Restaurants in Brewster

“Being a Bronx Italian girl, let me tell you this place is the place to be. I’ve been here 3 times and they do not disappoint. I met the owner the first time I came in, he was a chef in Westchester and it shows. Chicken parmigiana was thin, crispy and amazing. Penne aldente. Grilled chicken arugula salad fantastic. Garlic knots so good. And the zeppoles, let me tell you, the most amazing zeppoles ever. I have an allergy to shellfish and the owner (who is the chef) made sure he cooked my cutlet seperate. I appreciate that more than anything else! I don’t live in Carmel anymore, I live in Dutchess county but work down here and will keep returning. I hope they do well!”

“We love Rraci's. Our “go to place” for speacual events. Service and food are always consistent. We have noticed that the menu choices have become fewer(smaller menu) and potions have also gotten smaller. We were satisfied but worth the mention since so little has changed in the past 20 years.”

“I ordered the wrong thing and though I didn’t expect them to refund me, they gave me a massive discount on the food I intended to order. Very kind of them. I’ve gone here a lot and the food and service is always exceptional. Great for dine in and take out.”

“Classic diner with a real focus on quality. The chef mans the flat top during rush hour - he's unflappable, runs a clean grill and work station, and puts out good looking and tasting food. Staff is excellent - and this place is a gem. Get there soon...”

“They catered a family reunion for 50 people. Delicious food, generous quantity and fair price. Chef Rosa was easy to work with and we developed a crowd-pleasing menu together. She supplied all the serving dishes, kept the food hot, and cleaned up afterwards. I will definitely call her for my next catered event.”

“Food was awesome, service was great. Even on a chilly Wednesday afternoon with only a few tables in the restaurant, my wife and I still felt a unique atmosphere. Very enjoyable lunch!”

“Super deli. About an hour north of the city for anyone headed that way. It's a really great stop. They made us awesome sandwiches made to order. Super friendly. Super fast service as well. One of the best delis anywhere in the area for sure.”

“Aversanos holds a special place in my heart. The owners are great men who care about their food, but even more so, about their customers!The service is great, and don't even get me started about the food... the seafood ravioli is to die for!If you are looking for a fine place for a date, or nice, authentic Italian food, then look no further than Aversanos. They even have gluten free options. What are you waiting for? Get over there.”

“I loved it. Try the birria tacos. I also ordered the stuffed jalapenos. (I burned myself. They were piping hot) The shrimp cocktail was spectacular. The ranchero steak and enchilada were perfect. We had a great Mother's Day. The place was busy but the service was fast. We finished with something light for dessert...churros and flan.Kid-friendliness: Family place.Wheelchair accessibility: If there is wheelchair access”

“What a joy to find a great food spot along Main street in Brewster. More than just a small restaurant, it's sited between a namesake Mini-Mart to the east and the bakery/cafe on its west flank. This trip I was only in the restaurant but it was more than good enough to warrant repeat visits.... The menu is simple but wonderfully extensive. So many choices and based on our simple lunch, my oh my, we will be back for more. There are Mexican dasayuno platos (breakfast dishes), a slew of tasty looking appetizers, the usual tacos and tamales and tortas, plus full meals that I'll save for dinner when we're back. Today we had tacos. And OH BOY I didn't want to stop. Not only plentiful, but surprisingly tasty, backed up with two or three freshly made salsas, a bit of appropriate heat, but nothing too biting for the feint of heart. Our three-taco lunch had one each of Carne Asada, Al Pastor, and Chorizo. There were at least a half-dozen other options, presumably at least as good as ours. The tacos came with unusually flavorful rice and perfectly seasoned beans. Today was only lunch, no more. Definitely our bad. But we'll make up for that; this is going to be one of our essential foodie stops in the area.”

“The best pizza hands down.... If you are driving anywhere near Brewster you need to stop by and get a slice..... Any style any toppings... They are all great! A must have!”

“Great all around. The beef wellingtons were cooked about a measure too hot, i.e. one ordered rare, arrived medium, another ordered medium-rare arrived medium-well, albeit delicious. Souffle and Creme Brulee were excellent.”

