Wow! Absolutely perfect evening. First time here and wish we had this restaurant at home so we could visit for date night couple of weeks. Service is top notch, and the food is amazing. Well done 511, you have created something special. Special shout out for having the perfect kids menu. There is truly something for everyone at 511.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Klessig
They were out of both the dishes I ordered. I felt like I was dining in a warehouse. Service wasn't bad, but the overall experience was not worth coming back to try it again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
R Hooper
Update 3/2024: they changed their mushroom polenta crostini to Polenta Crostini with Ragu. While I get the chef is an Italian chef, this isn’t an Italian restaurant. While it was good, won’t be re-ordering something I used to always order. Won’t remove a star for it as everything else was still on point. Please bring back the original polenta. Speghetti sauce & not formed polenta ruins it.12/2023:511 has always been my fave restaurant here. Went there tonight and had the best food ever. It’s always been great but this was so so good. It was on point, delicious and what I kept referring to as a “foodgasm”. Food was so good that I only remembered to take pics of the main course. Forgot the appetizer & deserts. Their drinks are perfect although there’s usually a long wait to get a drink there for some reason. The Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme desert needs to stay on the menu. It was heavenly. The Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed had a bit of crispiness on the top which took it up a few notches above any others I’ve ever tried. Nice touch.Appetizer (a repeat that I always get):POLENTA CROSTINI – Shiitake mushroom marsala, parmesan, herbsEntree:WOODFIRED FILET MIGNON (8oz) – Black truffle compound butter, crispy phyllo potatoes, broccolini & butter braised leeks, demi-glaceEntree:GRILLED STEELHEAD – Lobster risotto, grilled asparagus, beurre blanc 38Deserts:Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme– Cinnamon whipped cream“Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed, vanilla ice cream, spiced rum caramel
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cory Dickson
Super nice atmosphere,Great staff speedy service. Amazing menu.Rich and deep flavorefull food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Michael
I had a great steak and cocktail here! Not many places in Eureka are open Tuesday nights. If I were local I’d have wanted to come back to try more of the cocktail menu.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Glitterina Sassypants
The new menu is great. We had the Butterfish, Gnocchi, Carpaccio and oysters for apps. I had the Filet for dinner - It was amazing !!!Thanks, Chef Wiley ☆☆☆☆☆
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Smith
Everything was delicious! From the burger to the rib eye to the shrimp scampi! Service was great and attentive. We had a reservation for 5pm but probably would have been ok without. Great drink selection. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bernie Krystkowiak
I've never experienced such deliberate disrespect. We didn't have a reservation so were directed to the short leg of the bar which was fine (except for all the dirty glassware in front of us). We sat for 15" at least without so much as glance or word from anyone. It felt intentional whether it was or not and it was very upsetting.We live here but never would set foot in the place again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amy Smith
Great place for date night dinner, meeting up with friends or cocktails before dinner atThe Pearl next door. These are sister restaraunts and you can have the full menu in either area as they’re connected. Waitress was super friendly and the food was on point. I had the pork chop with mustard sauce, I was going out on a limb and was pleasantly surprised at the combo, the veggies were perfect, tricky when cooking potatoes and Brussels sprouts together, can’t wait to go back to try more of the menu. Crème brûlée was delish!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ceasar Salad
Rhonda Hooper
511 has always been my fave restaurant here. Went there tonight and had the best food ever. It’s always been great but this was so so good. It was on point, delicious and what I kept referring to as a “foodgasm”. Food was so good that I only remembered to take pics of the main course. Forgot the appetizer & deserts. Their drinks are perfect although there’s usually a long wait to get a drink there for some reason. The Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme desert needs to stay on the menu. It was heavenly. The Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed had a bit of crispiness on the top which took it up a few notches above any others I’ve ever tried. Nice touch.Appetizer (a repeat that I always get):POLENTA CROSTINI – Shiitake mushroom marsala, parmesan, herbsEntree:WOODFIRED FILET MIGNON (8oz) – Black truffle compound butter, crispy phyllo potatoes, broccolini & butter braised leeks, demi-glaceEntree:GRILLED STEELHEAD – Lobster risotto, grilled asparagus, beurre blanc 38Deserts:Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme– Cinnamon whipped cream“Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed, vanilla ice cream, spiced rum caramel
I actually ate in the connected lounge, which had the same menu. I recommend making a reservation for dinner. The food was spectacular, and I'm thinking about going there for dinner the next 2 nights to try other dishes. So many dishes made my mouth water! Too many food choices and not enough meals during my visit!Kid-friendliness: I didn't see many kids, except for 1 toddler. This is an upscale place, so well-behaved children would do best here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Duck Confit
joanna shofner
Delicious food and great customer service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
ryun shofner
The food was amazing and service was exceptional. We ate at the bar and the bartender was a rockstar!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan Coffelt
Great food and friendly service. Happy hour is the best in town and great variety of unique small plates. 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: North Bay Shellfish Kumamoto Oysters
K. Dely
My husband and I have come here a couple times because we love the food and have had great service every time. The menu does change some items seasonally which is great because you can try something new every time and we haven't been disappointed. The music can be louder at some tables so you can always ask to switch tables. My photos may show old menus but just wanted to give you an idea of the variety of food they offer. I always get the mussels and clams when available and my husband always gets the polenta to start. Yes expensive, but when the food makes you do a little happy dance in your chair it's worth it.
