18 Best Caterers near East Haven

1
Deli

Deli Deli • $
453 Short Beach Rd, East Haven

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni Prima Pizza
Ricotta Eggplant Pizza
Tomato Basil Garlic
Bacon Egg & Cheese
French Fries Small
Onion Ring Small
Eggplant Parm
Chicken Parm
Italian Combo

“It's a local deli...several men gather around a table having coffee and talking...the owner and his family along with Mike, the best cook/chef in town. Chicken Parm, Eggplant Parm to die for...everything is delicious and always greeted with a smile!“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Old World Pizza Truck Caterers • $$
163 Foster St, New Haven - 3.31 miles

“This was simply the best experience we could have imagined. They were super easy to deal with to set our event up. On the day of our event the staff arrived and literally took care of everything. The pizza was outstanding and everyone couldn't stop talking about how delicious it was. The staff was top notch, super friendly and made sure everyone was enjoying the pizza. They also cleaned up everything before they left. A 10/10 experience. Will definitely use them again in the future.“

5 Superb43 Reviews
Bill Miller's Castle Caterers • $$$
834 E Main St, Branford - 6.58 miles

“Our wedding day at Bill Miller’s Castle was absolutely perfect, thanks to Victoria and her exceptional staff. Choosing Bill Miller’s Castle for your wedding venue is one of the wisest decisions you can make. Victoria's guidance and expertise were invaluable in planning and executing our dream wedding. She was transparent throughout the process, offered excellent suggestions when we needed guidance, and presented a wide range of options and ideas to bring our vision to life. Victoria's passion and enthusiasm made the wedding planning process enjoyable and stress-free.Our reception was catered by the in-house La Luna restaurant, and it exceeded our expectations. Our guests were delighted with the flavorful and generously portioned meals, with many proclaiming it as the best wedding food they've ever had, especially praising the prime rib.Of course, Bill Miller’s Castle's most significant allure is its breathtaking atmosphere. Every room and corner is filled with historical charm and intricate details that create a truly unique experience. We've been to other weddings at venues attempting to replicate Bill Miller’s ambiance, but none could match Bill Miller’s "Wow" factor.The facilities at Bill Miller’s were outstanding, clean, easily accessible, and well-maintained, allowing for seamless planning and visualization of our big day. The venue is highly regarded among local wedding vendors, and the staff's professionalism and dedication shine through. When you choose Bill Miller’s Castle, you have an entire team committed to making your day more perfect than you could have imagined.Choosing Bill Miller’s Castle for our wedding was undoubtedly the best decision we made. Every expectation was not just met but exceeded. Our heartfelt thanks to Victoria and her team.Alex and Heather“

5 Superb38 Reviews
Oak Beach Bar + Grill Bar •
291 Captain Thomas Blvd, West Haven - 4.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Cut Pork Chop
Fried Artichokes
Ricotta Dumplings
Steak and Cheese
Veggie Stir Fry
Chicken Wings
Broccoli Rabe
Petite Filet
Beef Burger
Fish Tacos

“They let us in and were so kind to us 15 minutes before closing when everyone else was already shut down for the night. We were on a roadtrip from Boston home to NJ and very hungry. The place is modern, new, clean, and welcoming. The food was very good. We had fried artichokes, steak tip tacos, stuffed clams, Caesar salad, Buffalo wings, and meatloaf. Everything is made fresh. Nothing was frozen. Portions were large so we took home leftovers. Pricing is affordable. The waitress was so gracious and attentive. She even brought us drink refills before we even asked. If you find yourself in the area I recommend you try this place.“

