs for our group size so we had more leftovers.Also, had the on tap Pina Colada Kombucha, it was delightful and effervescent. And the ice cream sandwiches were extra boujee, like “ginger cookie with lemon ice cream”. Check them out.Oh and 5 star staff, they were all really nice.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Pulled Pork, Leona's Ice Cream Sandwiches, Apple Butter, Pioneer, Ribs by the Rack
Good place I like it there very comfortable and they are really friendly Fried RibJalapeno Cheddar Brats were both really good
This is not for eating in but take out only. This food was amazing. We tried brisket, pulled pork, and turkey. The turkey blew us away with its flavor and juiciness. The pulled pork was done perfectly and the brisket just melted in your mouth. Do pair it with their amazing bbq sauces on the side for dipping! The sauces do not overpower the meat flavor but work perfectly with it to bring out both flavors at once. We will likely be back every time we visit Oglebay now that we know about it and being so close.
Great food, a little pricey for the portion sizes, but great quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Listen, there are no words for how truly amazing the food and the people are here. So, just do yourself a favor and go try it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Macaroni Salad, Corn Bread and Coleslaw, Leona
The meet is definitely the star as it should be! I travel all over Ohio for work & this is the best bbq I have eaten in Ohio!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket, Pulled Pork, Peppered Turkey, Leona
Great food love the place. Stop every time we go though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brisket
Restaurantji Recommends
We came 15 minutes before they closed, they were super nice about it and happy to help. We got a few venison sausages and ribs. The food was fantastic and really hit the spot after a long day. Everyone was super friendly. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best ribs I've ever had if not thee best. Great flavor, pulled right off the bone. A Delicacy. Staff/owners were on point, very friendly. Compliments to the
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ribs by the Rack
I stop here every time that I am back home in Wheeling. The food is really outstanding! Keep up the great work Billy and Stephanie!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork
This is a must stop when in the Wheeling area. I will remember the smoked wings (weekends only) for a long time. The mac and cheese was fantastic as well. Be sure to try the Appalachian (horseradish mayo base) sauce, it was delicious. I do wish the Atomic 79 (spicy mustard) had a bit more spice, but that is personal preference. They will close early when they run out so do not wait until dinner time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Top notch BBQ! Grabbed some lunch today and it was difficult deciding what to get. They have several specials available but ended up getting items off the regular menu. If I go back I'm gonna give one of the specials a shot. Reasonable prices, nice people, and quality food.