Never disappointed. Hathaway's buffets and holiday events are superb. Great food, with amazing selection. The ambiance is elegant but not stuffy, making it work well for couples or families and casual to dressy. Excellent and friendly wait staff. I highly recommend Hathaway's.
MandyNtennessee
We arrived and were seated quickly, appeared to be 3-4 staff working. We were brought menus and water, then someone came to take order. We were never offered drink menus or asked if we wanted something other than water. We aren't local, so we thought maybe they didn't serve alcohol and we don't do soft drinks. My husband ordered the lamb, medium. I ordered trout, but we were told they didn't have trout or salmon (salmon and trout were both listed on my menu, but my husband's menu didn't even list one of those). I ordered the pesto pasta instead. We were each brought a roll and at that time my husband's water glass was already empty and it wasn't filled until after they came to clear our roll plates. The food came and my pasta was fine, not something too hard to mess up. My husband's lamb was WELL done, very well. No pink in sight. Halfway through our meal a couple other tables were seated and they ended up with beer and other drinks at their table. We weren't going to ask at that point, we nearly finished. We had looked forward to going here but thoroughly disappointed with half the food and service.
There was one poor person working the dining room the night we went. She was seating and waiting tables. , so the service was slower. The menus in our party were different. Two showed Trout and Salmon. Mine showed no Trout, but did have Salmon. Needless to say, they had neither available. Why even have them on the menu? The last time I dined here two years ago there were no seafood options, despite having them on the menu! Overall, a pleasant experience and the ribeye steak was very good!
Ninon2
Last year was a lot better, that was why we went back. The food choice was more limited, price went up (of course like everything else but it went up considerably). The quality of food went down, the servers were friendly but very unsure in their way of serving. The children were running around and it was very noisy, all in all, I was very disappointed and expected more for what I was paying, way overpriced. Not going back next year.
Expected the Christmas buffet to have more of a variety better quality and replaced food dishes instead of 3/4 empty or totally out. So disappointing with the cost of $89 . Will not attend another Christmas buffet. On a highlight , ambience was nice and waitress attended often. I'd highly recommend reviewing your cost for what you served today. I'd also recommend better quality meats and cooked veggies and more to offer.
DariusB
The quality of the food for the Christmas buffet was excellent. It was visually pleasing, fresh food and delicious. The ambiance was pleasant and we sat in the bar area which had a fireplace that was lit and Delightful. The buffet was set up nicely so you could get to everything easily. We had a wonderful server. We would recommend this to anyone. It made our Christmas dinner relaxing and just right.
ChristineM
THIS WAS THE WORST WASTE OF MONEY WE'VE EVER SPENT IN MY 55 YEARS OF LIFE! FOR CHRIATMAS EVE AND 668.00 WE ATE DRIED MAC AND CHEESE, CHICKEN FINGERS, CHEESE AND CRACKERS, SLIDERS, 1 FORM OF POTATOES, THE ONLY DECENT THING THEY HAD FOR THAT KIND OF MONEY WAS THE PRIME RIB. WHAT WHERE WE SUPPOSED TO DO JUST EAT THAT? THE SERVICE WAS HORRIBLE TOO, ALWAYS WANDERING WHEN WE WOULD GET DRINK REFILLS AND WERE NEVER TOLD THE MIMOSAS HAD TO HAVE THE OJ ADDED, AT THE DAMN BAR! THIS PLACE WAS SO HORRIBLE ALL I WISHED IS THAT OUR NICELY DRESSED FAMILY WOULD HAVE DRIVEN TO COLORADO TO GOLDEN CORAL!! WE WOULD E ATE BETTER AND SAVED HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS!! I CRIED MY EYES OUT, BECAUSE WE LOST OUR FAMILY MEMBER RECENTLY AND DIDNT HAVE TIME TO PLAN FOR A CHRISTMAS EVE DINNER! WHAT A JOKE THIS PLACE WAS!!
JaneM
For the price the food could have so much better. They did have a variety but maybe focusing on less variety and more on quality would make the price more acceptable. Also they had us sitting right by the door and we were continually in the way of people being sitted, wait staff and even the bus people. I could hardly wait to get the hell out of there to be honest!!
PattyM
It was just my son and I for Thanksgiving, and for our first time not having thanksgiving dinner at home we were pleasantly surprise. It was a great meal and a great time for the two of us who drove down from Livermore Colorado.