4.7 Superb83 Reviews
Amarante's Sea Cliff Caterers • $$$
62 Cove St, New Haven - 2.57 miles

“My wife and I just got married here this past weekend (09/03/23). Right front the start Kayleigh was amazing, got right back to us answering all of our crazy questions. She was on point durning all the months of preparation. We met Jose, banquet manager, at our private taste testing. Wonderful. After we ate he sat with us and answered every question we had. A week before the wedding, we brought all of our decorations to them. We met Kayleigh and Jose. They went threw all of our stuff and labeled so there were no mistakes. We set up how we wanted things and Jose took pictures so he would know. The day before the wedding we had the rehearsal. Sorta disorganized. We knew there was another wedding, but we were told to get there at a certain time so it wouldn’t be an issue. Had to move to a different area because it was an issue. Didn’t want my fiancé to know, but I was getting nervous about the wedding day. The next day we arrived for the wedding. As soon as we got there we were greeted by Ivan. He was absolutely superb!! He made that night perfect. He got us food, he always asked us if everything is ok and even went to the bar for us!!! He was amazing. The ceremony through the end of the reception flowed perfect. Right on with everything. If there were issues, which I don’t believe there was, they handled them perfect. Every single person that attended told us how beautiful the place was and that it was one of the best weddings they have ever been to. At the end of the night, Ivan packed up all the left over food for us. Told us to go and enjoy the rest of the evening and come back tomorrow for all your stuff. The next day we went to get all of our stuff and it was perfectly packaged, set aside for us. There are so many places out there that charge a fortune and it is just ok. This is the opposite, the pricing was fair, and you get 10 times more than what you paid for. Very Highly Recommended!“

4.6 Superb56 Reviews
Cascade Fine Catering Caterers • $$$
480 Sherman Ave, Hamden - 8.85 miles

“I had my daughter’s baby shower on March 9 2024 Sylvana was a wonderful person to work with she made sure the table settings were according to the theme. Gave us enough time to decorate before the event. The food and pastries were great all the guests raved about it. I recommend Cascade I give it 5 stars“

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
Spuds Your Way Caterers • $$
3500 Whitney Ave, Hamden - 9.7 miles

“The food is delicious. I personally like the fries (good blend of spices that's tasty but not too spicy), mozzarella sticks, and chicken tenders. My wife loves the potato skins and burgers. We usually get takeout with curbside pickup and the food is ready really fast with great service.“

4.6 Superb38 Reviews
La Cucina Prepared Meals & Catering Caterers • $
193 Foxon Rd, North Branford - 4.12 miles

“I had them cater a family Christmas party. Staff was very courteous and helpful placing the order and determining amount we needed for number of guests. Pick up was prompt,everything was ready and hot boxes they have for transport worked great. Personally I thought the food was very good,we had chicken stuffed with spinach,cavatelli Bolognese and stuff filet of sole ,mixed veggies,salad. The overwhelming majority liked the food,couple of complainer but can't please everyone. Overall it was a very positive experience and I'd use them again if and when I'm involved in planning a event.“

4.8 Superb21 Reviews
Durante's Pasta Pasta • $$
78 Fenwick St, West Haven - 5.56 miles

“My favorite family small business, Angelo and staff make this pasta with love…fresh and delicious..I been getting my pasta from them for years from homemade meatballs, chicken cutlets, cheese, meats and homemade sauces.Parking: Street parking in front and on side street“

4.7 Superb25 Reviews

10
Zoi's

Zoi's Caterers • $
63 Grove St, New Haven - 3.31 miles

“Where do I start... I'm a huge oatmeal fan and this by far is the BEST oatmeal I have had at a restaurant. Everything here is cooked to order and is so fresh. The egg sandwich was so delicious with bacon and caramelized onions on pumpernickel bread. It was amazing... And I'm definitely coming back. If you are in New Haven looking for great food then you must come here!“

4.4 Superb65 Reviews
B & B Deli Deli • $
1440 Dixwell Ave, Hamden - 5.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ham & Cheese Sub or Wrap

“This place is EXCELLENT! I started coming here recently and am I glad I found this place. Perfectly balanced subs on the Perfect bread. An old-school sub that doesn't try to hard, it's simply done right!! I'm going to miss this place when I go south. But will definitely stop by when I visit.“

4.9 Superb17 Reviews
Edibolic Kitchen - Food Delivery Service Health Food • $
867 Jones Hill Rd, West Haven - 5.26 miles

“THE difference between me living a healthier life and not. Edibolic is delicious, interesting, and has great variety. There is not one week I dont see a couple of meals that are different from what I would normally eat, that I WANT to eat. Nutritious balanced meals that allow me not to have to worry about what fast food I'm going to wait in line only to regret eating later. The prices are better than fast food , while the food is obviously healthier. I really cant say enough good things and wish I had found this company earlier. I say this with allsincerity, let Edibolic Kitchen help you live a better, healthier life.“

