The Penny Ice Creamery

$ • Ice Cream, Caterers

Hours:
262 Mt Hermon Rd Suite 104, Scotts Valley
(831) 204-2523

Customers' Favorites

The Penny Ice Creamery Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.1 (87)
Restaurantji Rating

I've been wanting to go here for years because of their delicious-looking toasted marshmallow topping and we finally made it happen! Happy to say that Penny lived up to the hype! It was quiet for a Friday night because it was raining. Service was really nice. He let us try the flavors first. I was surprised by how gourmet the flavors were. I got the Banana Toffee and it tasted like those sweet, Asian baby bananas I used to eat as a kid. I liked the large toffee chunks. The flame-broiled...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

Super service and homemade ice cream and Sorbet. Unique flavors like Quince and Pumpkin Caramel. I had Fresh Mint Chocolate Chip. Luv the pieces of dark chocolate chip. I love that they offer small waffle cones, just enough to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Restaurantji Rating

I am obsessed with the toasted marshmallow fluff. Truly the star of the show. The mini scoop option was the perfect amount for me. More ice cream places should start offering this. I got 1 mini scoop of mint chip and 1 mini scoop of vanilla bean. Both were delicious. I definitely plan to go back to another penny ice creamery location in the future.

More Reviews(87)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
The Penny Ice Creamery
The Penny Ice Creamery
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 12 - 9:30PM
Tuesday 12 - 9:30PM
Wednesday 12 - 9:30PM
Thursday 12 - 9:30PM
Friday 12 - 10PM
Saturday 12 - 10PM
Sunday 12 - 9:30PM
Updated on: