I can not express how good this pizza is. I'm from NY and it is spot on! I'm going to be making the hour drive from Douglas 1 of not 2 times a month just to get a pizza here. It's not made on bread it's made on actual pizza dough. Thin and crispy but with a little soft give also. Crispy crust. I can't find a flaw at all. Only thing that is missing is the water from NY. It has certain minerals in it that change the flavor of the dough, but I can't fault this place for that. We're like 2k miles away from NY. Lol. Again, amazing pizza and amazing customer service. They needed up my pizza the first time (forgot a topping) and gave me a whole other one free. I tried paying then something for it. They wouldn't take it. Talk about above and beyond! 100% has my business. Thank you very much 5150. See ya soon
J Hall
The most incredible service! The staff couldn’t be nicer and more friendly. This is saying a lot in a world of declining customer service. The pizza slice was delicious, authentic New York, and very filling. Good bang for your buck!
Kimi Elliott
We had the best experience here!!! We are new to this restaurant and it was fantastic food, service, & atmosphere! We had Italian nachos, fries, and the Detroit pizza! We had the yummy dirty sodas!! Those are seriously the best! We had an awesome conversation with the young man working there named Elijah! He was very professional and welcoming!! Please give him some positive accolades or even a raise! Also combining the Italian nachos with the fries to make Italian nacho fries without chips would be a huge seller!!!! Maybe even adding a gluten free crust or option! I highly recommend this local eatery!!!!!
Mandi Willett
We ordered 4 big pizzas for a family gathering, the staff was friendly and the pizzas were hot and ready as soon as we got there. Most importantly, they were delicious! Thanks so much
Tara Lee Fulkerson
Staff was very friendly and helpful! Food was yummy. Very clean & nice atmosphere!!! Great prices!!! We loved it, got stuffed!
Jan Gaskill
My son who coaches for NC (Go Mustangs!) highly recommended 5150 Slice Pizza so I could take my grandkids there for dinner. We were greeted with a welcome, smiles, and great service!Eric asked if the kids if the kids wanted take their own pizza, they were thrilled! He brought the dough & ingredients to the table & showed them how to make their pizza. They even got to watch the pizza bake (from a very safe distsnce!) The pizza was amazing!Thank you Eric for a wonderful memory for my grandkids & great pizza!! It will be my go to pizza place when I'm in Casper!
Amber H.
Ordered pizza about 50 minutes ago. Said it would be here in 50 minutes. They called 20 minutes ago to say it would be awhile as they ran out of cheese. My husband called back to cancel it and was told he cant. They would have to call a manager and call him back to give him a gift card of the order we canceled. Waited another 20 minutes for a call back asking to use a different cheese and it would be another 45 minute wait. We asked they refund our money and cancel the order as we have a 1 and half year old who wants to eat now not later besides we waited long enough. They said they cant do that but promised our pizza would be here in 20 minutes. We live 15 minutes away so doubtful it will be here in 20 minutes. I understand things happen but to not refund your customers money and cancel an order is wrong. I dont want a gift card. We will not be going back. Horrible business practice. Update: pizza came 15 minutes later then they said it would. Pizza was slightly burnt. They forgot our 3 ranches we ordered which was an additional $6. My husband called to tell a manager all the issues and was told, "Well were short staffed." Seems to be their answer for their crappy customer service. You can still do the right thing and be understaffed. Everyone is right now. So now we get charged for ranch they didnt even bring us and the manager couldnt figure out how to refund it so my husband asked how long it would take and he was told to call back later and next time order from dominos. So many issues from the beginning. No excuse for any of it. They could have just let us cancel our order and refund us from the start and I wouldnt be upset.
Jess Mc
Great pizza order online and pickup in drive thru! Fun drinks I'd like to try soon and the Italian Fries are soooo good!!
myra smith
Super yummy great staff clean tables!
Burgendy Jorgensen
shout out to the wonder staff and service! my family will be coming back!
Very busy tonight! Multiple customers between phone and lobby. Short staffed but the staff prevailed! They worked great together to jump in and help each other. Great food and very appreciative of the effort to address all concerns. We will come back
Morgan Moller
This has got to be the worst customer service I have ever experienced and that’s coming from someone who has worked in customer service in a restaurant. The workers were extremely rude and disrespectful and it took 30 minutes to get one slice of pizza and we had to ask for a refund for two orders of garlic knots because it was taking too long. We were very patient with them but the workers still said rude comments to us. I do NOT recommend this place to anyone, you would be better off just going to domino’s the pizza tastes the same.
J Bnett23
Amazing pizza and a nice, friendly environment
jennifer herzberg
Very good food. The floor needed to be swept though. Gelato is very delicious.
Tiffany Theien
I would have liked to try this pizza if we ever got served . We drove in from Glenrock to get a late lunch . Lobby was not busy , we placed our order at counter with guy for our family of 5 . After 30 min of waiting we asked for our drinks and a nice ,overwhelmed girl got them for us . It seemed like the girl was doing all the work . People came in after us and we’re getting served ? We sat there for almost an hour without food . I went up to the counter and found out the guy never actually put our order in . We got a refund and left . Super disappointed.
