6 Best Pizza Restaurants in Brewster

“Being a Bronx Italian girl, let me tell you this place is the place to be. I’ve been here 3 times and they do not disappoint. I met the owner the first time I came in, he was a chef in Westchester and it shows. Chicken parmigiana was thin, crispy and amazing. Penne aldente. Grilled chicken arugula salad fantastic. Garlic knots so good. And the zeppoles, let me tell you, the most amazing zeppoles ever. I have an allergy to shellfish and the owner (who is the chef) made sure he cooked my cutlet seperate. I appreciate that more than anything else! I don’t live in Carmel anymore, I live in Dutchess county but work down here and will keep returning. I hope they do well!“

“Aversanos holds a special place in my heart. The owners are great men who care about their food, but even more so, about their customers!The service is great, and don't even get me started about the food... the seafood ravioli is to die for!If you are looking for a fine place for a date, or nice, authentic Italian food, then look no further than Aversanos. They even have gluten free options. What are you waiting for? Get over there.“

“I would definitely come back here again. Have a wide variety of pizza, soups pastas, calzones, etc. It’s very popular with the locals. They also offer various desserts. I knocked down a star because the bathroom can use increased cleaning. I feel like those pizzas be a little less crunchy.“

“These guys go above and beyond. I live in Phoenix az and they packaged my order so I could take it home on the plane and then when I ordered for my family for valentine's day they separated the portions to go to 2 different places for me. They are great and the chicken francese is just awesome. Thank you guys can't wait to get back there, you're my 1st stop for dinner. ❤️ ?“

“I can’t believe I’ve never eaten at their restaurant before tonight living my whole life in the area! After loving Limni for the time they were open, I heard that they were the same owners as Mezza Luna so we had to give it a try. The food was amazing! I got the veal saltimbocca which was delicious. The mesclun salad was great with a delicious homemade vinaigrette, and they had the same amazing affogatos that I fell in love with at Limni! Can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend their restaurant for a nice night out, and their takeout for a cozy night in.“

“I recently left a negative review. I immediately received a phone call regarding my review which welcomed me to let them know if I was unhappy with my food as well as a credit. I thought that was excellent customer service, not too often found anymore. I went this evening and not only received my credit but an additional pizza as well. The pizzas were much better, so that and that the review was acknowledged go very far, a big thank you to Tony's Pizza!“