Ok let me begin by saying to those complaining about how long it takes to get their food, Do you like amazing great tasting pizza or do you want microwavable 3 minute frozen pizza from a box?In order to experience professional top quality food you might want to have patience if you expect really good pizza or any kind of food. New Jersey pizza cares about the way they prepare their food and how they serve their customers. They don't want to just slop it all together and just toss it in the oven without knowing what they are doing. Their pizza is good, very very good because that's how they do it, they give it more time to be carefully put together so you can have a wonderful meal.Please understand that they get extra busy with many orders also so it does take extra long at times but be assured once you do get your meal you won't be disappointed. Keep up the great work NJP???.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ebay
Pizza - 8.5 (Delicious)Was given a wait time of 70 mins and had to wait in the car additional 20 mins. I would not even care if they told me 90 mins from the start.Waiting in the car for 20 mins with 4 kids, wasn’t cool.-1 Star for misleading timeline.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Gregory N.
This place is hard to judge, so I'll try the compliment sandwich. Pro: their ranch dressing is very good. Odd compliment, but good ranch is worth the mention. Con's: They are slow, like really really slow. We've called a couple times in the afternoon for take out and been given a 2+ hour wait time. Tried dining in, still took forever. Not sure if they are so swamped by to go orders that they just can't be faster, or if there is a little too much mountain high vibe going on, but service is definitely lacking. Bottom bread of this sandwich: the pizza is good. There's a reason people wait for it, and that is probably what matters, but order in advance and don't order hungry or you will quickly find yourself hangry.
Brian Grosbayne
Omg! This place is 100% a gem! The quality of the food is amazing! The wings are incredible. The pizza is legit awesome! Best pizza in Flagstaff hands down and I’m super picky when it comes to wings and pizza. This place gets 5 stars for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Bread Sticks
Kelli Gaither-Banchoff
Ok so the reviews are correct about this being a slow food experience. But the staff is friendly and this is top notch food (quality ingredients, fermented crust! And a house made gf crust for our daughter!); so bring good company, order a glass of wine, and enjoy the wait.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Mady Lee
The best I’ve ever had.Thank you New Jersey Pizza Company!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexis Bundy
Amazing food. Visiting from Phoenix for the weekend and will be returning just for this pizza! Service was excellent and everyone was so
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyle
The meats they use on the pizza are tasty but the pie does them no justice. We ordered a 12" and a 16", both two toppings. The 16" was so greasy and limp that you could barely hold it, half of it went to waste. The 12" bottom crust wasn't as soaked, but still dripping everywhere. I'm not sure why it seemed so wet when there didn't appear to be that much cheese or sauce??We were quoted 35-40min for pickup and it ended up being an hour and 15 minutes. Prices are absurd for what you get. There's other pizza within a mile of this spot that's both better and cheaper.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Edward L.
We ordered a 12" and a 16" pizza last night and we were told they would be ready in 40 minutes. We arrived in 40 minutes and the owner or manager was training an employee at the register. After five minutes standing there not acknowledged, he said "we will be right with you". He preceded to make a salad and after another 5 minutes.. the cash register girl asked our name and said it will be ready shortly. We paid for our pizzas ($54 for a small and a large) plus tip was $60. I then noticed the pizza guy putting ingredients on a pizza that looked like ours. Yes, after 50+ minutes, he was now making our pizza and it would be another 10 minutes. We ran an errand and came back in 10 minutes and it was just coming out of the oven. It was our first time trying and were excited to try the pizza after the reviews (even if the wait was long). The cheese was yellow and greasy (like low quality cheese), but the sausage was excellent as were the caramelized onions. The roasted red peppers were almost non-existent on both pizzas and the ricotta was weak (but not surprising since that's common at pizza places). We don't mind paying premium prices for premium pizza as it is our favorite, but for $60 we expected way more ingredients. Don't overcharge and then skimp on the ingredients (especially after making us wait an hour). Primary a take out place as the sit down area is not very nice and not one person was in there. Better cheese and more ingredients would make this place a success... the crust was really good on the 12", but a bit too floppy on the 16". I hope they make some adjustments as this pizza could be awesome. Not so much now.
