Andy's Frozen Custard
$ • Ice Cream
Hours:
3505 River Point Pkwy, Sheridan
(720) 409-3836
About Andy's Frozen Custard
Customers' Favorites
Andy's Frozen Custard Reviews
Share your opinion about Andy's Frozen Custard
Went last night for a cookie casanova jack hammer + pecans. Got a jackhammer with only pecans👎🏼 complete disappointment. Wasn't gonna waste our time going back to have it fixed.
TRIED THE PUMPKIN PIE CONCRETE LAST NIGHT!!!
1. It's actually made with an entire blended slice of real pumpkin pie that they bake in-store
2. It looked nothing like this picture and we didn't take any pics of our own lol (it basically looked like a cup of beige blended custard. It had chunks when you ate it, but you couldn't really see them)
3. It was extremely rich and decadent, I couldn't even finish my "small"
4. You could upgrade to a jackhammer that has...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 11:30PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 11:30PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 11PM |
People in Sheridan Also Viewed
Andy's Frozen Custard is known for having the best frozen custard, with a wide variety of mix-in choices. Customers are willing to travel 30 miles to enjoy the custard, which is described as creamier than clouds and thicker than Snickers, with the right amount of sweetness. One of the highlights is the friendly service, as customers appreciate how the staff goes above and beyond. Recently, employees have demonstrated their kindness by replacing a dropped cone at no charge, which shows their commitment to customer satisfaction.
The general manager, Jacob, receives praise for his friendliness and effective communication, which contributes to the success of the store. Customers also commend the busy work of the employees, including Alondra and Hector, who help create a welcoming atmosphere.
Customers express appreciation for the well-run and impressive store, stating they plan to be lifelong customers and recommend the location to others. They enjoy the delicious flavors, such as chocolate and the well-loved apple pie sundae and butter pecan. Some customers have noted that the music can be too loud at times, but overall, the experience is highly positive.
Andy's Frozen Custard has been in Colorado for a while, and it continues to impress. Customers love the ever-changing flavors of Cement, like the small pumpkin pie concrete that includes real chunks of pumpkin. The customer service is fantastic, and the store is noted for being kid-friendly and wheelchair accessible. The enthusiasm for returning to Andy's Frozen Custard remains high, despite any dietary concerns.