4.8 Superb17 Reviews
Chefs A L'Orange Caterers Caterers • $$
316 Racebrook Rd, Orange - 6.97 miles

“Cathy , Connor & the chef AL Orange just catered our wedding . on a scale (1--10 ) , they would get a 12+. a great experience . the communication between Cathy and us was wonderful. the food tasting , at our house was ideal. the day of our wedding , the crew arrived early and set up the food table and the bar. the service crew was outstanding . Cathy could not have been more attentive. the food was very good. chef a l orange was professional - taking care of our guests as well as us. it was a wonderful wedding and we were happy we had Cathy & Connor as our caterers. aug / 2022 . thank you. JDS/CT“

4.8 Superb16 Reviews
Small Kitchen Big Taste | CT Catering & Events Caterers • $$
420 Sackett Point Rd, North Haven - 5.85 miles

“SKBT catered out backyard wedding for 72 guests, effortlessly in the pouring rain this past weekend. The service from the first planning stages was outstanding. They transformed our home into a wonderland when we had to move indoors for cocktail hour. The grazing tables were fantastic, artfully displayed and so enticing! The dinner was cooked onsite , fresh and delicious. If a caterer can prepare halibut and keep it moist and tasty , you know you are onto a good thing! I cant recommend SKBT highly enough.“

5 Superb12 Reviews
Chestnut Fine Foods & Confections Fine Dining • $$
1012 State St, New Haven - 3.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Linzer
Bakery

“Chestnut fine foods has served New Haven for so long with such kindness, mastery and grace.Patricia is the kindest person, and Fred is a master chef, second to none.From crab cakes with sauce to die for, quiche and eggplant parmigiana that is exquisite, to other dishes available for catering!They also have a selection ofsandwiches on homemade bread, soup of the day and the best is for last…The cookies are a fan favorite, but be sure to check out the other sweets like their signature butter finger chewyYou will not find a ‘finer’ place to eat in New Haven! The staff is incredible, bon appetite !“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Stellato's Deli & Catering Deli • $$
King Acres Plaza, 69 State St, North Haven - 7.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Panini

“Went to Stellato's Deli today to grab lunch. Ended up ordering the 3.1 Panini, chicken was tender, thin sliced prosciutto with tomato, mozzarella and pesto. Great sandwich, full of great flavors , hit the spot. First time visit, will be back. Plenty of free parking in front of Deli.“

4.5 Superb26 Reviews
Hill’s Kitchen Soul Food • $$
552 Congress Ave, New Haven - 3.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Banana Pudding
Fish Sandwich
Mac & Cheese
Pepper Steak
Rasta Pasta
Add Chicken
Egg Rolls
Fries
Wings
Fish

“Incredible homemade deliciousness! Wow. This was our first time there and we asked for whatever they had ready. We got two dinner plates that included: ribs, shredded chicken, sweet potatoes, macaroni and chess, collard greens, onion and cornbread. Just wow. Clearly homemade from some longtime family recipes. 5/5 stars and then some. HIGHLY, HIGHLY RECOMMEND.“

4.3 Superb49 Reviews
Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Shop • $
159 Temple St, New Haven - 3.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Butter Pecan
Strawberry

“Ben & Jerry's in New Haven, Connecticut is a family-run, locally owned and operated ice cream shop that has been serving up delicious scoops since 2012. The shop is located in the heart of downtown New Haven, just a short walk from Yale University and the New Haven Green.The Ben & Jerry's in New Haven is a popular spot for locals and tourists alike. The shop is always busy, but the staff is friendly and efficient, and they move the line quickly.The wide variety of unique and creative ice cream flavors, including vegan and dairy-free options.The high-quality ingredients and delicious taste of the ice cream.The friendly and efficient staff.The convenient location in the heart of downtown New Haven.“

4.4 Superb24 Reviews
Loading...
map Map