Abi R
We decided to try out a new pizza place and were shockingly disappointed. Delivery took 2 hours. Kitchens get busy, so a long wait can be excused as long as the end result is a delicious meal. This was far from it. We each tried a slice and the rest was tossed into the trash. The pizza was so greasy, that when held upright, it dripped onto the plate. Flavor-wise it was very bland and oddly tasted watered down. Maybe their other styles would have been a better choice. We also ordered wings. Thankfully, they were edible. Not great, but edible. They were very dry and tough.
I truly pray that I receive an equally unprofessional response as the last guy who left an HONEST review.Before reading further just know you are better off with the 3 small pizzas from a lunchable.If an owner takes the time out of their day to respond to a review because they got their wittle feelings hurts, it’s because that review had truth.By far the worst food I’ve experienced in my life, and I’ve eaten bugs! This place is expensive and not at all worth it. For 2 16” pizzas and 2 dozen wings the bill came out to $120. Then the delivery itself was a 2 hr wait. At first I didn’t mind the wait because reviews mentioned a long wait but delicious taste. Delivery guy also said that the place is slow but good. Is New Jersey Pizza Co. paying everyone to lie? Or are they holding their families hostage? Did I miss the secret code to receive actual good food?God awful greasy limp pizza. The wings? Tiny, dry and too much vinegar. After everyone had a serving, not that it could be finished, this was all thrown into the trashIf you want your tastebuds to be offended and appalled then this is the trash for you. I’m convinced it’s children held captive being forced to cook the pizza because the pizza tastes like its secret ingredient is hatred.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Craig Byers
This place came recommended, and it did not disappoint. Hard to find at night time but worth the hunt. Had a pepperoni black olive pizza and let me tell you it was heavy on the black olives and pepperoni lol... anyway, I think everybody should check this place out ...I think they'll enjoy it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
Arelio Lendo
The Pi is tasty and authentic without the Jersey Attitude LMAO...seriously tho great Pi and service. Walk in order was a bit long in service but we're were given choice of two free drinks items for the wait.Don't forget get to try the Gelato!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
Ed Decker
Very tasty pizza with a great crust?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
D Dar
Excellent pizza. It reminded me of the pizza I grew up eating in NY. We can't wait to go back!
Ok let me begin by saying to those complaining about how long it takes to get their food, Do you like amazing great tasting pizza or do you want microwavable 3 minute frozen pizza from a box?In order to experience professional top quality food you might want to have patience if you expect really good pizza or any kind of food. New Jersey pizza cares about the way they prepare their food and how they serve their customers. They don't want to just slop it all together and just toss it in the oven without knowing what they are doing. Their pizza is good, very very good because that's how they do it, they give it more time to be carefully put together so you can have a wonderful meal.Please understand that they get extra busy with many orders also so it does take extra long at times but be assured once you do get your meal you won't be disappointed. Keep up the great work NJP???.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza - 8.5 (Delicious)Was given a wait time of 70 mins and had to wait in the car additional 20 mins. I would not even care if they told me 90 mins from the start.Waiting in the car for 20 mins with 4 kids, wasn’t cool.-1 Star for misleading timeline.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place is hard to judge, so I'll try the compliment sandwich. Pro: their ranch dressing is very good. Odd compliment, but good ranch is worth the mention. Con's: They are slow, like really really slow. We've called a couple times in the afternoon for take out and been given a 2+ hour wait time. Tried dining in, still took forever. Not sure if they are so swamped by to go orders that they just can't be faster, or if there is a little too much mountain high vibe going on, but service is definitely lacking. Bottom bread of this sandwich: the pizza is good. There's a reason people wait for it, and that is probably what matters, but order in advance and don't order hungry or you will quickly find yourself hangry.