“Talking about close to home food! This cozy, energetic Guatemala restaurant has two main doors. The main entrance and the bar, but both places are connected. Space for family or large gathering, accessible, light ramp going into the restroom, free street parking available, cash and credit cards accepted. Please be patient since service could be a bit slow, very popular restaurant. Delicious Mix Guatemala season food to dream of. Lots to choose from seafood meat chicken and combination flatters. Mix drinks and straight shots are available, and their homemade Horchata was sweet to the taste with the light cinnamon. This restaurant gets packed quickly at the weekends, so make your plans coordinately.Kid-friendliness: Booster seats available for children accommodations for strollers.Wheelchair accessibility: Is a light ramp going to the restaurant”

“These guys go above and beyond. I live in Phoenix az and they packaged my order so I could take it home on the plane and then when I ordered for my family for valentine's day they separated the portions to go to 2 different places for me. They are great and the chicken francese is just awesome. Thank you guys can't wait to get back there, you're my 1st stop for dinner. ❤️ ?”

“I can’t believe I’ve never eaten at their restaurant before tonight living my whole life in the area! After loving Limni for the time they were open, I heard that they were the same owners as Mezza Luna so we had to give it a try. The food was amazing! I got the veal saltimbocca which was delicious. The mesclun salad was great with a delicious homemade vinaigrette, and they had the same amazing affogatos that I fell in love with at Limni! Can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend their restaurant for a nice night out, and their takeout for a cozy night in.”

“We just happened to stumble upon this bakery on a walk on the Maybrook trail. Wow is all I can say. The service and food was amazing. We cannot wait to go back!! So many yummy things to try.”

“If you're going to get a flat tire, I strongly recommend that you get one on NY-22, right in front of this deli, as I did. The staff are lovely (a man and his mother) and speak Italian to one another. They make their own mozzarella, soup, and at least some pastries, if not all. Cannoli are filled to order and excellent. Another pastry (crostata?), cut into squares with a shortbread-like crust, cherry jam and chocolate was even more spectacular and something that I *must* come back for. The man told me it was homemade. The sfogliatelle pastry was a little tough and stale, but the thick, ricotta-rich filling was delicious. To be fair, these things have a very short shelf life. I gave it a few minutes in the toaster oven when I finally made it home and the texture was far improved. The son patiently answered my questions [e.g. how to properly pronounce "sfogliatelle," how much the fresh mozzarella costs (about $11 / lb)] and the mother kindly warmed up some pasta e fagioli for me. Sandwiches seem to be the focus here -- the menu is vast! -- but I sorely needed the warm-you-from-the-inside-out comfort of soup at that moment. The rich broth full of red beans, potatoes, and carrots absolutely hit the spot. It's too bad that it took a flat tire to get me in this place. We've been driving by for years and have clearly been missing out all this time!”

“This pastry shop is a local treasure! This is the go to place for most popular pastries, and they taste fantastic! Emma is the best and always recommends new things to try out. I will be a lifetime customer!”

“I recently left a negative review. I immediately received a phone call regarding my review which welcomed me to let them know if I was unhappy with my food as well as a credit. I thought that was excellent customer service, not too often found anymore. I went this evening and not only received my credit but an additional pizza as well. The pizzas were much better, so that and that the review was acknowledged go very far, a big thank you to Tony's Pizza!”

“Went to a comedy night and the setup did not really accommodate the crowd. Long lines to get food and drinks. Comedy was great. Have not tried the restaurant yet.”

“I have ordered food her for my job and 6ft wedges and wrap platters for parties and they are amazong. Always well prepared and on-time. Food is well prepared and taste amazing. Always a guaranteed perfect meal for any occasion!”

“Ordered through DoorDash. The food came quickly and hot as well as correct. We ordered the hibachi noodles, shrimp and vegetable tempura, beef negimaki and sweet potato rolls. The beef negimaki and sweet potato rolls were very good. The hibachi noodles were a bit gummy but ok tasting and the tempura lacked favor. All in all they were good portions and reasonably priced. Would definitely order from here again.”

“The people here are so friendly. Even offer to run the food out to the car if you can’t find a parking spot. The food is delish. By far my favorite Chinese food!”

“Food is delicious, service is a bit slow but it’s worth the wait I promise. Lots of yummy opinions and prices are good. They also have a buffet style service if you are in a hurry on you want something quick to go. Bread is yummy, they have conchas and a lot of sweet bread that you can get. Love that this is local and I can have a yummy cheap meal anytime.”

“Small spot. Nice buffet selection. Locals of all kinds so you know it's good.. Not a lot of tables to dine in. Best for takeout. Food constantly rotating from the kitchen in the back. As soon as you open the door, the aroma of food grabs you.”

“I live in the area 17 years & have never been to North Brewster Deli. Tried it recently. I had the best eggplant mozzarella panini sandwich. Loved it & will definately be going back to try other selections!! Love.”

“Best cheesesteak wrap and service was wonderful.”