BuzzS
Great place for holiday buffets. We had 2 small children and they were each given a Little America stuffed animal upon entering Hathaway's. They also loved the free pictures and chat with Santa and the letters to Santa. Food, Service, and ambiance are always excellent. Love going to Hathaway's!
The food was overcooked, they ran out of baked potatoes and I opted for the sweet potato that seemed mushy, over cooked and served in its tin foil on the platter. On the upswing our server was warm, kind and helpful regarding the service and the menu.
TwinChimney2011
Read reviews all over the place…decided we’d take a chance. Order was taken quickly. Then it went downhill. Ordered grilled chicken, was ok if you like rubber chicken. Also had a inedible side of green beans. They were undercooked and heavily seasoned with garlic?? Husband food was slightly better. You can’t blame the servers, since there were only two for the entire restaurant. Also a NO when there are multiple flys landing on my food. Overall a very unpleasant experience.
susanbV4890DH
Good diner food in an honest environment. My husband had the fish sandwich and onion rings. Both were lightly breaded and were very good. I had a delicious taco salad. Connie, our waitress was as attentive as was possible in the dinner rush. The service was prompt and the only negative thing was the fact we had to wait a few minutes to check out.
BethB
We went there to celebrate two birthdays and it was written in the reservation. There was no mention of the birthdays or any celebration. Food was good but there was a loud party of 40 that ruined the noise level for everyone. The room is about 1/3 of the size that it was when I went there last.
322mimih
Convenient to our hotel, nice variety on the menu, food basic, but tasty. My husband had the fried fish, which was good, and the sides were garden salad (which was good) and baked potato. The potato wasn’t really hot enough or it had just been sitting out too long. I had the grilled chicken breast which was surprisingly really delicious. My sides were hash browns (delicious), and the green beans (they were okay.) We had to wait a long time for our menus, water, and silverware. Don’t know if it was just an inexperienced waitress or what but all took way longer than usual. Ex., when our food arrived, we still had no silverware, asked for some and the missing side, the waitress went and fixed the salad, brought it to the table, but brought no silverware. Here I was with my meal and no way to eat it. So, if I ever went there again, and had the same issues, I’d just get up and go get the stuff I need myself.
Never disappointed. Hathaway's buffets and holiday events are superb. Great food, with amazing selection. The ambiance is elegant but not stuffy, making it work well for couples or families and casual to dressy. Excellent and friendly wait staff. I highly recommend Hathaway's.
We arrived and were seated quickly, appeared to be 3-4 staff working. We were brought menus and water, then someone came to take order. We were never offered drink menus or asked if we wanted something other than water. We aren't local, so we thought maybe they didn't serve alcohol and we don't do soft drinks. My husband ordered the lamb, medium. I ordered trout, but we were told they didn't have trout or salmon (salmon and trout were both listed on my menu, but my husband's menu didn't even list one of those). I ordered the pesto pasta instead. We were each brought a roll and at that time my husband's water glass was already empty and it wasn't filled until after they came to clear our roll plates. The food came and my pasta was fine, not something too hard to mess up. My husband's lamb was WELL done, very well. No pink in sight. Halfway through our meal a couple other tables were seated and they ended up with beer and other drinks at their table. We weren't going to ask at that point, we nearly finished. We had looked forward to going here but thoroughly disappointed with half the food and service.
There was one poor person working the dining room the night we went. She was seating and waiting tables. , so the service was slower. The menus in our party were different. Two showed Trout and Salmon. Mine showed no Trout, but did have Salmon. Needless to say, they had neither available. Why even have them on the menu? The last time I dined here two years ago there were no seafood options, despite having them on the menu! Overall, a pleasant experience and the ribeye steak was very good!
Last year was a lot better, that was why we went back. The food choice was more limited, price went up (of course like everything else but it went up considerably). The quality of food went down, the servers were friendly but very unsure in their way of serving. The children were running around and it was very noisy, all in all, I was very disappointed and expected more for what I was paying, way overpriced. Not going back next year.
Expected the Christmas buffet to have more of a variety better quality and replaced food dishes instead of 3/4 empty or totally out. So disappointing with the cost of $89 . Will not attend another Christmas buffet. On a highlight , ambience was nice and waitress attended often. I'd highly recommend reviewing your cost for what you served today. I'd also recommend better quality meats and cooked veggies and more to offer.
