Atomic Cowboy home of Denver Biscuit Co & Fat Sully's NY Pizza

3237 E Colfax Ave, Denver
(303) 339-3977

Recent Reviews

Omar Guzman

I'm picky about my food. There pizza is by far the best. Everything was hot fresh and delicious. Just the way I like it. Thank you and I will be back.

Tony Rodgers

Great place to get a slice of great NY style pizza, maybe some wings and drinks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots, Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza, Waffle Fries, Buffalo Wings

Ian Currie

Soggy

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Andrew Neely

One of the best spots for a slice in Denver!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dustin Rogers

Big delicious pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shiela J.

This place never disappoints. They have happy hour from 3-6 drinks are half off and some of thr appetizers are half off also. This is my pizza go to spot. For two people it was $32 before tip. Service is always great here everyone is friendly.

Ed Moreno

Last week I stopped and got a slice pepperoni. Was the worst slice I have had in years. Dry no cheese and burned crust.Ok everybody has a bad day.I stopped again today for another slice.Just as bad but even worse. Dry no cheese and 8 pieces of pepperoni.Been going there for years.Not anymore.Cost more get less

Mark F.

So, the pizza is good, the biscuit time is great too, but the bottom line is that they serve the best burger in Denver. First, it is the best burger. Second, it is $6 during HH and $9 the other times...ridiculous value. Pic below. I have raved about this in the past, so let me give you a new "level" talk. There are different levels of quality, as you can expect with any kitchen. On their worst day, the burger is in the conversation for the best in town still, but it is debatable. I would accept other people's lobbying on those days. On their GOOD days, there is NO argument. It is the best, hands down. Not even close. They have TV's with sports on, neutral music at an energetic level, and a massive bar area, where one side is a higher level (though I am a lower level person). They have fantastic beers on tap, and my go-to is Rare Trait. Oh, and they include IPA's on their HH specials. Score. Great selection of hot sauce, although you don't need ANYTHING on the burger. No hot sauce, ketchup, mustard, etc. The staff is always on point. Today, I had Mel and Jackie behind the bar, and my experience was flawless as usual. But, you sense the high level of service, along with cohesiveness with their colleagues no matter when you go. And, you should go there. Order the other stuff, and I am sure you will be happy. I will just stay in my groove of continuing to order my magical burger. Definitely recommend, and see you there.

Mason M.

Visiting from Houston and this genuinely is the top 5 pizza places I've ever had. Giant slice of pizza perfectly cooked and a generous amount of toppings. Best bang for your buck *chefs kiss*

Alexander Hernandez

Big slice of pizza ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel T.

Pizza is pretty good, but the service is poor.Do not trust their wait times - they hadn't even started the pizza when I got there to pick up when I was told to pick it up. Not a single apology from anyone - they have no customer service skills.UPSATE: Management reached out to make things right, which is greatly appreciated!

Amy Koon

I’ve heard wonderful things about this place. Unfortunately it did not live up to those statements… party of 6 ordered loaded 2 garlic knots, 2 chicken sandwiches and a giant pizza. The garlic knots were absolutely amazing!!!! Both chicken sandwiches were inedible and overcooked the waitress was gracious enough to remake them and said the next ones wouldn’t be burned… unfortunately that wasn’t the case after 4 chicken sandwiches we faced the music that edible chicken sandwiches were not in the future. The giant pizza showed up and there was a giant blonde hair baked into it ? we were absolutely done at that point. The manager did comp all the food which was expected considering the circumstances, we paid for our drinks and have no intentions of returning. We were told the cooking issue was because of visiting cook staff. Our visit lasted 1.5 hours and we all left starving. Definitely would not recommend. The staff we dealt with was pleasant and tried to be helpful but did not make up for the terrible experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots

Matt Meow

Thems some big pizzas - and I like big pizzas. Really though...some good thin pizza to highlight your favorite toppings. Folding is required!

Food: 5

Stay17327905058

I ordered a large red pizza to go with sausage, and all I can say is it was just not a very good pizza. It was just okay and not very flavorful.

Dawn Reid

I ordered chicken wings from this place and they were bloody and raw. This is the aftermath of what I picked away. hopefully I do not get food poisoning.

Food: 1

Load More

Atomic Cowboy home of Denver Biscuit Co & Fat Sully's NY Pizza

3237 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80206
(303) 339-3977