Wow! Absolutely perfect evening. First time here and wish we had this restaurant at home so we could visit for date night couple of weeks. Service is top notch, and the food is amazing. Well done 511, you have created something special. Special shout out for having the perfect kids menu. There is truly something for everyone at 511.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They were out of both the dishes I ordered. I felt like I was dining in a warehouse. Service wasn't bad, but the overall experience was not worth coming back to try it again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Update 3/2024: they changed their mushroom polenta crostini to Polenta Crostini with Ragu. While I get the chef is an Italian chef, this isn’t an Italian restaurant. While it was good, won’t be re-ordering something I used to always order. Won’t remove a star for it as everything else was still on point. Please bring back the original polenta. Speghetti sauce & not formed polenta ruins it.12/2023:511 has always been my fave restaurant here. Went there tonight and had the best food ever. It’s always been great but this was so so good. It was on point, delicious and what I kept referring to as a “foodgasm”. Food was so good that I only remembered to take pics of the main course. Forgot the appetizer & deserts. Their drinks are perfect although there’s usually a long wait to get a drink there for some reason. The Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme desert needs to stay on the menu. It was heavenly. The Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed had a bit of crispiness on the top which took it up a few notches above any others I’ve ever tried. Nice touch.Appetizer (a repeat that I always get):POLENTA CROSTINI – Shiitake mushroom marsala, parmesan, herbsEntree:WOODFIRED FILET MIGNON (8oz) – Black truffle compound butter, crispy phyllo potatoes, broccolini & butter braised leeks, demi-glaceEntree:GRILLED STEELHEAD – Lobster risotto, grilled asparagus, beurre blanc 38Deserts:Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme– Cinnamon whipped cream“Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed, vanilla ice cream, spiced rum caramel
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super nice atmosphere,Great staff speedy service. Amazing menu.Rich and deep flavorefull food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had a great steak and cocktail here! Not many places in Eureka are open Tuesday nights. If I were local I’d have wanted to come back to try more of the cocktail menu.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The new menu is great. We had the Butterfish, Gnocchi, Carpaccio and oysters for apps. I had the Filet for dinner - It was amazing !!!Thanks, Chef Wiley ☆☆☆☆☆
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was delicious! From the burger to the rib eye to the shrimp scampi! Service was great and attentive. We had a reservation for 5pm but probably would have been ok without. Great drink selection. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've never experienced such deliberate disrespect. We didn't have a reservation so were directed to the short leg of the bar which was fine (except for all the dirty glassware in front of us). We sat for 15" at least without so much as glance or word from anyone. It felt intentional whether it was or not and it was very upsetting.We live here but never would set foot in the place again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great place for date night dinner, meeting up with friends or cocktails before dinner atThe Pearl next door. These are sister restaraunts and you can have the full menu in either area as they’re connected. Waitress was super friendly and the food was on point. I had the pork chop with mustard sauce, I was going out on a limb and was pleasantly surprised at the combo, the veggies were perfect, tricky when cooking potatoes and Brussels sprouts together, can’t wait to go back to try more of the menu. Crème brûlée was delish!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ceasar Salad
511 has always been my fave restaurant here. Went there tonight and had the best food ever. It’s always been great but this was so so good. It was on point, delicious and what I kept referring to as a “foodgasm”. Food was so good that I only remembered to take pics of the main course. Forgot the appetizer & deserts. Their drinks are perfect although there’s usually a long wait to get a drink there for some reason. The Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme desert needs to stay on the menu. It was heavenly. The Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed had a bit of crispiness on the top which took it up a few notches above any others I’ve ever tried. Nice touch.Appetizer (a repeat that I always get):POLENTA CROSTINI – Shiitake mushroom marsala, parmesan, herbsEntree:WOODFIRED FILET MIGNON (8oz) – Black truffle compound butter, crispy phyllo potatoes, broccolini & butter braised leeks, demi-glaceEntree:GRILLED STEELHEAD – Lobster risotto, grilled asparagus, beurre blanc 38Deserts:Chocolate & Espresso pot de créme– Cinnamon whipped cream“Bananas Fosters” Cake– Brûléed, vanilla ice cream, spiced rum caramel
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I actually ate in the connected lounge, which had the same menu. I recommend making a reservation for dinner. The food was spectacular, and I'm thinking about going there for dinner the next 2 nights to try other dishes. So many dishes made my mouth water! Too many food choices and not enough meals during my visit!Kid-friendliness: I didn't see many kids, except for 1 toddler. This is an upscale place, so well-behaved children would do best here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Duck Confit
Delicious food and great customer service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was amazing and service was exceptional. We ate at the bar and the bartender was a rockstar!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and friendly service. Happy hour is the best in town and great variety of unique small plates. 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: North Bay Shellfish Kumamoto Oysters
My husband and I have come here a couple times because we love the food and have had great service every time. The menu does change some items seasonally which is great because you can try something new every time and we haven't been disappointed. The music can be louder at some tables so you can always ask to switch tables. My photos may show old menus but just wanted to give you an idea of the variety of food they offer. I always get the mussels and clams when available and my husband always gets the polenta to start. Yes expensive, but when the food makes you do a little happy dance in your chair it's worth it.