The quality of the food for the Christmas buffet was excellent. It was visually pleasing, fresh food and delicious. The ambiance was pleasant and we sat in the bar area which had a fireplace that was lit and Delightful. The buffet was set up nicely so you could get to everything easily. We had a wonderful server. We would recommend this to anyone. It made our Christmas dinner relaxing and just right.
THIS WAS THE WORST WASTE OF MONEY WE'VE EVER SPENT IN MY 55 YEARS OF LIFE! FOR CHRIATMAS EVE AND 668.00 WE ATE DRIED MAC AND CHEESE, CHICKEN FINGERS, CHEESE AND CRACKERS, SLIDERS, 1 FORM OF POTATOES, THE ONLY DECENT THING THEY HAD FOR THAT KIND OF MONEY WAS THE PRIME RIB. WHAT WHERE WE SUPPOSED TO DO JUST EAT THAT? THE SERVICE WAS HORRIBLE TOO, ALWAYS WANDERING WHEN WE WOULD GET DRINK REFILLS AND WERE NEVER TOLD THE MIMOSAS HAD TO HAVE THE OJ ADDED, AT THE DAMN BAR! THIS PLACE WAS SO HORRIBLE ALL I WISHED IS THAT OUR NICELY DRESSED FAMILY WOULD HAVE DRIVEN TO COLORADO TO GOLDEN CORAL!! WE WOULD E ATE BETTER AND SAVED HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS!! I CRIED MY EYES OUT, BECAUSE WE LOST OUR FAMILY MEMBER RECENTLY AND DIDNT HAVE TIME TO PLAN FOR A CHRISTMAS EVE DINNER! WHAT A JOKE THIS PLACE WAS!!
For the price the food could have so much better. They did have a variety but maybe focusing on less variety and more on quality would make the price more acceptable. Also they had us sitting right by the door and we were continually in the way of people being sitted, wait staff and even the bus people. I could hardly wait to get the hell out of there to be honest!!
It was just my son and I for Thanksgiving, and for our first time not having thanksgiving dinner at home we were pleasantly surprise. It was a great meal and a great time for the two of us who drove down from Livermore Colorado.
Great place for holiday buffets. We had 2 small children and they were each given a Little America stuffed animal upon entering Hathaway's. They also loved the free pictures and chat with Santa and the letters to Santa. Food, Service, and ambiance are always excellent. Love going to Hathaway's!
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was overcooked, they ran out of baked potatoes and I opted for the sweet potato that seemed mushy, over cooked and served in its tin foil on the platter. On the upswing our server was warm, kind and helpful regarding the service and the menu.
Read reviews all over the place…decided we’d take a chance. Order was taken quickly. Then it went downhill. Ordered grilled chicken, was ok if you like rubber chicken. Also had a inedible side of green beans. They were undercooked and heavily seasoned with garlic?? Husband food was slightly better. You can’t blame the servers, since there were only two for the entire restaurant. Also a NO when there are multiple flys landing on my food. Overall a very unpleasant experience.
Good diner food in an honest environment. My husband had the fish sandwich and onion rings. Both were lightly breaded and were very good. I had a delicious taco salad. Connie, our waitress was as attentive as was possible in the dinner rush. The service was prompt and the only negative thing was the fact we had to wait a few minutes to check out.
We went there to celebrate two birthdays and it was written in the reservation. There was no mention of the birthdays or any celebration. Food was good but there was a loud party of 40 that ruined the noise level for everyone. The room is about 1/3 of the size that it was when I went there last.
Convenient to our hotel, nice variety on the menu, food basic, but tasty. My husband had the fried fish, which was good, and the sides were garden salad (which was good) and baked potato. The potato wasn’t really hot enough or it had just been sitting out too long. I had the grilled chicken breast which was surprisingly really delicious. My sides were hash browns (delicious), and the green beans (they were okay.) We had to wait a long time for our menus, water, and silverware. Don’t know if it was just an inexperienced waitress or what but all took way longer than usual. Ex., when our food arrived, we still had no silverware, asked for some and the missing side, the waitress went and fixed the salad, brought it to the table, but brought no silverware. Here I was with my meal and no way to eat it. So, if I ever went there again, and had the same issues, I’d just get up and go get the stuff I need myself.