“Good food. Great selection of beer. The Margaritas were strong. The staff was very nice and courteous. Very nice outside dining area.Parking: Very large parking lot”

“This place makes the best combination dinners for anyone that likes several dishes and can’t choose just one thing. They make the best margaritas around and the service is great.Parking: Ample parkingKid-friendliness: Excellent choices for kids meals”

“I came here with some friends and loved that they had dairy and gluten free options. I ended up going with the pineapple and berry flavor and it was good. The dairy free options and other allergen friendly options were labeled clearly so it was easy to tell which flavors were safe to eat. I also noticed that they had a large variety of toppings and sauces that were delicious. I ended up going mostly for the fruity options including the sour patch kids. It was delicious. I look forward to my next visit.”

“(Translated by Google) It is a very ironic fascinating place is the best I love it and I adore it(Original)Es un lugar muy irónico fascinante es lo mejor lo amo y lo adoro”

“(Translated by Google) I loved it very beautiful and excellent roaches there are in the cosima(Original)Me encantó muy bello y excelente asta cucarachas hay en la cosima”

“Ice cream was good I never eat ice cream ,machine wasn't printing for the credit-card not good the girls working were sweet but it was nice to have ice cream ty”

“Loved it! Stopped in while driving from Boston to Indiana. Picked it out of a hat. And we were glad we did. The service was great, everyone was friendly, and the Ruebens were the best I have ever had. The bread was fresh and perfectly grilled, the meat was tender, and the ratio of the rest of the ingredients were perfect.”

“Kelly’s Corner is a classic bar-inspired restaurant in the heart of Brewster. Family friendly, Kelly’s has a lot of classic meals—burgers, wings, beer, common appetizers and sandwich-like items. While not “amazing,” you can rely on Kelly’s to give you good service and serve you a decent cocktail.I’ve had a few items from their menu including their Pulled Pork Sandwich, A Classic Cheeseburger, French Onion Soup, and various cocktails. Their food is good, but not necessarily “great.” Items could use a tad more seasoning and the food is meant to be simple, nothing fancy.For being a simplistic, hometown “bar,” the prices at Kelly’s could be better. A dozen wings are $13.99 and I paid I recently paid over $20 for a burger and a cocktail, with no add-ons. While not “unreasonable,” I’d rather pay a few dollars extra for an upgraded meal.”

“A hidden gem. Unlike other Italian restaurants in Brewster, they know how to make a tomato sauce that actually tastes like tomatoes! And is light on the salt, unlike the salt bombs at the most popular Italian restaurant nearby. The food is positively delicious. And their family meals are both delicious and a bargain. We had a last minute family get together, and ordered 5 family meals. It was a huge amount of food, and they had the entire order ready in 30 minutes. On a Saturday night!!!! We were certain that we would have ample leftovers, at least 1/3. But it was all devoured! Because everyone loved the food. It was greatFinally, the owners and the young girls that take the orders are so nice. A true delight.This is truly a hidden gem. Yum!!!!”

“I like to shout out to the best people at this location Dunkin in Brewster ny !! Aleta.telma .justin. Nuza . You guys are the best I go there almost everyday the best customer service thank you guys for making my day ?”

“This Dominos never disappoints. They never miss with the pizzas or any of the other products you could order. Hate to say I haven't had a bad experience in Brewster with any restaurant thus far. But this Dominos comes in clutch and also makes sure everything tastes great!”

“My wife and I went during Hudson Valley Restaurant week and we took advantage of the specially priced menu. I had the calamari appetizer, braised short rib and bourbon pecan pie. My wife had the cucumber avocado salad, chicken vodka burrata parm and the vanilla bean honey pudding. Everything was delicious and the service was great. Can't wait to go back.”

“I’ve been coming here for quite literally over 20 years since I was a kid. The food is incredible, best chicken parm in town. Great pizza. Family owned and extremely friendly service. What more could you ask for?”

“I moved to New Fairfield 1 minute away from Zegarellis. The very first time I went there they had HUGE gourmet slices of pizza In the display case and amazing desserts as well. They have one of the most authentic NY style pizzas I’ve had. Big Mac pizza is incredible as well as lasagna, chicken Marsala, chicken bacon ranch, carbonara pizza, etc. the rest of the menu is spot on. We eat there 1-2 a week lol can’t seem to get enough!! A hidden gem of a restaurant on Fairfield Drive, you will not be disappointed if you go.”

“We had gone in last week to try your new skillets which, by the way are so delicious! Don’t take that chicken one off the menu! We had Gabby as a server. She was very kind, and she made our dinner very pleasant. We’ll definitely be back.”