11 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cool

“Our new favorite place. We've gone multiple times and their food is just so good. It's not your average pizza place, try it. You'll be able to tell how much thought went into the ingredients chosen and I'd be surprised if some of the items weren't an old family recipe, it's just so good right down to the salads. The owner is super nice as well and down to earth.“

“We had a great time celebrating a family birthday. The pizza was awesome.Vegetarian options: They had a make your own pizza with lots of veggies to choose from. They also have a vegetarian pizza.Wheelchair accessibility: We had two people with walkers and they were able to move around freely and safely.“

“This place is absolutely amazing. Thought it might have been overrated when I saw 4.9 stars. This place deserves what it has! Amazing pizza, no flop, sauces test fresh. Service was awesome, we had Mike- he was great. Ambiance is amazing as well, we were seated quickly. This pizza is top 10 I've ever had for sure. I'll be back!!“

“Came here to celebrate a birthday on a Saturday night, party of 8. We had reservations-- and a good thing because they were super busy! The pizza was absolutely delicious, as was the salads and garlic bread. We feasted!! The service was good, although it dropped off significantly about halfway through the meal. The whole table had to keep their eyes peeled/ participate in flagging down our waitress when it came time for dessert orders and then later the bill. We never did get an opportunity for a second beverage, but as I said, they were super busy, so I don't think that is their normal M.O. Parking was a BEAST. the parking lot is tiny, and Auburn being Auburn, there is very little parking elsewhere. We wound up parking up a S.F. style hill and had the joy of having to hike back up it after dinner. All in all, I'll be back. But I suggest off peak times!“

“Had the Coyote Supreme with a Caesar salad on the side. Sooooooooo, goood! Looking forward to going back again next week with the friends that weren't able to make it tonight. Service was great and the ambiance is on a more intimate scale than it's predecessor now is.“

“Went on a Wednesday night, party of two and got seated right away indoors. Great, quaint and dimly lit restaurant with some decent old jazz music and Dean Martin going on in the background. Servers kept re-upping their freshly made bread with balsamic/olive oil dip which is essential for an Italian restaurant and a great touch. Enjoyed some good wine, linguine & clam and spaghetti dishes which were excellent. Only thing I wish they would start doing is putting small candles or lamps at your table, can get a little dark in there. We'll definitely go again.“

“It took me a year or two to finally try this place after they replaced RT at the same location. I'm glad I finally did. The best way to describe this place is it's exactly like round table from the 80's and 90's. By that I mean, the toppings are real recognizable produce, the pizza is delicious and the all you can eat salad bar is spot on. The only thing missing is street fighter stand up game in the corner. Very nice family that runs it, they couldn't be more friendly or happy you're there.“

“The sourdough crust gives the pizza a unique flavor that I love. When I think of classic take-out pizza, this is exactly it and even more. Service is fantastic! Super friendly and personable-- the kind you only get with a local shop. The seating area has a great vibe too.“

“First time trying this place out. Brought my dad here for dinner. This inside is cooler than the outside. I ordered the bread sticks, pitcher of Coors light, medium taco pizza and a single salad. Funny story about the taco pizza is my dad and I used to get them back in the 90s from Godfathers(RIP) and it was sooooooo good. So I was excited to get one again because it had been a long time. This one was pretty good. Not a lot of toppings but still pretty good. Salad bar was solid. Beer was fresh, cold and served with ice cold glasses. The real winner though was the bread twists. Buttery, garlicy and cheese in it too. Loved them! Service was very friendly. Will totally be back. Can't wait to eat my leftovers today. Lol“

“Friendly, affordable and great ambiance. Easily the liveliest place around on a weekend night, and the pizza we had was tasty and well above our expectations as travelers. Nicely sprawling outdoor scene with live music (when we were there) behind the little building where they take your orders. Shout out to the hard working staff who got us our pies- with smiles - in next to no time despite beginning to run out of pizza!“

“With a doubt the best wood fired pizza in the area. If you have never had a wood fired pizza you have to try it, it's a game changer! Just don't be like the lady that wanted a refund because it was "burned", it's supposed to have charred parts, that's what sets it apart from "oven" pizzas and adds to the flavor. Staff is friendly and helpful, old town Newcastle charm at its best.“