I can not express how good this pizza is. I'm from NY and it is spot on! I'm going to be making the hour drive from Douglas 1 of not 2 times a month just to get a pizza here. It's not made on bread it's made on actual pizza dough. Thin and crispy but with a little soft give also. Crispy crust. I can't find a flaw at all. Only thing that is missing is the water from NY. It has certain minerals in it that change the flavor of the dough, but I can't fault this place for that. We're like 2k miles away from NY. Lol. Again, amazing pizza and amazing customer service. They needed up my pizza the first time (forgot a topping) and gave me a whole other one free. I tried paying then something for it. They wouldn't take it. Talk about above and beyond! 100% has my business. Thank you very much 5150. See ya soon
The most incredible service! The staff couldn’t be nicer and more friendly. This is saying a lot in a world of declining customer service. The pizza slice was delicious, authentic New York, and very filling. Good bang for your buck!
We had the best experience here!!! We are new to this restaurant and it was fantastic food, service, & atmosphere! We had Italian nachos, fries, and the Detroit pizza! We had the yummy dirty sodas!! Those are seriously the best! We had an awesome conversation with the young man working there named Elijah! He was very professional and welcoming!! Please give him some positive accolades or even a raise! Also combining the Italian nachos with the fries to make Italian nacho fries without chips would be a huge seller!!!! Maybe even adding a gluten free crust or option! I highly recommend this local eatery!!!!!
We ordered 4 big pizzas for a family gathering, the staff was friendly and the pizzas were hot and ready as soon as we got there. Most importantly, they were delicious! Thanks so much
Staff was very friendly and helpful! Food was yummy. Very clean & nice atmosphere!!! Great prices!!! We loved it, got stuffed!
My son who coaches for NC (Go Mustangs!) highly recommended 5150 Slice Pizza so I could take my grandkids there for dinner. We were greeted with a welcome, smiles, and great service!Eric asked if the kids if the kids wanted take their own pizza, they were thrilled! He brought the dough & ingredients to the table & showed them how to make their pizza. They even got to watch the pizza bake (from a very safe distsnce!) The pizza was amazing!Thank you Eric for a wonderful memory for my grandkids & great pizza!! It will be my go to pizza place when I'm in Casper!
Ordered pizza about 50 minutes ago. Said it would be here in 50 minutes. They called 20 minutes ago to say it would be awhile as they ran out of cheese. My husband called back to cancel it and was told he cant. They would have to call a manager and call him back to give him a gift card of the order we canceled. Waited another 20 minutes for a call back asking to use a different cheese and it would be another 45 minute wait. We asked they refund our money and cancel the order as we have a 1 and half year old who wants to eat now not later besides we waited long enough. They said they cant do that but promised our pizza would be here in 20 minutes. We live 15 minutes away so doubtful it will be here in 20 minutes. I understand things happen but to not refund your customers money and cancel an order is wrong. I dont want a gift card. We will not be going back. Horrible business practice. Update: pizza came 15 minutes later then they said it would. Pizza was slightly burnt. They forgot our 3 ranches we ordered which was an additional $6. My husband called to tell a manager all the issues and was told, "Well were short staffed." Seems to be their answer for their crappy customer service. You can still do the right thing and be understaffed. Everyone is right now. So now we get charged for ranch they didnt even bring us and the manager couldnt figure out how to refund it so my husband asked how long it would take and he was told to call back later and next time order from dominos. So many issues from the beginning. No excuse for any of it. They could have just let us cancel our order and refund us from the start and I wouldnt be upset.
Great pizza order online and pickup in drive thru! Fun drinks I'd like to try soon and the Italian Fries are soooo good!!
Super yummy great staff clean tables!
shout out to the wonder staff and service! my family will be coming back!
Restaurantji Recommends
Very busy tonight! Multiple customers between phone and lobby. Short staffed but the staff prevailed! They worked great together to jump in and help each other. Great food and very appreciative of the effort to address all concerns. We will come back
This has got to be the worst customer service I have ever experienced and that’s coming from someone who has worked in customer service in a restaurant. The workers were extremely rude and disrespectful and it took 30 minutes to get one slice of pizza and we had to ask for a refund for two orders of garlic knots because it was taking too long. We were very patient with them but the workers still said rude comments to us. I do NOT recommend this place to anyone, you would be better off just going to domino’s the pizza tastes the same.
Amazing pizza and a nice, friendly environment
Very good food. The floor needed to be swept though. Gelato is very delicious.
I would have liked to try this pizza if we ever got served . We drove in from Glenrock to get a late lunch . Lobby was not busy , we placed our order at counter with guy for our family of 5 . After 30 min of waiting we asked for our drinks and a nice ,overwhelmed girl got them for us . It seemed like the girl was doing all the work . People came in after us and we’re getting served ? We sat there for almost an hour without food . I went up to the counter and found out the guy never actually put our order in . We got a refund and left . Super disappointed.