Paul & Eddy's Pizza

1630 Whitney Ave #1919, Hamden
(203) 230-9396

Recent Reviews

Michael Alogna

I have to say I thoroughly enjoy the pizza from this place, been going there for years. It is really unfortunate that there is one person that works there that is beyond rude when you call on the phone to place an order. I apologize for putting you out, but I thought it was your job to fill customer requests for food.

Nicole Carpenter

Best pizza and service, ever! I was able to email over my order since it was a large one for my entire office and it was so efficient. The pizza is fantastic and delivery was right on time! Always my go-to!

Amanda Sousa

BEST. PIZZA. EVER!! We are obsessed and get their pizza once a week without fail! The texture of the crust is perfect and it’s just overall amazing! Sometimes pizza can be thinner or thicker than normal and can be a little burnt in some places so consistency isn’t always there but it’s still so yummy so to us the pros definitely outweigh cons! Highly recommend!

R G

So I moved to Connecticut from New Jersey last year in October and I’ve been looking for new pizza places to try. I’ve had some of the well-known places in the New Haven area which were pretty good. I wanted to try and find a good place close to where I live and driving past I saw it and decided to stopped in. Up to this point I would have to say Paul and Eddie’s has the BEST PIZZA that I’ve tried since I’ve moved here. Moving forward they will be my definitive go to when I’m craving the best pizza in the area.

Taylor Hauck

This place just hits the spot every time I go. The pizza is made fresh and the staff are super friendly.

Mike Barselau

Great pizza, wraps and salads. Nice people, reasonable priced.

Alexander Fretheim

The floppiest, sloppiest pizza crust you will ever have! This pie is right out of an episode of Scooby Doo... Actually tastes great, but the crust has reached such an incredible level of floppiness and weakness that it can actually stress you out a little: you're playing chess with your pizza! Atmosphere is a small family-owned pizza parlor, and the service is as New England as it gets.

Mallory

Placed an order for delivery and it was out for an hour after being made. When I called to follow up and see where the pizza was they told me there's nothing they can do because they have one driver. That's understandable but they had me on hold for 5 minutes to tell me that. Will not be ordering from them again. After another half hour I called back and was told again he’s “almost there”. At this point I offered to pick up a pizza that had not been sitting in the driver car for over an hour, or to bring them the cold pizza once it arrived for a refund. They opted out of fixing their mistake and making a new pizza for pick up and said they’d refund me then hung up.

Bootleg shorty Nolan

Very good pizza I will go back in future.good and friendly service

Brittany Landon

Great pizza and love the “turnover”! Food tastes great and is always delivered quick and hot!

Chad V.

Solid New Haven style thin slice. Bright flavorful sauce and good char on edges and bottom. Would happily return.

Lauren Schaffer

I ordered 2 slices to go, I noticed the box was light but was in a hurry. When I later opened the box, I saw they were very small and paper thin, no joke, the dough was completely overstretched. I can see in the pictures that's not how they usually make their pizza, so why did you sell these to me. I was out on business and didn't have time to go back or get something else. Just disappointed. If they were upfront about it I wouldn't be writing this, it's the fact that they sent me off with them like nothing was wrong. Shady.

Linda S.

Picked up 8 large pizza's for the QU Big Event students who were helping out at Grace & St Peter's Episcopal Church in the center of town. Thank you to a great QU crew!! Pizza was a big hit too! Thank you Paul & Eddy's!!

Joseph White

I LOVE PAUL AND EDDY'S PIZZA ITS A FAMILY SETTING

GOD Sent

One of my favorite pizza places to eat

Load More