Went there this year for St. Patrick's Day 2024. I have been there before for other St. Patrick's Day Celebrations. But this time I was very disappointed in the cornbeef sandwich. The bread fell apart and was very dry.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Richard A.
Came here for the first time after living in the area for 30 years. It was a fundraiser and was pleasantly surprised how good the food was. This is a local establishment that has many loyal customers, especially during Saint Patrick. They had eggplant rotini , it was delicious. They also had stuffed mushrooms. That were very good. They also had two versions of stuff, potato skins, and breaded fried fried chicken. They were good. Nice small local place to gather and eat good bar food.
Al Nyack
Wish we skipped to the entree. The scallops for the specials were perfectly cooked and the blackened scallops over rice was really good. However, the fried scallops on fries with a side of generic slaw for $25 was a bit overpriced. Our appetizer and mixed drink were blah and the waitress could not have cared less (never asked how the food was, made sure all was good, and practically tossed out check into the table at the end). This isn't an Irish pub, it's a typical (and mediocre) restaurant bar with average food dressed in Irish garb at best. The only Irish food that I noted on the menu was a corned beef sandwich. Paid $100 for humdrum. Oh well, lesson learned.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Christine Randall
Such a cute Irish pub! Everybody is very friendly and the food is absolutely delicious! Highly recommend the ribs. I get them every time I go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hallina Schrock
Homey atmosphere, excellent service, delicious food. Great family environment. Would recommend and come again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenni F.
For us, Tommy's Sullivan's Cafe was a PERFECT solution. We went to hear carolers at nearby Stony Creek Brewing. We had a big group (12) and about half an hour prior to the carolers finishing (around 6pm on a Saturday night) we all agreed: we were famished. And we wanted to keep hanging out. I did a quick search for a spot nearby that was casual and had great American fare (burgers, wraps, sandwiches, and the like). Within minutes, my husband called Tommy's and was told they had a big party wrapping up and the would hold the table for us. It was destiny! With a decidedly low-key vibe, this place was abuzz with holiday frivolity. People were welcoming and it was palpable that high spirits were abounding! Now to the food and drink! All the men in our party opted for black-and-tans and the ladies had J. Lohr cabernet, sold by the glass or the bottle. I enjoyed a pastrami sandwich on rye and sweet potato fries. Both were outstanding. Two members of the party (including my husband) ordered their meatloaf, which is apparently one of the most popular items on the menu. Both of them cleaned their plates...which is saying something because the portions are generous! The service was great...by that I mean friendly, attentive, accurate, and collegial. Next time we are in that area, we will definitely go back.
J H
Great food, extremely friendly staff. Atmosphere was awesome! Loved it!
I was surprised by my bill to find out that two seltzers (just seltzer) cost 12 dollars. I don't recall the seltzer saying nice things about my hair or doing my taxes for me.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
John
Quick drink on Thanksgiving day. In n out. Great people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pav W.
A real old-fashioned Irish pub! This place reminds me of Ireland, though it's in the center of Branford. We sat in a comfortable booth. I can't say it was exactly quiet as folks were having a fun time at the bar, but service was great and the waiter was friendly and prompt. My Ceasar salad was delicious with homemade croutons and well prepared dressing. The clam chowder was fresh and filling. By the time I ate my sandwich, I was full, but the meat was tender and the cheese and fried onions added that melt in your mouth flavor. Everyone loves a good Irish pub, so make sure you try this place if you haven't already.
Our favorite Irish cafe for Lunch! More than generous portions ! And great Drinks. You can sit inside or out on their lovely patio.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Authentic You
The best Irish pub in all of CT. The food, beer and people are all top notch. Feels like home every time you go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pam H.
Ok so I might have forgotten to take pics before we dug in... We were in town for a quick fb Marketplace pickup and had no idea where to go. Was in the mood for pub food so we landed here. The patio was a really nice spot - place was empty because we arrived at 4 for dinner. The food is very reasonably priced and our server was wonderful, food came out quickly. It's nothing special or amazing but it was good enough. My son enjoyed his tenders and my crab cakes were all crab next to no breading at all. Where I think they could improve dramatically is in the sauces. The wasabi dipping sauce for the shrimp was very sour and had no real depth; same for the crab cake sauce. It was just a sour mustard flavored sauce. The cheesy garlic bread was a tad too dry and the butter garlic mixture was just off somehow - it sat on top of the bread and the garlic was a little overpowering after the fact. With some minor tweets I think the food could be really quite good. Regardless, if you're looking for a simple meal and a drink, this place is just fine.
Anthony Calabrese
I lived in Guilford all my life and passed by this restaurant many, many times. I never went in. Until, one of my out-of-town colleagues suggested it. So I had to go. I had one of the best Corned Beef Rubens around. The bartender was super nice. I went for lunch. I can't comment about other food items, but I'm definitely going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Therese Dube
I have never had a bad meal or dessert here. The staff are wonderful! I visit here often!