Omg! This place is 100% a gem! The quality of the food is amazing! The wings are incredible. The pizza is legit awesome! Best pizza in Flagstaff hands down and I’m super picky when it comes to wings and pizza. This place gets 5 stars for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Bread Sticks
Ok so the reviews are correct about this being a slow food experience. But the staff is friendly and this is top notch food (quality ingredients, fermented crust! And a house made gf crust for our daughter!); so bring good company, order a glass of wine, and enjoy the wait.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The best I’ve ever had.Thank you New Jersey Pizza Company!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food. Visiting from Phoenix for the weekend and will be returning just for this pizza! Service was excellent and everyone was so
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The meats they use on the pizza are tasty but the pie does them no justice. We ordered a 12" and a 16", both two toppings. The 16" was so greasy and limp that you could barely hold it, half of it went to waste. The 12" bottom crust wasn't as soaked, but still dripping everywhere. I'm not sure why it seemed so wet when there didn't appear to be that much cheese or sauce??We were quoted 35-40min for pickup and it ended up being an hour and 15 minutes. Prices are absurd for what you get. There's other pizza within a mile of this spot that's both better and cheaper.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
We ordered a 12" and a 16" pizza last night and we were told they would be ready in 40 minutes. We arrived in 40 minutes and the owner or manager was training an employee at the register. After five minutes standing there not acknowledged, he said "we will be right with you". He preceded to make a salad and after another 5 minutes.. the cash register girl asked our name and said it will be ready shortly. We paid for our pizzas ($54 for a small and a large) plus tip was $60. I then noticed the pizza guy putting ingredients on a pizza that looked like ours. Yes, after 50+ minutes, he was now making our pizza and it would be another 10 minutes. We ran an errand and came back in 10 minutes and it was just coming out of the oven. It was our first time trying and were excited to try the pizza after the reviews (even if the wait was long). The cheese was yellow and greasy (like low quality cheese), but the sausage was excellent as were the caramelized onions. The roasted red peppers were almost non-existent on both pizzas and the ricotta was weak (but not surprising since that's common at pizza places). We don't mind paying premium prices for premium pizza as it is our favorite, but for $60 we expected way more ingredients. Don't overcharge and then skimp on the ingredients (especially after making us wait an hour). Primary a take out place as the sit down area is not very nice and not one person was in there. Better cheese and more ingredients would make this place a success... the crust was really good on the 12", but a bit too floppy on the 16". I hope they make some adjustments as this pizza could be awesome. Not so much now.
We decided to try out a new pizza place and were shockingly disappointed. Delivery took 2 hours. Kitchens get busy, so a long wait can be excused as long as the end result is a delicious meal. This was far from it. We each tried a slice and the rest was tossed into the trash. The pizza was so greasy, that when held upright, it dripped onto the plate. Flavor-wise it was very bland and oddly tasted watered down. Maybe their other styles would have been a better choice. We also ordered wings. Thankfully, they were edible. Not great, but edible. They were very dry and tough.
Restaurantji Recommends
I truly pray that I receive an equally unprofessional response as the last guy who left an HONEST review.Before reading further just know you are better off with the 3 small pizzas from a lunchable.If an owner takes the time out of their day to respond to a review because they got their wittle feelings hurts, it’s because that review had truth.By far the worst food I’ve experienced in my life, and I’ve eaten bugs! This place is expensive and not at all worth it. For 2 16” pizzas and 2 dozen wings the bill came out to $120. Then the delivery itself was a 2 hr wait. At first I didn’t mind the wait because reviews mentioned a long wait but delicious taste. Delivery guy also said that the place is slow but good. Is New Jersey Pizza Co. paying everyone to lie? Or are they holding their families hostage? Did I miss the secret code to receive actual good food?God awful greasy limp pizza. The wings? Tiny, dry and too much vinegar. After everyone had a serving, not that it could be finished, this was all thrown into the trashIf you want your tastebuds to be offended and appalled then this is the trash for you. I’m convinced it’s children held captive being forced to cook the pizza because the pizza tastes like its secret ingredient is hatred.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place came recommended, and it did not disappoint. Hard to find at night time but worth the hunt. Had a pepperoni black olive pizza and let me tell you it was heavy on the black olives and pepperoni lol... anyway, I think everybody should check this place out ...I think they'll enjoy it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
The Pi is tasty and authentic without the Jersey Attitude LMAO...seriously tho great Pi and service. Walk in order was a bit long in service but we're were given choice of two free drinks items for the wait.Don't forget get to try the Gelato!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
Very tasty pizza with a great crust?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza. It reminded me of the pizza I grew up eating in NY. We can't wait to go back!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Supreme