Went there this year for St. Patrick's Day 2024. I have been there before for other St. Patrick's Day Celebrations. But this time I was very disappointed in the cornbeef sandwich. The bread fell apart and was very dry.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Came here for the first time after living in the area for 30 years. It was a fundraiser and was pleasantly surprised how good the food was. This is a local establishment that has many loyal customers, especially during Saint Patrick. They had eggplant rotini , it was delicious. They also had stuffed mushrooms. That were very good. They also had two versions of stuff, potato skins, and breaded fried fried chicken. They were good. Nice small local place to gather and eat good bar food.
Wish we skipped to the entree. The scallops for the specials were perfectly cooked and the blackened scallops over rice was really good. However, the fried scallops on fries with a side of generic slaw for $25 was a bit overpriced. Our appetizer and mixed drink were blah and the waitress could not have cared less (never asked how the food was, made sure all was good, and practically tossed out check into the table at the end). This isn't an Irish pub, it's a typical (and mediocre) restaurant bar with average food dressed in Irish garb at best. The only Irish food that I noted on the menu was a corned beef sandwich. Paid $100 for humdrum. Oh well, lesson learned.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Such a cute Irish pub! Everybody is very friendly and the food is absolutely delicious! Highly recommend the ribs. I get them every time I go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Homey atmosphere, excellent service, delicious food. Great family environment. Would recommend and come again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For us, Tommy's Sullivan's Cafe was a PERFECT solution. We went to hear carolers at nearby Stony Creek Brewing. We had a big group (12) and about half an hour prior to the carolers finishing (around 6pm on a Saturday night) we all agreed: we were famished. And we wanted to keep hanging out. I did a quick search for a spot nearby that was casual and had great American fare (burgers, wraps, sandwiches, and the like). Within minutes, my husband called Tommy's and was told they had a big party wrapping up and the would hold the table for us. It was destiny! With a decidedly low-key vibe, this place was abuzz with holiday frivolity. People were welcoming and it was palpable that high spirits were abounding! Now to the food and drink! All the men in our party opted for black-and-tans and the ladies had J. Lohr cabernet, sold by the glass or the bottle. I enjoyed a pastrami sandwich on rye and sweet potato fries. Both were outstanding. Two members of the party (including my husband) ordered their meatloaf, which is apparently one of the most popular items on the menu. Both of them cleaned their plates...which is saying something because the portions are generous! The service was great...by that I mean friendly, attentive, accurate, and collegial. Next time we are in that area, we will definitely go back.
Great food, extremely friendly staff. Atmosphere was awesome! Loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shepards Pie, Corned Beef Sandwich, Meatloaf
I was surprised by my bill to find out that two seltzers (just seltzer) cost 12 dollars. I don't recall the seltzer saying nice things about my hair or doing my taxes for me.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Quick drink on Thanksgiving day. In n out. Great people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A real old-fashioned Irish pub! This place reminds me of Ireland, though it's in the center of Branford. We sat in a comfortable booth. I can't say it was exactly quiet as folks were having a fun time at the bar, but service was great and the waiter was friendly and prompt. My Ceasar salad was delicious with homemade croutons and well prepared dressing. The clam chowder was fresh and filling. By the time I ate my sandwich, I was full, but the meat was tender and the cheese and fried onions added that melt in your mouth flavor. Everyone loves a good Irish pub, so make sure you try this place if you haven't already.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our favorite Irish cafe for Lunch! More than generous portions ! And great Drinks. You can sit inside or out on their lovely patio.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best Irish pub in all of CT. The food, beer and people are all top notch. Feels like home every time you go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ok so I might have forgotten to take pics before we dug in... We were in town for a quick fb Marketplace pickup and had no idea where to go. Was in the mood for pub food so we landed here. The patio was a really nice spot - place was empty because we arrived at 4 for dinner. The food is very reasonably priced and our server was wonderful, food came out quickly. It's nothing special or amazing but it was good enough. My son enjoyed his tenders and my crab cakes were all crab next to no breading at all. Where I think they could improve dramatically is in the sauces. The wasabi dipping sauce for the shrimp was very sour and had no real depth; same for the crab cake sauce. It was just a sour mustard flavored sauce. The cheesy garlic bread was a tad too dry and the butter garlic mixture was just off somehow - it sat on top of the bread and the garlic was a little overpowering after the fact. With some minor tweets I think the food could be really quite good. Regardless, if you're looking for a simple meal and a drink, this place is just fine.
I lived in Guilford all my life and passed by this restaurant many, many times. I never went in. Until, one of my out-of-town colleagues suggested it. So I had to go. I had one of the best Corned Beef Rubens around. The bartender was super nice. I went for lunch. I can't comment about other food items, but I'm definitely going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I have never had a bad meal or dessert here. The staff are wonderful! I visit here often!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5